Create Your Own Shake
- 3 Topping Shake $5.75+

Freshman Fifteen
- Strip Tease Shake $5.05+
  
  Nutella.
- O So Mad So Shake $5.05+
  
  Oreo.
- Tempting Tabo Shake $5.05+
  
  Peanut butter.
- Coli Nights Shake $5.05+
  
  Cookie butter.
- Club Recess Shake $5.05+
  
  Reese's.
- Plain Purgatory Shake $5.05+
  
  M&Ms.
- Cereal Killer $5.05+
  
  Fruity Pebbles
- Crunch Time $5.05+
  
  Captain Crunch Berries

Alumni Status
- War Chant Chop Shake $5.28+
  
  Reese's and brownies.
- Stroz Pic-Me-Up Shake $5.28+
  
  M&Ms and peanut butter.
- Club Pub Mix Shake $5.28+
  
  Nutella and peanut butter.
- Parking Attempt Shake $5.28+
  
  Mint Oreo.
- S'Mores $5.28+
  
  Graham Crackers, Marshmallow Fluff, Chocolate Syrup

Classic Gator Haters
- Lord Jimbo Shake $4.58+
  
  Vanilla.
- Doak Dynasty Shake $4.58+
  
  Chocolate.
- Sucks To Be U Shake $4.58+
  
  Banana.
- Famous Jameis Shake $4.58+
  
  Strawberry.
- Coffee Break $5.05+
  
  Coffee Shake

Real Tally Classics
- Inappropriate Capitol Shapes Shake $5.28+
  
  Strawberry and pineapple.
- Walk of Shame Shake $5.28+
  
  Strawberry and Nutella.
- Fear The Spear Shake $5.28+
  
  Banana and Nutella.
- Hangover Cure Shake $5.28+
  
  Banana and peanut butter.
- Tally Always Wins Shake $5.28+
  
  Strawberry and banana.

Donuts
- Glazed Donut $1.39
- Strawberry Frosted Donut $1.39
- Chocolate Frosted Donut $1.39
- Vanilla Frosted Donut $1.39
- Strawberry Sprinkled Donut $1.39
  
  Strawberry frosted donut with sprinkles.
- Chocolate Sprinkled Donut $1.39
  
  Chocolate frosted donut with sprinkles.
- Vanilla Sprinkled Donut $1.39
  
  Vanilla frosted donut with sprinkles.
- Bavarian Kreme Donut $1.39
  
  Sugar powdered donut with Bavarian kreme filling.
- Raspberry Filled Donut $1.39
  
  Sugar powdered donut with raspberry filling.
- Lemon Filled Donut $1.39
  
  Sugar powdered donut with lemon filling.
- Maple Glazed Donut $1.39
  
  Glazed donut with maple frosting.
- Caramel Apple Donut $1.39
  
  Caramel frosted donut with apple filling.
- 12 Donut Holes $2.14
- Red Velvet Donut $1.39
- Old Fashion Glazed Donut $1.39
- Chocolate Cake Donut $1.39
- Old Fashion Plain Donut $1.39
- Caramel Frosted Donut $1.39
- Twix Donut $1.39
  
  Old fashion donut with chocolate and caramel.
- CinnaRing Donut $1.39
  
  Maple frosting, finished with some cinnamon.

Donut Ice Cream Sandwich
- Donut Ice Cream Sandwich $4.99

Food
- Salted Pretzel with Cheese Dip $3.99
- Blueberry Muffin $1.99
- Double Chocolate Muffin $1.99
- Banana Nut Muffin $1.99
- Fruity Pebbles Rice Krispie Treat $1.99
  
  Topped with Dried Strawberries
- Red Velvet Rice Krispie Treat $1.99
  
  Topped with Mini Marshmallows
- Oreo Rice Krispie Treat $1.99
  
  Topped with White Chocolate and Oreos

Ice Cream Bars
- Snickers Ice Cream Bar $1.99
- Reese's Ice Cream Cup $1.99
- Choco Taco $1.99
- Twix Ice Cream Bar $1.99
- M&M Ice Cream Sandwich $1.99
- Oreo Klondike Bar $1.99
- Chocolate Eclair Ice Cream $1.99
- Strawberry Eclair Ice Cream Bar $1.99
- King Cone Ice Cream $1.99

Drinks
- Water $1.50

Menu for Shake Shop provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.