• Illinois
  • Chicago
  • Old Fifth

Old Fifth

(312) 374-1672
  • 1027 W Madison St, Chicago, IL 60607
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American (New) ,  Gastropub ,  Pizza
  • $$$$$
(312) 374-1672
  • Menu
  • Old Fifth Special
    • The Fifth Ward $27

      thin crust, pepperoni, sausage, ham, apple-wood smoked bacon, salami with mozzarella, parmesan, provolone

    • Holden's Heater $22.5

      thin crust, pizza sauce hot with chili flakes, spicy italian sausage, and topped with giardiniera

    • Double Decker Pepperoni $25

      the old fifth special sauce, stacked! of course only available in 16" anything smaller just wouldn't be enough

    • Kentucky Pizza-Q $21

      thin crust, uncle dougie's bbq pulled pork, chihuahua, aged cheddar, roasted peppers, red onion and cilantro

    • Low Fat Veggie $19

      for the health conscious - thin crust, ricotta, skim-milk mozzarella, onion, green peppers, mushrooms

  • Create Your Masterpiece
    • Crust - Thin $13.45

    • Crust - Double Decker $17.95

    • Cheese

      regular or low fat. yes, old fifth special cheese blend comes in a reduced fat version

    • Meats $1.95

      large slice pepperoni, italian sausage, apple-wood smoked bacon, turkey sausage

    • Veggies $1.95

      fresh green peppers, fresh jalapenos, black olives, tomato, basil, cremini mushrooms, onions, baby spinach, garlic rubbed crust

    • Genius $2.5

      chevre goat cheese, roasted pork shoulder, prosciutto, grilled chicken, salami, grilled artichokes

  • Tasty Treats
    • House Batched Smore's $9

      fresh graham crackers, home made marshmallow, raspberries, mint and chocolate sauce

    • Griddled Nutella Pound Cake $8

      vanilla ice-cream, toasted hazelnuts and a nutella-caramel sauce

    • Crushed Chocolate $6

      (gf). crushed milk chocolate, semi-sweet & belgium chocolates with roasted salted nuts

  • Snacks
    • Orange And Extra Virgin Olive Oil Marinated Olives $7

      pit-in olives, orange peel, fresh thyme, extra virgin olive oil, toasted baguette

    • Truffle Fries $4

      (gf). fresh cut fries, parmesan, fresh herbs, truffle aioli

    • Jalapeño Fries $4

      (gf). fresh cut fries, jalapeños, queso fresco

    • Loaded Fries $9

      (gf). shredded aged white cheddar, braised oxtail

    • Salty Nuts And Dry Fruits $6

      (gf). almonds, pecans, pistachios, peanuts, dried cherries, blueberries, currants, apricots

    • Charcuterie And Cheese Plate $16

      assorted meats, artisanal cheeses, crunchy baguette, gherkins, italian parsley, whiskey mustard, seasonal marmalade

  • Shared Bar Bites
    • Brazilian Nachos $13

      (gf). slow roasted pork shoulder, fried tortillas, aged white cheddar, chihuahua cheese, avocado puree, brazilian black beans, pico de gallo, jalapeno, confit of onions, chipotle-lime sauce, shredded lettuce

    • Chicken Wings $10

      choice of hot, chili-soy or ancho-bourbon bbq sauce

    • 50/50 Sliders $12.5

      fifty/fifty blend of apple-wood bacon and grass fed beef, aged white cheddar, roma tomato, crispy onion

    • Apple-Wood Bacon And Blue Cheese Sliders $12.5

      grass fed beef blended with point reyes blue cheese and apple-wood smoked bacon, baby arugula, roma tomato, black pepper aioli

    • Formerly Known As "Tots" $9

      (gf). potato "tot" stuffed, apple-wood smoked bacon and reny picot camembert cheese, black pepper aioli. so good, you may not want to share!

    • Pancetta Cavatappi & Cheese $9

      béchamel, aged white cheddar, gruyere and parmesan, pancetta, cavatappi pasta

    • Hefeweizen Hummus $10

      puree of chick peas with hw reduction, lemon juice, garlic, tahini and olive oil; with english cucumber, baby carrots, asparagus, breakfast radish, grilled flat pita

    • Seared Ahi Tuna $15

      ahi tuna, napa cabbage slaw, daikon sprouts, pickled ginger, fried pickled ginger, wasabi, lime-sriracha sauce

  • Handhelds
    Served With House Fries Except For Fish Tacos
    • Ancho-Bourbon Pulled Pork $12.5

      slow roasted pork shoulder, ancho- bourbon bbq sauce, urban slaw, on a pretzel bun

    • The "BCS" $12.5

      blackened chicken, crisp romaine, aged white cheddar, avocado, tomatoes, chipotle aioli, ciabatta round

    • Blackened Fish Tacos

      chipotle aioli, flour tortilla, lemon vinaigrette, white cabbage, corn and black bean salsa, pico de gallo.

    • Blackened Fish Tacos $13

      tilapia

    • Blackened Fish Tacos $23

      halibut

  • Burgers
    Served With House Fries Except For Fish Tacos Add A Fried Egg For $2
    • The Old Fifth Burger $14

      special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, aged white cheddar, horseradish sauce, crispy onions, baby arugula, tomatoes, brioche burger bun

    • You're My Boy Bleu $14

      special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, point reyes blue cheese, apple-wood smoked bacon, baby arugula, tomato, black pepper aioli, brioche burger bun

    • B.Y.O. Cheese Burger $12.5

      special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, turkey, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, onions, & choice of cheese white and yellow cheddar, provolone, mozzarella, swiss, brioche or pretzel buns

    • B.Y.O. Cheese Burger $3.5

      bison add

    • The Broad Shoulder Burger $15

      special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, sharp yellow cheddar cheese, slow roasted pork shoulder, ancho-bourbon bbq sauce, urban slaw, chipotle aioli, pretzel bun

  • Perhaps A Salad
    Add Grilled Or Blackened Chicken $5, Salmon $6, Tuna $8
    • Caesar Salad $9.5

      parmesan, garlic brioche croutons, caesar dressing

    • House Salad $10.5

      (gf). baby greens, point reyes blue cheese, candied pistachios, pear tomatoes, carrot, cucumber, balsamic vinaigrette

    • Asian Salad $10.5

      napa cabbage and romaine, red peppers, green onions, carrots, daikon radish, english cucumber, peanuts, sesame seeds, daikon sprouts, sesame-soy dressing

    • Truffled Beet Salad $10.5

      (gf). red beets, baby beets, chevre goat cheese, orange, baby greens, basil, red onions citrus-truffle vinaigrette

    • Baby Spinach Salad $10.5

      (gf). baby spinach, red quinoa, grilled artichokes, roasted red peppers, grilled asparagus, fine herbs, pear tomatoes, sherry vinaigrette

    • Southwest Salad $9.5

      romaine, corn and black bean salsa, avocado drizzle, pear tomatoes, red peppers, green onion, corn tortilla, apple-wood smoked bacon, chipotle ranch dressing

  • Entrees Not To Forget
    • Whiskey Glazed Salmon $22

      (gf). scottish salmon, whiskey glaze, french green beans, roasted shallots, fine herbs

    • St. Louis Style Ribs $25

      pork ribs, uncle dougies' bbq sauce, urban slaw, house fries. half or full slab

    • New York Strip Steak $40

      prime beef, whiskey butter, yukon potato mashies, veal demi glace, crispy onions, herbs. steaks are dipped in whiskey during the grilling process

    • Tuna Au Poivre $28

      (gf). ahi tuna, black peppercorns, sautéed spinach, pinot noir reduction, pomme paille, basil oil

  • Sides (GF)
    • House Fries $3.5

    • French Beans $3.5

      with roasted shallot

    • Urban Slaw $2.5

    • Steamed Broccoli $2.5

    • Yukon Gold Potato Mashies $3.5

  • Beverages
    • Coke $2.25

    • Diet Coke $2.25

    • Sprite $2.25

    • Sprite Zero $2.25

    • Lemonade $2.25

    • Iced Tea $2.25

    • Orange Juice $2.25

    • Cranberry Juice $2.25

    • Club Soda

    • Water

  • Protein & Side
    All Items Include Fresh Cut Skinny House Fries. Side Swap: Substitute Fries For Seasonal Fruit Or Veggies. Add $1
    • Mini Burger

      grass fed beef with or w/o american cheese

    • Crispy Chicken Strips

    • Grilled Cheese

  • Light Bites
    • Truffle Fries $4

      fresh cut fries, parmesan, fresh herbs, truffle aioli

    • Jalapeño Fries $4

      fresh cut fries, jalapeños, queso fresco

    • Loaded Fries $9

      shredded aged white cheddar, braised oxtail

    • Brazilian Nachos $13

      slow roasted pork shoulder, fried tortillas, aged white cheddar, chihuahua cheese, avocado puree, brazilian black beans, pico de gallo, jalapeno, confit of onions, chipotle-lime sauce, shredded lettuce

    • Chicken Wings $10

      choice of hot, chili-soy or ancho-bourbon bbq sauce

    • 50/50 Sliders $12.5

      fifty/fifty blend of apple-wood bacon and grass fed beef, aged white cheddar, roma tomato, crispy onion

    • Apple-Wood Bacon And Blue Cheese Sliders $12.5

      grass fed beef blended with point reyes blue cheese and apple-wood smoked bacon, baby arugula, roma tomato, black pepper aioli

    • Formerly Known As "Tots" $9

      potato "tot" stuffed, apple-wood smoked bacon and reny picot camembert cheese, black pepper aioli. so good, you may not want to share!

  • Sweets
    • House Batched Smore's $9

      fresh graham crackers, home made marshmallow, raspberries, mint and chocolate sauce

    • Crushed Chocolate $6

      crushed milk chocolate, semi-sweet & belgium chocolates with roasted salted nuts

  • Beverages
    • Coke $2.25

    • Diet Coke $2.25

    • Sprite $2.25

    • Sprite Zero $2.25

    • Lemonade $2.25

    • Iced Tea $2.25

    • Orange Juice $2.25

    • Cranberry Juice $2.25

    • Club Soda

    • Water

  • Bourbons
    • Old Fashioned $11

      buffalo trace bourbon, demerara syrup, angostura bitter's

    • Manhattan $12

      koval bourbon, sweet vermouth, bitters

    • Old Fifth $13

      four roses bourbon, walnut liqueur, apricot liqueur, lime juice and jamaican bitters

    • High Plains Drifter $12

      eagle rare 10yr single barrel, stirrings ginger liqueur, velvet falernum, fresh lemon juice, egg white

  • Other Whiskey $12
    • Whiskey Smash

      prichard's tennessee whiskey, demerara syrup, fresh lemon juice

    • Scofflaw

      templeton rye, noilly prat dry vermouth, pom grenadine, fresh lemon juice

    • Proper Sazarac

      bulleit rye whiskey, demerara syrup, peychaud's bitters, absinthe rinse

  • Guest Cocktail
    • Clover Club $12

      tanqueray dry gin, house made pomegranate grenadine, fresh lemon juice, egg white

  • IPA & Pale Ales
    • Anti-Hero $7

      revolution

    • Dunegräs $7

      greenbush

    • Mirrorpond $6

      deschutes

  • Amber, Wheat & Lagers
    • Eliot Ness $7

      great lakes

    • Blue Moon Belgian White $5

    • Coors Light $4.5

    • Krankshaft Lager $5

      metropolitan

  • Porter & Stouts
    • Milk Stout Nitro $6

      left hand

  • Unique Blends
    • 80-Acre Hoppy Wheat $6

      boulevard

    • Hennepin $7

      ommegang

    • Iniquity $7

      southern tier

    • Kentucky Bourbon Ale $7

  • Ciders
    • Vandermill Apple Cider $8

    • Crispin Original $6

  • IPA & Pale Ales
    • Double Jack $9

      firestone walker

    • Modus Hoperandi $7

      ska

    • Daisy Cutter $6

      half acre

    • Dale's Pale Ale $6

      oskar blues

    • Sidekick $5

      two brothers

    • Sierra Nevada Pale Ale $5

  • Wheat & Lagers
    • Goose Island 312 $6

    • Allagash White $6

    • Hacker-Pschorr Weisse $6

    • Miller High Life $4

  • Porter & Stouts
    • Black Butte $6

      deschutes

    • Edmund Fitzgerald $5

      great lakes

    • Guinness $6

    • Porter $6

      founders

    • Satin Solstice $7

      central waters

  • Unique Blends
    • Lil Sumpin Sumpin $6

      lagunitas

    • Midas Touch $9

      dogfish head

    • Dirty Bastard $8

      founder's

    • Robert The Bruce $5

      three floyd's

    • Oak Aged Pale (Sour Ale) $9

      petrus

    • Sublimely Self Righteous $9

      stone

    • Summer Shandy $5

      leinenkugel's

    • Sweet Action (Cream Ale) $6

      six point

  • Gluten Free $5
    • New Grist

      lakefront

    • Prairie Path

      two brothers

  • Non-Alcoholic
    • Kaliber $4

  • Bubbles
    • NV Tommasi Prosecco Brut, Valdobbiadene $11

  • Whites
    • Bricco Riella Moscato D'asti, Italy $8

    • 2012 Riff Pinot Grigio, Trentino $8

    • 2011 Mohua Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough $10

    • 2011 Raymond Chardonnay, California $10

    • 2012 Amalaya Torrontes Riesling, Salta $8

    • 2011 Batasiolo Gavi, Piemonte $10

  • Rose
    • 2012 Crios Malbec Rose, Mendoza $10

  • Reds
    • 2011 Castle Rock Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley $10

    • 2010 La Ginestra Chianti, Tuscany $9

    • 2011 Decero Malbec, Mendoza $11

    • 2011 Milbrandt Cabernet Sauvignon, Columbia Valley $12

    • 2010 Aia Vecchia 'Lagone', Tuscany $12

    • 2011 Langmeil Shiraz, Barossa Valley $12

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.