Nick's Tomato Pie
Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.
-
Nick's Tomato Pie
-
- Menu
-
Raw Bar & Appetizers
-
Clams On A 1/2 Shell $12.95
-
Little Neck Clams $14.95
"a bowl full" red or white sauce or steamed
-
Clams Casino Or Oreganato $10.99
-
Fresh Maine Mussels $10.99
"a bowl full" red or white sauce or provencale sauce
-
Baked Mushroom Caps $9.99
* stuffed w/ crabmeat & crumbs w/ spinach & chopped tomatoe
-
Fried Mozzarella $6.75
served w/ marinara sauce.
-
Bruschetta $6.99
sliced and grilled country bread, topped with herbs, tomatoes & basil.
-
Eggplant Rollatini $8.50
w/ ricotta cheese
-
Ricotta Stuffed Meatballs $5.95
"parmigiana"
-
Crispy Fish Fingers $10.95
w/tartar sauce
-
Mozzarella Caprese $9.95
sliced tomatoe and fresh mozzarella
-
Calamari $9.95
monterey squid seasoned, lightly floured & fried.
-
Calamari $1.50
tossed with cherry peppers
-
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $2.50
minimum 3
-
Antipasto Alla Famiglia $14.99
* mozzarella caprese, prosciutto, roasted peppers, salami, olives, calamari, stuffed mushroom, clams casino & oreganato. "great for sharing"
-
Antipasto Di Casa $9.99
* prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & tomatoe, salami, olives
-
Roasted Peppers & Provolone $8.99
-
Roasted Peppers & Provolone $1.99
w/prosciutto add
-
-
Soups
-
Del Giorno
-
Pasta Fagioli
-
-
Salad Bowls
-
Gorgonzola Salad $10.95
radicchio, arugula and endive with tomatoes, basil & our special gorgonzola dressing
-
Gorgonzola Salad $4.95
with entrée
-
The Guido Caesar Salad $9.99
-
The Guido Caesar Salad $4.95
with entrée
-
Spinach Salad $10.50
fresh spinach, pecans, apples, and red onions tossed with creamy vinaigrette
-
Spinach Salad $4.95
with entrée
-
Joe "Mow The Lawn"Green Salad $6.95
-
Joe "Mow The Lawn"Green Salad $1.95
add gorgonzola cheese to any salad
-
Nick's Romano Salad $14.95
chopped greens topped with chicken milanese, creamy italian parmesan dressing, chopped eggs, bacon, tomatoes, green onions & cucumbers.
-
-
Tomatoe Pies
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $11.50
* tomatoe, mozzarella.
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $13.25
with salsiccia (sausage)
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $13.25
with pepperoni
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $12.50
with funghi (mushrooms)
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $14.50
with meatballs (3) or bolognese sauce
-
Di Casa $14.50
3 color peppers and onion.
-
Quattro Formaggi $14.50
4 cheeses.
-
Vegetarian $14.99
eggplant, 3 color peppers, broccoli and fresh tomatoe.
-
-
Pasta Of Your Choice
-
Capellini
"angel hair" the most delicate pasta
-
Penne Rigate (Mostaccioli)
"pencil points" a thin tubular pasta.
-
Linguine
"small tongues" , really a spaghetti but the shape of a narrow flat noodle.
-
Fettuccine
"small ribbons" , the famous noodle that has been responsible for the fortunes of restaurants.
-
Rigatoni
"ridges or groves" a large tubular pasta.
-
Farfalle
"bow ties" or "butterflies" , the american version often called "bows" , is made with egg noodles.
-
Spaghetti
thin pasta introduced to italy by marco polo.
-
Tortellini
cheese stuffed
-
Tortellini $2.00
add to sauce
-
Ravioli
cheese stuffed
-
Ravioli $2.00
add to sauce
-
-
Sauce Of Your Choice
-
Aglio & Olio $12.95
fresh garlic and extra virgin olive oi.
-
Marinara Or Fra Diavolo $14.50
plum tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, basil and white wine. crushed red pepper in fra diavolo
-
Alfredo $16.75
"the famous dish from roma."
-
Alla Vodka $17.99
* plum tomatoes, prosciutto, parmigiano, cream and a hint of vodka
-
Alla Vodka $14.99
lighter portion
-
Bolognese $16.99
meat sauce with fresh basil.
-
Bolognese $14.99
lighter portion
-
Roasted Chicken Vodka $17.95
over rigatoni with peas, mushrooms & red bell peppers
-
Fresh Shucked Clam Sauce Red Or White Sauce $19.99
chopped clams, virgin olive oil, wine, parsley and garlic over linguini. whole clam garni.
-
-
Add As You Wish
-
Peas $1.00
-
Capers $1.50
-
Cream Sauce $1.00
-
Chopped Garlic $1.00
-
Crumbled Sausage $1.75
-
Fresh Tomatoe $1.99
-
Mushrooms $1.99
-
Melted Mozzarella $1.99
-
Anchovies $1.99
-
Olives $1.99
-
Bell Peppers $1.99
-
Eggplant $1.99
-
Shrimp $2.50
-
Broccoli $1.99
-
Sundried Tomatoes $2.25
-
Prosciutto $3.25
-
Roasted Peppers $1.99
-
Artichokes $2.99
-
Grilled Chicken Breast $3.95
-
-
Add As You Wish
-
Gnocchi Alla Nick's (Nyaw-Key) $16.95
* homemade potato dumplings sauteed with marinara sauce, butter, and parmigiano cheese.
-
Grilled Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions $16.95
in a light tomatoe sauce.
-
-
Baked Pasta
-
Manicotti $13.00
-
Lasagna "Ala Nicola" $15.95
-
Baked Ziti "NTP Style" $14.95
sausage, meatball, bell peppers, onion, 3 cheeses & chopped tomatoe.
-
-
Parmigiana
-
Veal $18.95
-
Chicken Breast $16.95
-
Chicken Breast $13.99
lighter portion
-
Eggplant Parm $14.95
-
Rollatini* $16.95
stuffed with ricotta cheese
-
Shrimp $17.95
-
-
Chicken At Nick's
-
Roasted Pollo "NTP Style" $15.95
* our house specialty with vegetable, roasted potatoes or pasta.
-
Chicken Scarpariello $18.99
* bone-in with sliced sausage, pepperoncini, potato, & capers in a vinegar wine sauce.
-
Chicken Cacciatore $18.95
bone-in with marinara, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and red wine
-
Chicken Florentine $17.50
fresh spinach, provolone & tomatoe in a light red sauce.
-
Chicken Florentine $14.99
lighter portion
-
Chicken Marsala $16.95
mushroom and marsala wine sauce
-
Chicken Marsala $13.95
lighter portion
-
Grilled Chicken Breast "Parm" $17.50
-
Chicken Milanese $16.95
lightly breaded and sauteed w/ green salad, marinated tomato.
-
-
Top Round Of Veal
-
Marsala $21.95
mushrooms and wine sauce.
-
Marsala $17.95
lighter portion
-
Francese $21.95
lemon, butter & wine sauce.
-
Piccata $21.95
lemon, butter, wine sauce & capers.
-
Saltimbocca $21.95
fresh sage & prosciutto served on a bed of spinach with fontina cheese.
-
Florentine $21.95
* fresh spinach, 3 cheeses & tomato.
-
Veal Milanese $21.95
lightly breaded and sauteed w/ green salad and marinated tomato.
-
-
From Nick's Hoagie Shop $12.95
-
Meatball Hoagie
parmigiana style. choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad.
-
Sausage Hoagie
parmigiana style or grilled peppers & onions. choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad.
-
Nick's Special Burger
choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad. choices of cheese - american, provolone, blue cheese, mozzarella, gorgonzola & fries.
-
-
The Fish Market
-
Florida Snapper
francese style. over capellini tossed with vegetables
-
Florida Snapper
blackened
-
Florida Snapper
broiled. with white wine & lemon butter.
-
Jumbo Shrimp $18.95
fra diavolo or with marinara sauce. over linguine.
-
Jumbo Shrimp $15.95
lighter portion
-
Francese $18.95
lemon, butter & white wine sauce over vegetable-tossed pasta.
-
Shrimp Scampi $18.95
in traditional sauce served over linguine
-
Zuppa Di Pesce $24.95
shrimp, mussels, clams, calamari, lobster and plum to- matoes, with a hint of balsamic vinegar and fresh herbs served over a bed of linguine with fresh marinara sauce.
-
Crispy Fish Sandwich $14.95
with choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad.
-
-
The Lobster Trap $29
-
Lobster Tail
fra diavolo with shrimp & clams
-
Lobster Tail
broiled with crabmeat, crumbs & citrus
-
-
The Stock Yard
-
N.Y. Strip
pan seared, gorgonzola, peppercorn
-
-
Coffee Specialties
-
Espresso $3.25
this dark rich coffee adds a perfect final touch to a great meal
-
Irish Coffee $7.75
coffee with irish whiskey topped with green creme de menthe and whipped cream
-
Cappuccino $4.95
fresh, steaming espresso, topped with steamed milk, rich and frothy.
-
Italian Coffee $7.75
coffee and amaretto topped with whipped cream
-
-
Fresh Vegetables $4.50
-
Sautéed Spinach
-
Sautéed Broccoli
-
-
Ginny's Bake Shop
-
Cannoli $4.95
italian pastry shell stuffed with ricotta cheese and italian liqueur.
-
Tiramisu $5.95
enjoy this italian favorite made with fresh cream, lady fingers, and imported italian liqueurs.
-
Toni's Torta Ricotta Cheesecake $5.95
-
New York Style Cheesecake $5.95
-
Florida Key Lime Pie (In Season) $5.95
traditional key west style
-
Cold Zabaglione $5.95
a heavenly concoction of whipped cream, marsala wine and brandy with fresh strawberries & chocolate.
-
Ice Cream $3.50
-
Stacked Brownie Fudge Sundae $4.75
-
Janet's Surprise
ask your server what we have tonight
-
-
Raw Bar & Appetizers
-
Clams On A 1/2 Shell $12.95
-
Little Neck Clams $14.95
"a bowl full" red or white sauce or steamed
-
Clams Casino Or Oreganato $10.99
-
Fresh Maine Mussels $10.99
"a bowl full" red or white sauce or provencale sauce
-
Baked Mushroom Caps $9.99
* stuffed w/ crabmeat & crumbs w/ spinach & chopped tomatoe
-
Fried Mozzarella $6.75
served w/ marinara sauce
-
Bruschetta $6.99
sliced and grilled country bread, topped with herbs, tomatoes & basil.
-
Eggplant Rollatini $8.50
w/ ricotta cheese
-
Ricotta Stuffed Meatballs $5.95
"parmigiana"
-
Crispy Fish Fingers $10.95
w/tartar sauce
-
Mozzarella Caprese $9.95
sliced tomatoe and fresh mozzarella
-
Calamari $9.95
monterey squid seasoned, lightly floured & fried.
-
Calamari $1.50
tossed with cherry peppers add
-
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $2.50
minimum 3
-
Antipasto Alla Famiglia $14.99
* mozzarella caprese, prosciutto, roasted peppers, salami, olives, calamari, stuffed mushroom, clams casino & oreganato. "great for sharing"
-
Antipasto Di Casa $9.99
* prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & tomatoe, salami, olives
-
Roasted Peppers & Provolone $8.99
-
Roasted Peppers & Provolone $1.99
w/ prosciutto add
-
-
Soups
-
Del Giorno
-
Pasta Fagioli
-
-
Fresh Vegetables $4.50
-
Sautéed Spinach
-
Sautéed Broccoli
-
-
Salad Bowls
-
Gorgonzola Salad $10.95
radicchio, arugula and endive with tomatoes, basil & our special gorgonzola dressing
-
Gorgonzola Salad $4.95
with entrée
-
The Guido Caesar Salad $9.99
-
The Guido Caesar Salad $4.95
with entrée
-
Spinach Salad $10.50
fresh spinach, pecans, apples, and red onions tossed with creamy vinaigrette
-
Spinach Salad $4.95
with entrée
-
Joe "Mow The Lawn"Green Salad $6.95
-
Joe "Mow The Lawn"Green Salad $1.95
add gorgonzola cheese to any salad
-
Nick's Romano Salad $14.95
chopped greens topped with chicken milanese, creamy italian parmesan dressing, chopped eggs, bacon, tomatoes, green onions & cucumbers.
-
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pies
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $11.50
* tomatoe, mozzarella.
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $13.25
with salsiccia (sausage)
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $13.25
with pepperoni
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $12.50
with funghi (mushrooms)
-
Nick's Tomatoe Pie $14.50
with meatballs (3) or bolognese sauce
-
Di Casa $14.50
3 color peppers and onion.
-
Quattro Formaggi $14.50
4 cheeses.
-
Vegetarian $14.99
eggplant, 3 color peppers, broccoli and fresh tomatoe.
-
-
Pasta Of Your Choice
-
Capellini
"angel hair" the most delicate pasta
-
Penne Rigate (Mostaccioli)
"pencil points" a thin tubular pasta
-
Linguine
"small tongues" , really a spaghetti but the shape of a narrow flat noodle
-
Fettuccine
"small ribbons" , the famous noodle that has been responsible for the fortunes of restaurants
-
Rigatoni
"ridges or groves" a large tubular pasta
-
Farfalle
"bow ties" or "butterflies" , the american version often called "bows" , is made with egg noodles
-
Spaghetti
thin pasta introduced to italy by marco polo.
-
Tortellini
cheese stuffed
-
Tortellini $2.00
add to sauce
-
Ravioli $2.00
cheese stuffed
-
Ravioli $2.00
add to sauce
-
-
Sauce Of Your Choice
-
Aglio & Olio $12.95
fresh garlic and extra virgin olive oi.
-
Marinara Or Fra Diavolo $14.50
plum tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, basil and white wine. crushed red pepper in fra diavolo
-
Alfredo $16.75
"the famous dish from roma."
-
Alla Vodka $17.99
* plum tomatoes, prosciutto, parmigiano, cream and a hint of vodka
-
Alla Vodka $14.99
lighter portion
-
Bolognese $16.99
meat sauce with fresh basil
-
Bolognese $14.99
lighter portion
-
Roasted Chicken Vodka $17.95
over rigatoni with peas, mushrooms & red bell peppers
-
Nick's Favorite $14.95
penne, aglio & olio style w/ broccoli. choice of crumbled sausage or chicken.
-
Fresh Shucked Clam Sauce Red Or White Sauce $19.99
chopped clams, virgin olive oil, wine, parsley and garlic over linguini. whole clam garni.
-
-
Add As You Wish
-
Peas $1.00
-
Capers $1.50
-
Cream Sauce $1.00
-
Chopped Garlic $1.00
-
Crumbled Sausage $1.75
-
Fresh Tomatoes $1.99
-
Mushrooms $1.99
-
Melted Mozzarella $1.99
-
Anchovies $1.99
-
Olives $1.99
-
Bell Peppers $1.99
-
Eggplant $1.99
-
Shrimp $2.50
-
Broccoli $1.99
-
Sundried Tomatoes $2.25
-
Prosciutto $3.25
-
Roasted Peppers $1.99
-
Artichokes $2.99
-
Grilled Chicken Breast $3.95
-
-
Add As You Wish
-
Gnocchi Alla Nick's (NYAW-KEY) $16.95
* homemade potato dumplings sauteed with marinara sauce, butter, and parmigiano cheese
-
Grilled Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions $16.95
in a light tomatoe sauce.
-
-
Baked Pasta
-
Manicotti $13.00
-
Lasagna "Ala Nicola" $15.95
-
Baked Ziti "NTP Style" $14.95
sausage, meatball, bell peppers, onion, 3 cheeses & chopped tomatoe.
-
-
Parmigiana
-
Veal $18.95
-
Chicken Breast $16.95
-
Chicken Breast $13.99
lighter portion
-
Eggplant Parm $14.95
-
Rollatini $16.95
* stuffed with ricotta cheese
-
Shrimp $17.95
-
-
Chicken At Nick's
-
Roasted Pollo "NTP Style" $15.95
* our house specialty with vegetable, roasted potatoes or pasta
-
Chicken Scarpariello $18.99
* bone-in with sliced sausage, pepperoncini, potato, & capers in a vinegar wine sauce.
-
Chicken Cacciatore $18.95
bone-in with marinara, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and red wine.
-
Chicken Florentine $17.50
fresh spinach, provolone & tomatoe in a light red sauce.
-
Chicken Florentine $14.99
lighter portion
-
Chicken Marsala $16.95
mushroom and marsala wine sauce.
-
Chicken Marsala $13.95
lighter portion
-
Grilled Chicken Breast "Parm" $17.50
-
Chicken Milanese $16.95
lightly breaded and sauteed w/ green salad, marinated tomato.
-
-
Top Round Of Veal
-
Marsala $21.95
mushrooms and wine sauce
-
Marsala $17.95
lighter portion
-
Francese $21.95
lemon, butter & wine sauce
-
Piccata $21.95
lemon, butter, wine sauce & capers
-
Saltimbocca $21.95
fresh sage & prosciutto served on a bed of spinach with fontina cheese.
-
Florentine $21.95
* fresh spinach, 3 cheeses & tomato
-
Veal Milanese $21.95
lightly breaded and sauteed w/ green salad and marinated tomato.
-
-
From Nick's Hoagie Shop $12.95
-
Meatball Hoagie
parmigiana style. choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad.
-
Sausage Hoagie
parmigiana style or grilled peppers & onions. choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad.
-
Nick's Special Burger
choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad. choices of cheese - american, provolone, blue cheese, mozzarella, gorgonzola & fries.
-
-
The Fish Market
-
Florida Snapper
francese style. over capellini tossed with vegetables
-
Florida Snapper
blackened
-
Florida Snapper
broiled. with white wine & lemon butter.
-
Jumbo Shrimp $18.95
fra diavolo or with marinara sauce. over linguine.
-
Jumbo Shrimp $15.95
lighter portion
-
Jumbo Shrimp $18.95
francese. lemon, butter & white wine sauce over vegetable-tossed pasta.
-
Shrimp Scampi $18.95
in traditional sauce served over linguine
-
Zuppa Di Pesce $24.95
shrimp, mussels, clams, calamari, lobster and plum tomatoes, with a hint of balsamic vinegar and fresh herbs served over a bed of linguine with fresh marinara sauce.
-
Crispy Fish Sandwich $14.95
with choice of soup or "mow the lawn" salad.
-
-
The Lobster Trap $29
-
Lobster Tail
fra diavolo with shrimp & clams
-
Lobster Tail
broiled with crabmeat, crumbs & citrus
-
-
The Stock Yard
-
N.Y. Strip
pan seared, gorgonzola, peppercorn
-
-
Coffee Specialties
-
Espresso $3.25
this dark rich coffee adds a perfect final touch to a great meal
-
Irish Coffee $7.75
coffee with irish whiskey topped with green creme de menthe and whipped cream
-
Cappuccino $4.95
fresh, steaming espresso, topped with steamed milk, rich and frothy.
-
Italian Coffee $7.75
coffee and amaretto topped with whipped cream
-
-
Ginny's Bake Shop
-
Cannoli $4.95
italian pastry shell stuffed with ricotta cheese and italian liqueur
-
Tiramisu $5.95
enjoy this italian favorite made with fresh cream, lady fingers, and imported italian liqueurs
-
Toni's Torta Ricotta Cheesecake $5.95
-
New York Style Cheesecake $5.95
-
Florida Key Lime Pie $5.95
(in season) traditional key west style
-
Cold Zabaglione $5.95
a heavenly concoction of whipped cream, marsala wine and brandy with fresh strawberries & chocolate.
-
Ice Cream $3.50
-
Stacked Brownie Fudge Sundae $4.75
-
Janet's Surprise
ask your server what we have tonight
-
-
BambiniKid's. Under 10 Years & 200 Lbs. Served With Complimentary Ice Cream * Denotes Specialita Della Casa. Consuming Raw Or Undercooked Meats, Poultry, Seafood, Shellfish, Or Eggs May Increase Your Risk Of Foodbourne Illness, Especially If You Have Certain Medical Conditions.
-
Pasghetti & Meatballs $5.95
-
Nick's Chick Strips $6.95
with french fries or spaghetti
-
Mac & Cheese $5.95
with garlic bread
-
Hershey's Chocolate Milk $1.75
-
Kids Cup Soda $1.25
-
Steamed Broccoli & Carrots $1.50
-
Ravioli $5.95
cheese filled pasta pillows
-
Nick's Tomatoes Pie $6.95
-
Nick's Tomatoes Pie $0.50
cheese and tomato extra items
-
Grilled Cheese & French Fries $5.95
-
Kid's Salad $2.95
-
Kid's Salad $1.00
with entree comes with ranch dressing
-
Great French Fries $1.95
-
Menu for Nick's Tomato Pie provided by Allmenus.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.