Allmenus.com
  • Florida
  • Islamorada
  • Hungry Tarpon Restaurant

Hungry Tarpon Restaurant

(305) 664-0535

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 77522 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
  • Seafood
  • $$$$$
  • Hungry Tarpon Restaurant

  • (305) 664-0535
  • Menu
  • Standard Fare
    Served With Hash Browns Or Grits, Toast Or Biscuit
    • 1 Or 2 XL Eggs Any Style $5.95

    • 1 Or 2 XL Eggs Any Style $11.95

      with steak

    • 1 Or 2 XL Eggs Any Style $8.95

      with country fried steak

    • 1 Or 2 XL Eggs Any Style $7.95

      with sugar-cured ham or hash

    • 1 Or 2 XL Eggs Any Style $6.95

      with bacon or sausage patties

    • 1 Or 2 XL Eggs Any Style $8.95

      with fried chicken breast

  • Morning Favorites
    • Homemade Biscuits & Sausage Gravy $5.95

    • Creamed Chipped Beef (SOS) $5.95

    • Buttermilk Pancakes $3.95+

    • Buttermilk Pancakes $1.50

      add blueberries or chocolate chips

    • French Toast $5.95

    • Belgian Waffle $5.95

    • Bagel & Cream Cheese $3.95

    • Bagel & Peanut Butter $3.95

    • Assorted Cold Cereal $4.50

  • Combos
    • Cowboy $13.95

      2 eggs any style, served with rib-eye steak, a belgian waffle & hash browns

    • The Flats $6.95

      2 eggs any style with hash browns, fresh tomato & chipped beef served over toast

    • Country Combo $7.95

      2 eggs any style with hash browns, fresh tomato, homemade biscuit and sausage gravy

    • Heavy Hitter $7.95

      2 pancakes, 2 eggs with choice of bacon, sausage or ham

  • Breakfast Sandwiches
    • Silver King $5.50

      eggs, sausage patties and american cheese served on grilled sourdough

    • Gringo $5.50

      eggs, bacon and american cheese served on grilled sourdough

    • Bagel Breakfast Sandwich $5.50

      eggs, ham & american cheese served on a bagel

    • Steak & Egg Sandwich $10.95

      eggs, rib-eye steak and american cheese served on grilled sourdough

    • Reef Sandwich $6.50

      eggs, ham, fresh tomato and american cheese served on grilled sourdough

    • Grilled Cheese $5.95

    • Grilled Cheese $7.95

      with bacon and tomato

  • Scrambles $8.95
    Served With Hash Browns Or Grits, Toast Or Biscuit These Are Not Omelettes.
    • Willy Roberts

      3 eggs scrambled with cured ham, fresh basil, scallions, topped with pico de gallo

    • Hawk's Channel "This Is Really Good"

      3 eggs scrambled with shaved rib eye steak, scallions, red bell peppers and mushrooms, topped with melted cheese

    • Alligator Reef

      3 eggs, scrambled with chorizo, black beans, fresh cilantro, chopped tomatoes and feta cheese topped with sour cream and scallions

  • Frittata Style Omelettes
    Served With Choice Of Hash Browns, Grits Or Fresh Tomato
    • Lobster Frittata $11.95

      sauteed lobster, shredded potatoes, jack cheese, red bell peppers topped with hollandaise sauce and chopped scallions

    • El Gringo Grande $7.50

      eggs, ham, scallions & jack cheese topped with green chili salsa

    • Spring Omelette $7.50

      eggs, feta cheese, scallions, fresh basil and tomato

    • Diego Frittata $7.50

      sauteed hash browns incorporated with eggs, chorizo, red bell pepper, scallions and jack cheese, topped with ranchero salsa

    • Your Way Omelette $7.50

      3 eggs omelette with your choice of three items of c, one item of a, & one item of b

  • Toppings
    For Omelettes, Scrambles & Burritos Only.
    • A. Add These Items. $1.25

      bacon, sausage, chorizo, ham

    • B. Add Cheese $1.00

      american, cheddar, jack, feta

    • C. Add These Items $0.75

      peppers, basil, tomato, scallions, mushrooms, jalapeno

  • Breakfast Burritos
    Served With Choice Of Hash Browns, Grits Or Fresh Tomato
    • The Western $9.95

      eggs, shaved rib-eye steak, jack cheese & tomato

    • Southern Style $7.95

      eggs, sausage, scallions & jack cheese topped with ranchero salsa

    • A La Burrito $7.95

      eggs, ham, scallions and jack cheese, topped with green chili salsa

    • Burrito Fra Diablo $7.95

      eggs, chorizo, scallions, red bell peppers, jalapeno and jack cheese

    • Ranchero Burrito $7.95

      eggs, chorizo sausage, jack cheese and topped with ranchero salsa

    • Your Way Burrito $7.95

      tortilla stuffed with 3 eggs, and choice of three items of 'c', one item of 'a', and one item of 'b'

  • Specialties
    For Egg Whites Add $1.
    • The Purple Isle $11.95

      stacked crepes stuffed with fried eggs and lobster, topped with hollandaise sauce and tomatoes on the side

    • Long Key Benedict $9.95

      toasted muffins, sugar cured ham, soft fried eggs and topped with hollandaise sauce

    • Hungry Permit $7.95

      hash browns topped with american cheese, fresh tomato, bacon, 2 eggs, a homemade biscuit and sausage gravy

    • Hungry Tarpon $7.50

      hash browns topped with 2 eggs, jack cheese, a homemade biscuit and sausage gravy

    • Grits & Grunts $9.95

      2 eggs, fresh fried fish, grits and choice of toast or homemade biscuit

    • Blue Marlin $9.95

      2 eggs, fresh fried fish, hash browns and choice of toast or homemade biscuit

    • Huevos Rancheros $6.95

      flour tortilla topped with 2 fried eggs salsa, cheese and refried beans

    • The Hump $8.95

      3 eggs scrambled with bacon, ham, chorizo and jack cheese, served with a homemade biscuit and topped with sausage gravy

  • Sides
    • Steak $8.00

    • Sausage Gravy Or Chipped Beef $4.95

    • Bacon Or Sausage $2.95

    • Ham Or Hash $3.95

    • Red Or Green Salsa $1.95

    • Hash Browns Or Grits $1.95

    • Toast Or Biscuit $1.25

    • Tortilla, English Muffin Or Bagel $1.95

    • XL Egg $1.00

    • Any Cheese $1.00

  • Beverages
    • Champagne Cocktails $6.95

      mimosa, hibiscus or poinsettia

    • Coffee $1.95

    • Hot Tea $1.75

    • Coffee To-Go $2.00+

    • Iced Tea, Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Orange, Lemonade $1.95

      includes 1 refill

    • Milk, Chocolate Milk, Hot Chocolate $2.50

    • Orange, Tomato, Cranberry, Apple Juice $2.95

  • For The Kids
    12 Years & Younger
    • Pancake Or French Toast $3.95

      with bacon

    • Eggs, Bacon, Toast, Hash Browns Or Grits $3.95

    • The Gooey $5.95

    • Belgian Waffle $5.95

  • Starters
    • Sashimi Tuna $9.95

    • 1 1/2 Lb. Jumbo Wings $7.95

    • Conch Fritters $6.95

    • Cheese Sticks $5.95

    • Cheese Fries $5.95

    • Onion Rings $5.95

  • Soups & Salads
    • Conch Chowder $3.50+

      best homemade chowder in florida

    • Real Lobster Bisque $3.50+

    • Spicy Black Bean Soup $3.50+

    • Soup & House Salad Combo $8.00

    • Caesar Salad $6.00

      with homemade dressing

    • Dinner Salad $5.00

      with choice of dressing

  • Add These To Any Salad
    • Fish Of The Day $9.00

    • Ahi Tuna $8.00

    • Chicken Breast $6.00

    • Shrimp $9.00

    • Steak $8.00

  • Signature Specials
    Served With Choice Of Fries, Chips Or Slaw, Substitute Beans And Rice, Onion Rings Or Side Salad, Add $2.
    • Stiltsville $9.95

      fresh grilled or blackened chicken breast on grilled sourdough, topped with bacon and melted swiss cheese

    • Florida "Cracker Cowboy" $13.95

      hand cut rib eye steak, with grilled onions and melted cheese on a hoagie roll with lettuce and tomato

    • Cash Island Shrimp Po Boy $12.95

      hot grilled roll with fried shrimp, tartar sauce & provolone cheese

    • The Bluewater Sandwich $13.95

      8oz. ahi tuna grilled to temperature on a kaiser roll with wasabi mayo, lettuce and tomato

    • Matecumbe Fish Sandwich $13.95

      blackened, grilled or fried fish with provolone, bacon, lettuce, tomato and thousand island dressing on grilled sourdough

    • Islamorada Fish Sandwich $13.95

      fried or blackened grouper with cheese, grilled onions, lettuce and tomato on kaiser roll

    • Whole Fried Yellowtail $15.95

      a whole fish fried bahamian style with black beans and rice

  • Burgers & Dogs
    Served With Choice Of Fries, Chips Or Slaw; Substitute Beans And Rice, Onion Rings Or Side Salad, Add $2
    • "Prime Cut" Burger $9.95

      we prefer not to serve this one well done

    • "Choice Cut" Burgers $6.95+

      angus beef

    • Specialty Burgers - Ricochet Burger $15.95

      two 8oz. choice cut beef patties topped with grilled onion, mushroom, bacon and cheese on grilled sourdough

    • Black-N-Bleu Burger $9.95

      8oz. choice cut beef, blackened with our homemade seasoning, topped with bleu cheese crumbles on grilled sourdough

    • Vegeterian Garden Burger $7.95

    • 1/4lb. All Beef Hot Dog $5.95

    • Double Dogs $8.95

  • Burgers & Dogs - Toppings
    Dress Up Your Burger Or Dog
    • A. Add These Items $1.50

      bacon, chorizo, ham

    • B. Add Cheese $1.00

      american, cheddar, jack, swiss provolone

    • C. Add These Items $0.75

      bell peppers, mushrooms, grilled onions

  • For The Kids
    12 Years & Younger
    • Mac & Cheese $4.95

    • Pancake $3.95

    • Burger $5.95

    • Fish Sandwich $7.95

    • Hot Dog $5.95

    • PB & J $4.95

    • Shrimp Basket $7.95

    • Fish Basket $7.95

  • South Of The Border Soft Tacos
    Served With Beans And Rice
    • Ahi Tuna Tacos $12.95

      grilled ahi tuna, shredded cabbage, special sauce and cilantro, topped with pico de gallo

    • Fish Tacos $11.95

      our fresh fish (grilled, blackened, or fried) tartar sauce, fresh cilantro and shredded cabbage with pico de gallo

    • Shrimp Tacos $12.95

      grilled, blackened or fried shrimp, tartar sauce, cilantro and shredded cabbage with pico de gallo

  • Quesadillas
    Served With Beans And Rice, Sour Cream And Salsa And Chopped Salad
    • Cheese Quesadillas $6.95

      jack & cheddar cheeses

    • Chicken Quesadillas $8.95

      chicken, jack & cheddar, tomatoes and scallions

  • Burritos
    Served With Beans And Rice, Sour Cream And Salsa And Chopped Salad
    • Shrimp Burrito $12.95

      "a house favorite"

    • Seafood Burrito $11.95

    • Steak, Cheese And Veggie Burrito $10.95

      shaved rib eye steak, steak grilled vegetables, refried beans and melted cheese

    • Beef & Bean Burrito $8.95

    • Chicken & Bean Burrito $8.95

  • Sandwiches
    Served With Choice Of Fries, Chips Or Slaw. Substitute Beans And Rice, Onion Rings Or Side Salad, Add $2
    • Philly Cheese Steak $7.95

      shaved rib eye steak, topped with onion, bell peppers and melted cheese

    • Chicken Philly Cheese $7.95

      same as above with chicken breast

    • Premium Fish Sandwich

      fresh dolphin or grouper blackened, grilled or fried

    • Premium Fish Sandwich $11.95

      mahi

    • Premium Fish Sandwich $13.95

      grouper

    • Black-N-Bleu Fish $11.95

      blackened fish with melted blue cheese on a kaiser roll

    • Chicken Breast Sandwich $7.95

    • Cuban Press $7.95

      "a house favorite"

    • BLT $6.95

    • Grilled Cheese $5.95

      with bacon and tomato

    • Ham, Turkey, Turkey & Ham, Tuna Salad Or Chicken Salad $7.95

  • Baskets
    Served With Choice Of Fries, Chips, Or Slaw; Substitute Beans And Rice, Onion Rings Or Side Salad, Add $2
    • Premium Fish Basket

      fresh dolphin or grouper

    • Premium Fish Basket $11.95

      mahi

    • Premium Fish Basket $13.95

      grouper

    • Fried Shrimp Basket $12.95

    • Fried Seafood Basket $11.95

    • Cracked Conch Basket $16.95

    • Calamari Basket $9.95

    • Chicken Tenders Basket $6.95

  • Sides & Extra
    • Fish Or Shrimp $9.00

    • Chicken Tender Or Chicken Breast $6.00

    • Beans & Rice $3.95

    • Cole Slaw Or Rice $1.95

    • Fries $2.95

    • Onion Rings $5.95

  • Beverages
    • Champagne Cocktails $6.95

      mimosa, hibiscus, or poinsettia

    • Coffee $1.95

    • Hot Tea $1.75

    • Coffee To-Go $2.00+

    • Iced Tea, Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Orange, Lemonade $1.95

      include 1 refill

    • Milk, Chocolate Milk, Hot Chocolate Orange, Tomato, Cranberry, Apple Juice $2.95

  • Appetizers
    • Robbie's Calamari Cocktail $8.00

      served on tender baby greens dressed with the chef's special florida fresh citrus vinaigrette and served with chef joseph's original caribbean cocktail sauce

    • Shrimp Paradise $11.00

      delectable key west pink shrimp sautéed and served with a mouth watering mango papaya salsa

  • Soups
    Cup $4 / Bowl $5
    • Soup Du Jour

    • Chef Joseph's Award Winnin Fresh Fish Chowder

  • Salads
    • The Hungry Tarpon Salad $5.00

      served with your choice of dressing

    • The Sunshine Salad $6.00

      juvenile field greens, florida grown grapefruit, orange segments, tomatoes, corn and sunflower seeds served with a chef's special citrus balsamic vinaigrette

    • The Sunshine Salad $10.00

      with chicken

    • The Sunshine Salad $13.00

      with shrimp

    • Caribbean Conch Salad $7.00

      a new twist on a keys favorite. served with a light and mild onion pepper dressing

    • Asian Seared Tuna $12.00

      served on a bed of field grown greens, shaved carrots and cucumber with a homemade teriyaki mango-glaze wonton chips

  • The Lighter Side
    • Five Pepper Dip $6.00

      one of chef joseph's signature creations of five distinctive and locally grown homestead peppers blended together with secret herbs and spices to make tantalizing dip. served with tortilla chips

    • The Classic French Dip Au Jus $8.00

      tender sliced oven roasted beef served on freshly baked mini-french baguette. your choice of french fries or house salad

    • Cracked Conch $9.00

      a local favorite. tender conch lightly breaded and fried to perfection and served with a bahamian cocktail sauce

  • For The Kids
    12 Years & Younger, Please
    • Caroline's Grilled Cheese Sandwich $6.00

      served with choice of fries, chips or mixed vegetables

    • Robbie 's Mac N' Cheese $5.00

    • Hamburger Or Cheeseburger $7.00

      served with choice of fries, chips or mixed vegetables

    • Cailin's Pasta $7.00

      bowtie pasta alfredo with chicken, carrots and peas

    • Anna's Chicken Tenders $7.00

      served with choice of fries, chips or mixed vegetables

  • Entrees
    • Chicken Santorini $13.00

      free range chicken breast stuffed with greek feta cheese. cured ham and spinach served over bowtie pasta with a roasted red pepper cream demi-glaze

    • Chicken Picatta $13.00

      white wine caper lemon butter sauce. served with bowtie alfredo

    • Chef Joseph's Chicken Continental $13.00

      breaded and sauteed chicken breast topped with scallions and tomatoes in a key lime butter parmesan sauce. served with bowtie alfredo

    • Seared Sea Scallops $19.00

      tender fresh sea scallops served over italian polenta seasoned with herbs. garlic and olives

    • Purple Island Mahi-Mahi $19.00

      fresh dolphin filets accompanied by a brandy lobster sauce over island rice, and served with ripe plantains

    • Buck Starck's Native Recipe $19.00

      locally caught fresh snapper filets with sauteed onions and tomatoes dressed with key-lime parsley butter. served with island rice and ripe plantains

    • New York Strip Steak $22.00

      blackened or sauteed ny strip cooked to temperature and served with oven roasted potatoes and mixed vegetables

    • Veal Chops A La Michael $24.00

      a house signature favorite, topped with leek cream and cabernet demi-glace. served with mixed vegetables

  • House Specialties
    • Filet A La Annie $24.00

      filet with a mushroom, shallot, red wine demiglace. served with roasted potatoes and mixed vegetables

    • Joseph's Famous Seafood Cardinal $28.00

      an assortment of the finest seafood caught fresh daily and simmered with a brandy lobster cream sauce with fresh mushrooms over angel hair pasta

    • Lobster Termidor

      available seasonally to in sure the highest and freshest quality. the classic parisian delicacy created with fresh lobster tails and a blend of artisan cheeses

  • Cook Your Own Catch
    Adults $12 / Kids (12 Years & Younger, Please) $8
    • Prepared Five Different Ways

      served "family style" on a platter with island rice, vegetables and plantains. fried, blackened, sauteed, native and miniere

  • Desserts $6
    All Of Our Desserts Are Prepared In House Using Only The Freshest Ingredients
    • Traditional Key Lime Pie

    • Coconut Banana Cream Pie

    • Coconut Creme Brulee

    • Chocolate Cake

  • Hors D'oeuvres
    • Mini Brochette Jerk Chicken (Chicken On Skewers)

      with curry mango sauce

    • Mini Brochette Beef

      with guava barbeque sauce

    • Mini Sweet Potato Cupcake

      with key lime curry remoulade

    • Shrimp Cocktail

      with caribbean cocktail sauce

    • Artichoke Spinach Canapé

      with tostini

    • Sautéed Mini Quiche

    • Herb Crusted Seared Tuna Roll

      with ginger teriyaki mango glaze

    • Roasted Pork Tenderloin Canapé

      with mustard & mayonnaise

    • 5 Pepper Dip Canapé

    • Bacon Wrapped Beef

    • Tropical Fruit Tray

    • Domestic Or Imported Cheese Tray

  • Salads
    • Traditional Caesar Salad

    • Sunshine Salad

      with citrus balsamic vinaigrette (mixed baby greens, corn, sunflower seeds, grapefruit & orange slices, cucumber, diced tomatoes)

    • Bowtie Pasta Salad

    • Goat Cheese Salad

      with raspberry orange vinaigrette

    • Salad Exotic

      with coconut vinaigrette (mixed baby greens, papaya, heats of palm, and artichoke)

    • Greek Salad

    • Buffalo Mozzarella, Tomatoes, & Basil

      with balsamic glaze

  • Entrée
    • Marinated Roasted Pork Loin

      with rum glaze

    • Prime Rib Sliced Buffet Style

      with shallots burgundy demi-glaze

    • Chicken Ala Parisian

    • Beef Tenderloin Ala Bourguignon

    • Chicken Teriyaki

    • Seafood Au Gratin

      shrimp, scallops, & lobster

    • Yellowtail Almandine

      with orange butter sauce

    • Sautéed Mahi Creole

    • Seared Scallop Polenta

      with key lime butter sauce

  • Accoutrements
    All Buffets Come With French Dinner Rolls And Butter.
    • Island Rice

    • Rice Pilaf

    • Mash Sweet Potatoes

    • Mashed Potatoes

    • Steamed Asparagus

    • Mixed Garden Vegetables

    • Potatoes Au Gratin

  • Desserts
    • Key Lime Pie

    • Banana Coconut Cream Pie

    • Chocolate Cake

      with peach coulee

Menu for Hungry Tarpon Restaurant provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.