• Connecticut
  • Old Lyme
  • Pizza Plus

Pizza Plus

(860) 434-3282
  • 284 Shore Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • $$$$$
(860) 434-3282
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • Buffalo Wings with 2 Poppers $12.5

      12 pieces.

    • French Fries with Cheese $5.95

    • 8 Pieces Fried Mozzarella $8.95

    • Mild Wings with 2 Poppers $12.5

      12 pieces.

    • 8 Pieces Jalapenos $9.5

    • French Fries $4.5

    • Side of Meatballs with Sauce $7.5

    • 5 Pieces Chicken Fingers with Fries $9.95

    • Garlic Bread with Cheese $5.5

    • Side of Sausage with Sauce $7.5

    • Spicy Fries $6

      Blue cheese and hot sauce.

    • Onion Rings $7.5

    • Garlic Bread $3.5

    • Spinach Pie $11.95

      Served with a side of Greek salad.

    • Fried Clam Strips $9.95

  • Salads
    • Large Tossed Salad with Chicken $12.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and peppers.

    • Small Caesar Salad $7.75

    • Small Tossed Salad $7.75

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and peppers.

    • Large Antipasto Salad $12.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, turkey, ham, salami, pepperoni and cheese.

    • Large Tossed Salad $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and peppers.

    • Large House Special Salad $14.75

      Combination of Greek salad and antipasto salad.

    • Small Antipasto Salad $9.5

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, turkey, ham, salami, pepperoni and cheese.

    • Large Greek Island Salad $14.75

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, olives, feta cheese, pita bread and lamb gyro.

    • Small Greek Island Salad $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, olives, feta cheese, pita bread and lamb gyro.

    • Small Caesar Salad with Chicken $9.5

    • Small Tossed Salad with Chicken $9.5

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and peppers.

    • Large Tuna Salad $12.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers and tuna.

    • Small House Special Salad $10.95

      Combination of Greek salad and antipasto salad.

    • Large Caesar Salad with Chicken $12.95

    • Large Buffalo Chicken Salad $13.75

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and peppers.

    • Small Greek Salad $9.5

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, feta cheese, olives, stuffed grape leaves and pepperoncini.

    • Small Buffalo Chicken Salad $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and peppers.

    • Small Tuna Salad $9.5

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers and tuna.

    • Large Caesar Salad $9.95

    • Large Greek Salad $13.5

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, feta cheese, olives, stuffed grape leaves and pepperoncini.

  • Club Sandwiches
    All clubs are served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw, French fries and a pickle.
    • Ham Sandwich $12.25

    • Double Cheeseburger Sandwich $12.95

    • Italian Combo Sandwich $12.25

    • Tuna Sandwich $12.25

    • BLT Sandwich $12.25

    • Double Chicken Sandwich $12.95

    • Roast Beef Sandwich $12.25

    • Turkey Sandwich $12.25

  • Pita Bread Sandwiches
    All pita bread sandwiches come with French fries.
    • Philly Steak Pita Sandwich $9.95

      Mushrooms, onions, American cheese and mayo.

    • Tuna Pita Sandwich $9.95

      Comes with lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Chicken Pita Sandwich $9.95

    • American Philly Steak Pita Sandwich $9.95

      Crispy bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.

    • Turkey Pita Sandwich $9.95

  • Pizzas
    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
    • 18" Two Topping Cheese Pizza $19.95

    • 18" One Topping Cheese Pizza $18.95

    • 10" One Topping Cheese Pizza $9.75

      Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    • 14" Three Topping Cheese Pizza $16.25

    • 14" Two Topping Cheese Pizza $15.95

    • 18" Three Topping Cheese Pizza $21.5

    • 10" Two Topping Cheese Pizza $12.25

    • 14" One Topping Cheese Pizza $14.5

    • 10" Three Topping Cheese Pizza $12.75

  • Specialty Pizzas
    All pizzas come with red sauce.
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $12.95

    • Scallops Pizza $13.95

    • Shrimp Pizza $13.95

    • Pesto Chicken White Pizza $13.95

    • BBQ Chicken Pizza $12.95

    • Mozzarella Pizza $8.95

    • Chicken Pizza $12.95

  • Gourmet Pizzas
    All pizzas come with red sauce.
    • Shepherd Pizza $13.95

      White sauce or red sauce. Mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, spinach, roasted peppers and feta cheese.

    • Land & Sea Pizza $12.95

      Mozzarella cheese, clams, broccoli and garlic.

    • Florentine Pizza $11.95

      Mozzarella cheese and feta cheese, spinach, sliced tomatoes and olive oil.

    • Greek Pizza $13.25

      Mozzarella cheese and feta cheese, onions, sliced tomatoes, black olives and peppers.

    • Greek Island Pizza $13.95

      White sauce or red sauce. Mozzarella cheese, scallops, shrimp, feta cheese, spinach, bacon and tomatoes.

    • Cioppino Pizza $11.95

      Mozzarella cheese and Parmesan cheese, sliced tomatoes, garlic and olive oil.

    • Ranch Chicken Pizza $13.25

      White sauce. Mozzarella cheese, chicken, bacon, tomatoes, onions and ranch dressing.

    • Low Calorie Pizza $12.95

      Mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, artichokes, black olives and sliced tomatoes.

    • Fiesta Pizza $13.25

      White sauce. Mozzarella cheese, sauteed onions, ground beef, tomatoes, jalapenos, hot sauce and roasted peppers.

    • Meat Lover's Pizza $13.25

      Bacon, pepperoni, hamburger and meatballs.

    • Mexican Spice Pizza $12.95

      White sauce. Mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese, buffalo chicken, basil, hot sauce and pepperoncini.

    • Captain's Pizza $13.25

      Mozzarella cheese, scallops, shrimp, clams and a touch of garlic.

    • Shrimp Scampi Pizza $12.95

      White sauce or red sauce. Mozzarella cheese, shrimp and garlic.

    • Hawaiian Pizza $11.95

      Mozzarella cheese, ham or bacon and pineapple.

    • Mona Lisa Pizza $11.95

      Mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese, broccoli and sliced tomatoes with a touch of garlic.

    • Vegetarian Pizza $13.25

      Mozzarella cheese, eggplant, mushrooms, onions, sliced tomatoes, black olives, peppers and broccoli.

    • Casino Pizza $13.95

      Mozzarella cheese, clams, shrimp, bacon, sliced tomatoes, jalapeno and a touch of garlic.

    • Shrimp Athenian Pizza $13.95

      Mozzarella cheese and feta cheese, shrimp, pepperoni, sliced tomatoesand black olives.

    • Pizza Plus Special $13.95

      Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, peppers, sausage, hamburger and bacon.

    • Gyro Pizza $12.95

      White sauce, mozzarella cheese, cucumber sauce, lamb gyro, sliced tomatoes and red onions with feta cheese, additional.

    • Margherita Pizza $11.95

      Mozzarella cheese, sliced tomatoes, garlic, basil and olive oil.

    • Mediterranean Pizza $13.25

      White sauce. Mozzarella cheese and feta cheese, chicken, kalamata olives and pesto.

    • Popeye Pizza $11.95

      Mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese, sliced tomatoes, spinach and a touch of garlic.

  • Calzones
    • Calzone with Cheese $10.5

      Stuffed with ricotta cheese and mozzarella cheese.

  • Hot Oven Grinders & Subs
    All subs come dry unless otherwise requested. All subs come with fries.
    • Small Veal Cutlet Sub $8.25

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Roast Beef Grinder $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Fish Fillet Cod Grinder $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and oil.

    • Small Chicken Cutlet Grinder $8.25

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Roast Beef Sub $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Fish Fillet Cod Sub $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and oil.

    • Small Sausage Sub $7.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Eggplant Parmesan Grinder $7.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Cooked Salami Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Chicken Parmesan Sub $10.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Tuna Grinder $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Vegetarian Sub $10.95

      Eggplant, onions, peppers, olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Small Pepper & Egg Sub $7.95

      Sauce and cheese.

    • Large American Philly Steak Sub $12.95

      Crispy bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoesand mayo.

    • Small Fish Fillet Cod Sub $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and oil.

    • Large Veal Cutlet Sub $11.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Chicken Cutlet Grinder $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Pepperoni Sub $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Veal Cutlet Grinder $11.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Genoa Salami Sub $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Turkey Sub $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Roast Beef Sub $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small American Philly Steak Sub $9.95

      Crispy bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.

    • Large Italian Combo Grinder $10.95

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Large Pepper & Egg Sub $9.95

      Sauce and cheese.

    • Large BLT Grinder $10.95

      Mayo.

    • Large Pepperoni Sub $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Eggplant Parmesan Sub $10.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Cheeseburger Grinder $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Pepperoni Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small American Philly Steak Grinder $9.95

      Crispy bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.

    • Small Philly Steak Grinder $8.95

      Peppers, onions and American cheese.

    • Small Genoa Salami Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Cheeseburger Grinder $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Meatball Grinder $7.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Turkey Grinder $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Philly Steak Sub $11.95

      Peppers, onions and American cheese.

    • Large Pastrami Sub $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Sausage Sub $9.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Pastrami Sub $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Eggplant Parmesan Sub $7.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Sausage Grinder $7.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Chicken Parmesan Sub $8.25

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Genoa Salami Sub $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Turkey Sub $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Ham Grinder $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Cheeseburger Sub $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Chicken Parmesan Grinder $8.25

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Pepperoni Grinder $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Buffalo Chicken Sub $8.25

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and blue cheese.

    • Small Turkey Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Chicken Cutlet Sub $8.25

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Tuna Sub $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Vegetarian Sub $7.95

      Eggplant, onions, peppers, olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Large Eggplant Parmesan Grinder $10.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Pepper & Egg Grinder $9.95

      Sauce and cheese.

    • Large Tuna Sub $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Ham Sub $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Italian Combo Sub $7.95

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Small Vegetarian Grinder $7.95

      Eggplant, onions, peppers, olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, lettuceand cheese.

    • Large American Philly Steak Grinder $12.95

      Crispy bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoesand mayo.

    • Large Italian Combo Sub $10.95

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Small Italian Combo Grinder $7.95

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Small Veal Cutlet Grinder $8.25

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Ham Sub $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Cooked Salami Sub $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Roast Beef Grinder $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Pepper & Egg Grinder $7.95

      Sauce and cheese.

    • Small Fish Fillet Cod Grinder $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and oil.

    • Small BLT Sub $7.95

      Mayo.

    • Large Meatball Grinder $9.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Buffalo Chicken Grinder $8.25

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cheeseand blue cheese.

    • Large Genoa Salami Grinder $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Chicken Parmesan Grinder $10.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Cooked Salami Sub $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Pastrami Grinder $11.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Buffalo Chicken Grinder $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and blue cheese.

    • Large Cooked Salami Grinder $9.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Meatball Sub $9.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Pastrami Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Buffalo Chicken Sub $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and blue cheese.

    • Small Philly Steak Sub $8.95

      Peppers, onions and American cheese.

    • Large Sausage Grinder $9.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Small Cheeseburger Sub $8.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Chicken Cutlet Sub $10.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small Tuna Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Large Vegetarian Grinder $10.95

      Eggplant, onions, peppers, olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

    • Small Meatball Sub $7.95

      Sauce, cheese and peppers.

    • Large Philly Steak Grinder $11.95

      Peppers, onions and American cheese.

    • Large BLT Sub $10.95

      Mayo.

    • Small Ham Grinder $7.95

      Lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

    • Small BLT Grinder $7.95

      Mayo.

  • Gyros
    Served on pita bread.
    • Lamb Gyro $11.99

      Strips of lamb with onions, tomatoes and cucumber sauce with French fries.

    • Chicken Gyro $11.99

      Strips of chicken with onions, tomatoes and cucumber sauce with French fries.

  • Super Burgers
    Comes with fries.
    • Cheeseburger $10.95

    • Golden Burger with Bacon $11.95

    • Hamburger $9.95

    • Pizza Plus Burger $12.95

      Bacon, cheese, mushrooms, onions, peppers, lettuce and tomatoes.

  • Pasta Dinners
    All dinners are served with a small tossed salad and garlic bread.
    • Veal Parmigiana $16.95

    • Stuffed Peppers $14.75

    • Stuffed Shells with Roasted Peppers Dinner $13.95

      4 jumbo pieces.

    • Stuffed Shells with Meatballs Dinner $14.75

      4 jumbo pieces.

    • Boss Pasta Parmigiana $17.95

      Chopped bacon, meatballs, peppers, broccoli, onions, tomatoes and mushrooms.

    • Homemade Lasagna $14.95

    • Baked Ziti $14.95

      With bacon and ricotta cheese.

    • Stuffed Shells with Mushrooms Dinner $13.95

      4 jumbo pieces.

    • Stuffed Shells Dinner $12.95

    • Ziti with Homestyle Sauce $11.95

    • King's Pasta Meal $18.95

    • Meat Ravioli $11.95

    • Linguine with Homestyle Sauce $11.95

    • Chicken Parmigiana $15.95

    • Baked Stuffed Eggplant $14.95

      With meatballs, sausage and ricotta cheese.

    • Linguine with Clams $14.95

    • Stuffed Shells with Sausage Dinner $14.75

      4 jumbo pieces.

    • Cheese Ravioli $11.95

  • Seafood Dinners
    All dinners are served with French fries and coleslaw.
    • 12 Pieces Fried Shrimp Dinner $16.95

    • 3 Pieces Fish & Chips Dinner $14.95

    • Fried Clam Strips $15.95

    • 12 Pieces Seafood Combo Platter Dinner $19.95

      Filet of cod, shrimp and clam strips.

  • Beverages
    • Juice $2.89

    • Water $1.85

    • Soda $1.25

    • Iced Tea $2.89

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.