• Illinois
  • Chicago
  • Horse Thief Hollow

Horse Thief Hollow

(773) 779-2739
  • 10426 S Western Ave, Chicago, IL 60643
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American ,  Gastropub
  • $$$$$
(773) 779-2739
  • Menu
  • Appetizers & Small Plates
    • Pulled Pork Nachos $13.99

      Slow smoked pork, poblano queso, fresh corn tortilla chips, black beans, avocado, tomato, fresh corn salsa, cilantro. Irish Curry Poutine.

    • Irish Curry Poutine $14.99

      Beer braised short rib, hand cut fries, curry gravy, Kerrygold aged cheese, sunny side up egg, fresh parsley.

    • Hand Crafted Charcuterie Plate $16.99

      An assortment of locally sourced meats and cheeses limited only by our imagination.

    • Rhode Island Calamari $13.99

      Lightly breaded & fried, pickled sweet & hot peppers, arugula, harissa tomato sauce.

    • House Made Spent Grain Pretzels $7.99

      Malty soft pretzels made from our own spent grain and served with roasted poblano queso.

    • Sweet Potato Gnocchi $13.99

      Guanciale, toasted pecans, baby spinach, Grana Padano, balsamic brown butter. Omit Guanciale for a vegetarian delight.

    • Buffalo Shrimp $11.99

      Gulf shrimp in buffalo sauce. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing.

    • Jumbo Chicken Wings $9.99

      Choose one of 4 sauces: Buffalo, O'Learys Hot, Korean BBQ, or Mango Habañero. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing.

    • Southwest Egg Rolls $9.99

      Chicken, black beans, corn, pepper jack, avocado, southwest ranch.

  • Soups and Salads
    • Old Man Tom's Gumbo $6.99

      Gulf shrimp, blue crab, clams, and house-made andouille.

    • Soup Special $5.99

      Scratch-made, creative interpretations of soups. Ask your server for today's variety!

    • Winter Kale Salad $11.99

      Baby kale, baby spinach, roasted apples, wheat berries, pickled butternut squash, spiced pecans, Ricotta Salata & cider vinaigrette.

    • Caesar Salad $11.99

      Romaine, mixed greens, grilled asparagus, shaved radish, cherry tomato, red onion, hardboiled egg, Grana Padano, herb polenta croutons.

    • Southwest Salad $10.99

      Mixed greens, romaine, fresh corn salsa, black beans, pickled red onion, cherry tomato, avocado, Chihuahua cheese, cilantro, tortilla strips, southwest ranch.

    • Thai Salad $11.99

      Baby bok choy, Thai basil, rainbow carrots, scallions, red cabbage, red bell pepper, smoked cashew, crispy wonton & spicy yuzu vinaigrette.

  • Burgers
    • Grass Fed $11.99

      ½ lb hand-formed 90/10 from 7 Sons Family Farm in Roanoke, IN.

    • Venison $15.99

      Illinois ground venison, American and cheddar cheese, red onion, pickle chips, house aioli, buttered brioche bun.

    • Lamb $14.99

      Slagel Farms ground lamb, arugula, red onion, tomato jam, mint infused goat cheese.

    • House-made Veggie $10.99

      Cheddar cheese, harissa aioli, black beans, farro, brown rice, roasted mushrooms and pimento cheese.

    • Southwest Turkey $11.99

      Pepperjack cheese, avocado, fried jalapeño, southwest ranch.

  • Sandwiches
    • Lieutenant Dan $13.99

      Fried Gulf shrimp, cilantro, baby bok choy, Thai chili aioli, pickled carrots & daikon, toasted French bread.

    • Cuban $12.99

      Smoked pulled pork, Gruy?re, Dijon mustard, pickles, pimento cheese, house smoked bacon, green chilis, red onion.

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $11.99

      A ½ lb of hand pulled pork on a brioche roll. Choice of sauces.

    • Fat Chef $13.99

      Pulled pork, house-made links, buttermilk slaw and a duo of sauces

    • Brisket Sandwich $13.99

      12-hour smoked beef brisket, horseradish aioli & fried onion strings on a biscuit bun.

    • Lamb Meatball Gyro $12.99

      Slagel Farms ground lamb, coconut tzatziki sauce, sweet vinegar cucumbers and red onion, parsley, pita.

    • Southern Chicken $13.99

      Breaded or grilled chicken breast, buttermilk slaw, sriracha bourbon maple, bread and butter pickles, toasted brioche biscuit bun.

    • Jerk Cauliflower Wrap $11.99

      Black eyed pea hummus, baby spinach, red onion, roasted sweet potato, Chihuahua cheese & tomato basil tortilla.

    • Stuffed Chinese Eggplant $11.99

      Wheat berries, butternut squash, pickled red cabbage, baby bok choy & pumpkin seeds.

  • BBQ
    • Pulled Pork $14.99

      ½ lb dry-rubbed pork shoulder, smoked 12 hours, and hand pulled.

    • Ribs $19.99

      White Marble Farms baby backs. Dry rubbed and smoked 4 hours.

    • BBQ Chicken $16.99

      ½ fresh brined chicken, dry rubbed, and smoked 4 hours.

    • Links $14.99

      House recipe pork sausage link smoked 2 hours and grilled.

    • Combination Platter $23.99

      ¼ lb pulled pork, ¼ chicken, links and ¼ rack of ribs.

  • Entrees
    • Miso Honey Glazed Salmon $22.99

      Baby bok choy, oyster mushrooms, carrot ginger puree, yuzu butter.

    • The Butcher's Cut $25.99

      10 oz. hanger steak, poblano potato gratin, charred broccolini with Calabrian chili, chimichurri butter.

    • Sweet Tea Brined Pork Chops $17.99

      Apple spaetzle, bacon braised red cabbage, smoked apple puree.

    • Beef Short Rib $20.99

      Herbed mascarpone polenta roasted rainbow carrots, "Beer"-delaise sauce fried giardiniera.

    • Hoppin' "Johnny" Strozzapret $17.99

      Priest Strangler pasta, black eyed peas, cherry tomato, poblano romesco, Calabrian chili, charred corn, Grana Padano.

  • Sides
    • French Fries $2.49

    • Sweet Potato Fries $3.99

    • Corn Bread $0.99

    • Baked Beans $2.49

    • Buttermilk Slaw $2.49

    • Mac & Cheese $3.99

    • House Salad $3.99

    • Sautéed Veggies $2.99

  • Desserts
    • Triple Chocolate Flourless Cake $6.99

      Semisweet, milk, and bittersweet chocolate.

    • Charleston Coconut Cake $7.99

      Coconut simple syrup infused cake, coconut custard, butter cream frosting.

    • Whiskey Sweet Potato Pecan Pie $6.99

      Butter crust, vanilla infused pecans, caramel sauce & vanilla ice cream.

    • Mississippi Mud Brownie $6

      Marshmallow, pecans, chocolate ganache

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.