Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Commack
  • Athenian Greek Tavern

Athenian Greek Tavern

(631) 499-7660

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 2187 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
  • Restaurant website
  • Greek
  • $$$$$
  • Athenian Greek Tavern

  • (631) 499-7660
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Appetizers
    • Spanakopita $8.00

      Spinach pie layers of phyllo dough w/ spinach greens & feta mixture.

    • Falafel $8.00

      Ground chick peas & spices fried golden brown

    • Yia Yia's Eggplant $8.00

      Eggplant topped w/ 3cheeses & tomato sauce

    • Gigantes $8.00

      Giant butter beans. Gluten free

    • Dolmathakia $8.00

      Grapeleaves stuffed w/ rice

    • Keftedes Greek Meatballs $8.00

      Pan fried, E.V.O.O.

    • Gyro Sliders $8.00

      3 mini gyros, chicken or lamb w/ lettuce, tom, onion and tzatzikill

    • Pork Stick $3.00

      Tender marinated cubes of pork on a stick. Gluten free

    • Land and Sea $10.00

      Little neck clams, loucaniko, scampi sauce. Gluten free

    • P.E.I. Mussels $9.00

      Sauteed mussels in our famous scampi sauce.

    • Fried Calamari $9.00

      Breaded and fried squid

    • Grilled Octopus $13.00

      Char-grilled w/ E.V.O.O. Lemon essence & imported greek oregano. Gluten free

    • Taramosalata $8.00

      Red caviar spread. Gluten free

    • Potato Chips $5.00

      House made dusted w/ greek oregano & parmesan served w/ spicy ketchup.

    • Hummus $8.00

      Ground chick pea spread. Gluten free

    • Pita Chips $3.00

      Seasoned pita wedges fried

    • Pita Chips Dipping Sauces $8.00

      Honey mustard, ygt, hummus.

    • Scordalia $8.00

      Creamy garlic & potato spread. Gluten free

    • Htipiti $8.00

      Spicy feta dip. Gluten free

    • Saganaki $8.00

      Broiled kasseri cheese w/ E.V.O.O. & tomatoes served on firers. Gluten free

    • Grilled Halloumi $8.00

      Cypriot halloumi cheese grilled w/E.V.O.O. Gluten free

  • Greek Salad
    We use the freshest ingredients in our salads. All greek salads come with shredded iceberg lettuce, ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, red onions, kalamat a black olives, stuffed grapeleaves, pepperoncini, hot peppers and pastuerized feta only yia yia could make it better.
    • Our Famous Greek Salad $9.00+

    • Greek Salad with Chicken $11.00+

    • Mediterranean Salad $11.00+

      Salad w/ gyro meat.

    • Greek Salad w/ Palapel $11.00+

    • Greek Salad w/ Shrimp $17.00

    • Greek Salad w/ Salmon $18.00

  • Specialty Salad
    Add chicken, gyro meator falafel $5.50. Add salmon, shrimp or pork souvlaki $7.50
    • Athenian $10.50

      A fresh mix of mesculin greens w/ red onions, cucumbers, peppers, tomatoes & imported feta. Topped w/ fire roasted red pepper & onion balsamic relish. Gluten free

    • Nostalgia $11.50

      A fresh mix of spinach & purple cabbage, grilled eggplant, mushrooms, roasted peppers, imported kasseri cheese and kalamata olives, served w/ pita chips and housemade honey mustard dressing.

    • Horiatiki $10.50

      A traditional greek salad no lettuce chunks of tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, bell peppers, olives & imported feta. Drizzled w/ housemade vinaigrette. Gluten free

    • Athenian Spring Roll $15.00

      Chicken, eggplant, roasted peppers, shredded halloumi cheese, sauteed and stuffed in fresh pita draped in panko, surrounded by pita chips and served over our athenian salad.

  • Soups, Sides
    • Avgolemono $3.50

    • Soup of The Day $3.50

    • Rice Pilaf $4.50

    • Basket of Fries $4.50

    • Patates Sto Forno $4.50

      Oven roasted lemon potatoes

    • Vegetables $4.50

      Gluten free

    • Orzo $8.00

      Rice shaped pasta in tomato sauce

  • Sandwiches
    Served w/ soup or salad substitute fries add $1.00
    • Zeus $11.50

      Seasoned lamb gyro sliced thin

    • Gyro Meet $11.50

      open faced gyro with melted kasseri cheese

    • Apollo $11.50

      Tender marinated cubes of chicken. Gluten free

    • Odysseus $11.50

      Gyro or chicken souvlaki. Sauteed onions and feta topped with honey mustard

    • Falafel $11.50

      Ground chick peas & spices fried golden brown

    • King George $11.50

      Tender marinated cubes of pork. Gluten free

    • Greek Pizza $11.50

      Spinach and feta mixture on a pita topped with marinara and kasseri cheese. Add chicken or gyro $3.00

  • Lunches
    Served w/ soup or salad & rice or potatoes. Substitute add $1.00
    • Gyro Platter $16.00

      Thinly sliced gyro meat

    • Chicken Souvlaki Platter $16.00

      Marinated cubes of grilled chicken. Gluten free

    • Plato Platter $16.00

      Marinated cubes of beef tri-tip. Gluten free

    • King George Platter $16.00

      Pork souvlaki marinated cubes of pork. Gluten free

    • Falafel Platter

      Ground chick peas & spices fried golden brown

    • Mt. Olympus Platter $19.00

      Gyro chicken beef pork

    • Yia Yia's Eggplant $13.00

      Eggplant topped w/ cheeses & tomato sauce

    • Spanakopita $13.00

      Spinach pie-layers of phyllo dough w/ spinach greens & feta mixture

    • Mousaka $16.00

      Layers of eggplant, potatoes and chopmeat. Topped with bechamel cream sauce

    • Pastichio $16.00

      Layers of macaroni and chopmeat. Topped with bechamel cream sauce

    • Chicken Akrata $16.00

      Stuffed chicken breast w/ spinach and feta topped w/ avgolemono sauce

    • Chicken Kebob $14.00

      Skewered w/ tom onion, pepper. Gluten free

    • Lamb Kebob $17.00

      Skewered w/ tom onion, pepper. Gluten free

    • Half Roasted Chicken $12.00

      Rotisserie style, E.V.O.O. lemon essence oregano. Gluten free

    • Grilled Octopus $19.00

      Char grilled E.V.O.O., lemon essence, oregano. Gluten free

    • Catch of The Day

      Fresh assortment of whole fish and fillets available. Please ask your server. Gluten free

  • Lunch Specials
    • The Combo Wrap $8.00

      Our famous greek salad wrapped in a pita. Served with a hearty bowl of soup. Add chicken or gyro meat $2.00

    • Chicken Yee-ro $12.00

      Hand stacked fresh chx cutlets, marinated and spiced greek style. Thinly shaved from our rotisserie. Have it 2 ways: either over a greek salad or wrapped in a pita with the fixins and a greek salad or fries. Gluten free

    • The Geargie $11.50

      Sliced gyro meat, wrapped in a pita stuffed with our famous orzo pasta and melted feta cheese. Includes a choice of soup or salad. Son and nephew approved

    • Yanni's Gyro $11.50

      Thinly sliced gyro piled high with roasted onions and tomatoes served inside warm pita slathered in spicy feta, topped with sriracha spiked tzatziki sauce. Served with your choice of soup or salad.

    • Spinach Pie Special $10.00

      Half a slice of spinach pie served with oven roasted lemon potatoes and salad

    • Stuffed Tilapia W/ Mussels $12.00

      Fillet of tilapia stuffed with spinach and feta surronded by mussels prepared scampi style. Served with a side of rice and your choice of soup or salad.

  • Appetizers - Seafood
    • Fried Calamari $9.00

      Breaded and fried squid

    • P.E.I. Mussels $9.00

      Sauteed mussels in our famous scampi sauce

    • Little Neck Clams $10.00

      Fresh little neck clams in scampi sauce

    • Grilled Octopus $14.00

      Char-grilled w/ E.V.O.O. lemon essence & imported greek oregano

    • Land & Sea $10.00

      Little neck clams and loucaniko in scampi sauce

  • Appetizers - Meats
    • Pork Stick $8.50

      Tender marinated cubes of pork on a stick $3.00

    • Chicken Souvlaki $8.50

      Tender marinated cubes of chicken

    • Gyro Meat $8.50

      Gyro meat sliced thin

    • Keftedes Greek Meatballs $8.50

      Pan fried in E.V.O.O.

    • Loucaniko $8.50

      Greek sausage imported from the island of cypress, barbequed over the open flame

    • Gyro Sliders $8.50

      3 mini gyros, chicken or lamb w/ lettuce, tomato and onion

  • Appetizers - Vegetables & Grains
    • Spanakopita $8.50

      Spinach pie-layers of phyllo dough w/ spinach greens and feta mixture

    • Falafel $8.50

      Ground chick peas and spices fried golden brown

    • Yia Yia's Eggplant $8.50

      Eggplant topped with three cheeses and tomato sauce

    • Fried Zucchini $8.50

      Batter fried zucchini served with scordalia

    • Gigantes $8.50

      Giant butter beans

    • Pita Chips $8.50

      Seasoned pita wedges fried and served with honey mustard, tzatziki, and hummus

    • Orzo $8.50

      Rice shaped pasta in tomato sauce

    • Dolmathakia $8.50

      Grapeleaves stuffed with rice

    • Potato Chips $5.00

      House made dusted with greek oregano & parmesan cheese. Served with spicy ketchup

  • Appetizers - Dips & Spreads
    • Fava $8.50

      Split pea puree with capers and red onions

    • Htipiti $8.50

      Spicy feta dip

    • Hummus $8.50

      Ground chick pea spread

    • Roasted Red Pepper Hummus $8.50

      Hummus infused with roasted red peppers

    • Scordalia $8.50

      Creamy garlic potato spread

    • Babaganouge $8.50

      Fire roasted eggplant dip

    • Tzatziki $8.50

      Yogurt sauce

    • Taramosalata $8.50

      Red caviar spread

  • Appetizers - Cheeses
    • Imported Feta $8.50

      Sliced and drizzled with E.V.O.O.

    • Broiled Feta $8.50

      Broiled feta drizzled with E.V.O.O. and greek oregano

    • Grilled Halloumi $8.50

      Cypriot halloumi cheese grilled with E.V.O.O.

    • Saganaki $8.50

      Broiled kasseri cheese with E.V.O.O and tomatoes. Served on fire

    • Tiropitakia $8.50

      Five individual cheese pies wrapped in phyllo

  • Appetizers - Shareable Samplers
    Served w/ warm pita both samplers feed two
    • Pekelia, Cold Sampler $15.00

      Hummus, babaganouge, grapeleaves, taramosalata, olives and imported feta cheese

    • Bekri Meze Hot Sampler $16.00

      Loucaniko, keftedes, spanakopitakia, tiropitakia, hummus and tzatziki

  • Soup
    • Avgolemono $3.50

    • Soup of The Day $3.50

  • Salads
    All greek salads are prepared with shredded iceberg lettuce, imported feta cheese, ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, red onions, kalamata olives, stuffed grapeleaves and pepperonchini hot peppers. Anchovies add $2.00
    • Our Famous Greek Salad $12.50

    • Greek Salad with Falafel $17.00

    • Greek Salad with Chicken $17.00

    • Greek Salad with Shrimp $18.50

    • Mediterranean Salad $17.00

      Salad with gyro meat

    • Greek Salad with Salmon $18.50

  • Specialty Salad
    Add chicken, gyro meat or falafel $5.50. Add salmon, shrimp or pork souvlaki $8.00
    • Athenian Salad $11.50

      A fresh mix of mesculin greens, red onions, cucumbers, peppers, tomatoes, and imported feta. Topped with fire roasted red pepper & onion balsamic relish.

    • Nostalgia $13.50

      A fresh mix of spinach and purple cabbage, grilled eggplant, mushrooms, roasted peppers, imported kasseri cheese, and kalamata olives. Served with pita chips and housemade honey mustard dressing.

    • Horiatiki $11.50

      A traditional greek salad no lettuce chunks of tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, bell peppers, olives and imported feta cheese. Drizzled with housemade vinaigrette.

    • Athenian Spring Roll $16.50

      Chicken, eggplant, roasted peppers, halloumi cheese, sauteed and stuffed in fresh pita draped in panko, surrounded by pita chips and served over our athenian salad.

  • Sandwiches
    All sandwiches are served with soup or salad & rice or lemon potatoes. Substitute fries add $1.00. Add chicken or gyro meat $3.00
    • Zeus (Gyro) $14.00

      Seasoned lamb gyro meat sliced thin with lettuce, tomato, and onion.

    • Gyro Melt $14.00

      Open faced with gyro meat and melted kasseri cheese.

    • Apollo (Chicken Souvlaki) $14.00

      Tender marinated cubes of chicken with lettuce, tomato, and onion.

    • Plato $14.00

      Tender marinated cubes of beef with lettuce, tomato, and onion.

    • Odysseus $14.00

      Gyro meat or chicken souvlaki with lettuce, tomato, sauteed onions and feta. Topped with honey mustard.

    • Falafel $14.00

      Ground chick peas, garlic and spices fried golden brown with lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • King George $14.00

      Tender marinated cubes of pork with lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Greek Pizza $14.00

      Spinach and feta mixture on a pita topped with marinara and kasseri cheese.

  • Main Menu
    Served with soup or salad and rice or lemon potatoes. Sustitute fries add $1.00
    • Yia Yia's Eggplant $15.00

      Fresh eggplant topped with tomato sauce and three cheeses.

    • Yemistes Pipergies $15.00

      Bell pepper stuffed with chopmeat and rice, topped with feta.

    • Spanakopita, Spinach Pie $15.00

      Layers of phyllo dough stuffed with spinach and feta mixture.

    • Moussaka $18.00

      Layers of eggplant, potatoes, and chopmeat, topped with bechamel cheese sauce.

    • Pastichio $18.00

      Layers of macaroni and chopmeat, topped with bechamel cheese sauce.

    • Combo Platter $20.00

      A combination of pastichio, moussaka, and spinach pie.

    • Chicken Akrata $17.00

      Chicken breast stuffed with spinach and feta. Topped with avgolemono sauce.

    • Chicken Athenian $19.00

      Twin chicken breasts char-grilled with E.V.O.O., greek oregano, and lemon essence. Served with gigandes.

    • Kota Me Kapari $19.00

      Twin chicken breasts with artichokes and capers in a lemon white wine sauce.

    • Kota A La Corfu $19.00

      Twin chicken breasts with roasted red peppers and artichokes in a light tomato broth, topped with melted feta.

    • Kota A La Mykonos $19.00

      Twin chicken breasts sauteed with fresh spinach, mushrooms, and sliced potatoes in a spicy white wine sauce, topped with melted saganaki cheese.

  • From The BBQ
    Served with soup or salad and rice or lemon everything. In this section is gluten free. Substitute fries add $1.00
    • Potatoes

      This section of the menu is near and dear to yia yia's heart. Everything is prepared tis skaras style, which simply means cooked over the open flame with E.V.O.O., fresh squeezed lemon, imported greek oregano, and of course a lot of love.

    • Chicken Kebob $16.00

    • Beef Kebob $16.00

    • Lamb Kebob $19.00

    • Kontosouvli $18.00

      Fresh roasted pork

    • Arni Tis Souvlas $22.00

      Fresh roasted lamb

    • Marinated Pork Chops $19.00

    • Half Roasted Chicken $13.00

    • Whole Roasted Chicken $18.00

  • Mythological Platters
    Served with soup or salad and rice or lemon potatoes. Substitute fries add $1.00.
    • Gyro Platter $18.00

      Gyro meat sliced thin.

    • Chicken Platter $18.00

      Chicken souvlaki, marinated cubes of chicken.

    • Plato Platter $18.00

      Beef souvlaki, marinated cubes of beef.

    • King George Platter $18.00

      Pork souvlaki, marinated cubes of pork.

    • Falafel Platter $18.00

      Pureed chick peas and spices fried golden brown.

    • Mt. Olympus Platter $20.00

      A mix of your favorite meats, gyro meat, chicken, beef and pork souvlaki.

  • From The Sea
    Served with soup or salad and rice or lemon potatoes, substitute fries add $1.00.
    • P.E.I. Mussels $17.00

      Sauteed in our famous scampi sauce.

    • Little Neck Clams $18.00

      Sauteed in scampi sauce.

    • Grilled Octopus $22.00

      Char-grilled with E.V.O.O., lemon essence and greek oregano.

    • Stuffed Shrimp $21.00

      Jumbo shrimp, seafood stuffing, scampi sauce.

    • Shrimp Santorini $20.00

      Shrimp sauteed with E.V.O.O., garlic and tomatoes topped with feta over rice.

    • Seafood Carnival $22.00

      Mussels, clams, and shrimp sauteed in scampi sauce. Served with rice.

  • Whole Grilled Fish
    Served with soup or salad and rice or lemon potatoes. Substitute fries add $1.00
    • Synagrida Red Snapper

      Mild sweet flavor, firm, moist texture.

    • Lavraki Striped Bass

      Mild flavor, firm, moist texture.

    • Bronzino Meditteranean Sea Bass

      Sweet flavor, moist texture.

    • Tsipoura Porgies

      Mild to sweet flavor, firm, flaky texture.

    • Rainbow Trout

      This fish can be stuffed, mild delicate flavor, tender, flaky texture.

  • Fillet Bar
    Please ask your server for prices
    • Broiled

      Choose a fillet: salmon, tilapia, fresh water bass, fillet of sole. Select a sauce: scampi, avgolemono, E.V.O.O. Fresh, lemon & greek, oregano

    • Stuffed

      Seafood stuffed or spinach & feta. Choose a fillet: salmon, tilapia, fresh water bass, fillet of sole. Select a sauce: scampi, avgolemono, E.V.O.O. Fresh, lemon & greek, oregano

  • Evening Specials - Appetizers
    • Tiropitakia Ke Spanakopitakia $8.00

      Individually wrapped cheese pies and spinach pies. Served with house made tzatziki.

    • Trio of Dips $10.00

      Classic creamy hummus, spicy feta and taramosalata, all topped with extra virgin olive oil. Served with crunchy pita chips. Feeds 2

    • Athenian Egg Rolls $8.00

      Diced chicken, roasted red peppers, onions, roasted garlic and saganaki cheese, rolled in wonton wrappers and flash fried. Served with sriracha spiked tzatziki. Yia-yia has gone pacific rim

    • Souvlakia $8.00

      Two skewers with pork souvlaki and two with chicken souvlaki served with pita and tzatziki.

    • Land and Sea $10.00

      Fresh little neck clams and greek sausage sauteed in a garlic white wine sauce.

  • Evening Specials - Entrees
    • Grilled Octopus $23.00

      Tender octopus char-grilled with E.V.O.O. Greek oregano and lemon essence.

    • Kebob Combo $25.00

      One skewer of our famous chicken and another skewer of juicy lamb, cooked with tomatoes, onions and peppers over the open flame.

    • Yia Yia's Bass and Shrimp $23.00

      A classic greek dish baked water bass fillet and jumbo shrimp cooked with tomatoes, onions and garlic in a light tomato sauce.

    • Kota Ke Loucaniko $19.00

      Chicken breast and greek sausage sauteed with red onions, fresh spinach, roasted peppers and in a spicy white wine sauce, topped with melted saganaki cheese.

    • Catch of The Day $9.00+

      Please ask you server for today's whole fish. All whole fish are char-grilled with E.V.O.O. Greek oregano and lemon essence. P/A

  • Sides
    • Over Roasted lemon $4.50

    • Potatoes $4.50

    • Rice Pilaf $4.50

    • Basket of Fries $4.50

    • Vegetables $4.50

  • Pastses Ke Pagota
    • Baklava $4.00

      Layers of phyllo dough filled w/ nuts, cinnamon & sugar. Baked and drenched in honey syrup.

    • Kataifi $4.00

      Shredded phyllo dough filled w/ nuts, cinnamon & sugar. Baked and drenched in honey syrup

    • Kourambiedes $4.00

      Greek butter cookies w/ almonds, nuts topped w/ powdered sugar. These are yia yia's jam

    • Rizogalo $4.00

      A creamy blend of rice, sugar, cinnamon, eggs and cream. Only yia yia herself could make it better

    • Greek Yogurt $4.00

      Greek yogurt, drizzled w/ honey and topped w/ nuts. A delightfully simple and refreshing dessert

    • Ice cream Sundae $4.00

      Vanilla Choc topped w/chocolate sauce & whipped cream

    • Tartufo $6.00

      Spumoni tartufo strawberry, pistachio and chocolate gelato w/ halzelnuts, a cherry, all dipped in chocolate

  • Kafes Ke Tzai
    • Iced Coffee Greek Style $4.00

    • Herbal $3.00

      Reg, decaf $2.00

    • American Coffee $2.00

      Regular, decaf

    • Greek Coffee - Sketo $3.00

      Plain

    • Greek Coffee - Metrios $3.00

      Medium

    • Greek Coffee - Glykos $3.00

      Sweet

Menu for Athenian Greek Tavern provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.