Old Chicago

3580 E 2nd St
Casper, WY 82609

(307) 473-1900

Strombolis

named after the stromboli volcano, this unique Italian sandwich is erupting with flavor. Savory ingredients are wrapped in our homemade pizzini dough and baked until golden brown. Served with your choice of fries, coleslaw or fresh vegetables with ranch d

  • Best Italian Sausage
    •  
    • $7.99
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Spicy Italian sausage, roasted onions, peppers and our fire-roasted marinara with parmesan, Romano and mozzarella cheese baked in our homemade pizzini bread
  • Meatball
    •  
    • $7.89
  • homemade meatballs smothered with fire-roasted marinara fresh basil and melted parmesan, Romano and mozzarella cheeses all wrapped in our homemade pizzini bread
  • New Philly Chicken
    •  
    • $7.89
  • roasted chicken breast with sweet onions, fire-roasted peppers and mushrooms. Smothered in mozzarella and cheddar cheeses and drizzled with green chili ranch sauce
  • Turkey
    •  
    • $7.89
  • roasted turkey breast, hickory-smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, ranch dressing and tomatoes stuffed into our pizzini bread and baked golden brown
Sandwiches

we've got it all-your traditional favorites and our own special creations. Served with your choice of fries, coleslaw or fresh vegetables with ranch dressing. Substitute a side salad enjoy our house salad or side caesar instead of fries or fresh veggies f

  • Classic Club
    •  
    • $7.99
  • a triple-decker pilled high with smoked turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo on toasted sourdough
  • Grilled Chicken Wrap
    •  
    • $7.79
  • a sandwich with a twist. Grilled chicken breast tucked in a tortilla with crisp lettuce, diced tomatoes, red onions and parmesan cheese drizzled with our tangy house Italian dressing
  • Best Hot Italian Beef Sandwich
    •  
    • $7.99
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. A Chicago favorite and sure to be one of yours. Tender, thin-sliced roast beef, slow-cooked in rich garlic au jus, topped with spicy peppers on a French roll
  • Best Classic Italian Melt
    •  
    • $7.99
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Layers of salami, pepperoni and turkey topped with lettuce, tomatoes, pepperoncinis, provolone and the right touch of red pepper mayo-all on toasted light rye bread
  • Chicken Blat Wrap
    •  
    • $7.79
  • a tempting take on the classic. Grilled chicken breast, bacon, guacamole, field greens, diced tomatoes and green chili ranch wrapped in a tortilla
  • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
    •  
    • $7.89
  • marinated chicken breast covered with homemade parmesan breadcrumbs. Served on a toasted French roll with melted mozzarella and our fire-roasted marinara
Burgers

our half-pound burger are made from USDA choice steak, charboiled to perfection on a toasted sesame seed bun and garnished with tomato, pickle, red onions and shredded lettuce. Includes your choice of fries, coleslaw or fresh vegetables with ranch dressin

  • Add Cheese
  • Old Chicago Burger
    •  
    • $0.99
    • $6.89
  • a classic burger-plain, simple and clone right!
  • Add Bacon
  • Guacamole Burger
    •  
    • $0.99
    • $7.59
  • smothered with guacamole and melted pepper jack cheese for a little kick.
  • New Turkey Burger
    •  
    • $7.29
  • a charbroiled seasoned turkey burger layered with lettuce, tomato, onion and green chili ranch dressing atop a grilled bun
  • Add BBQ Sauce
  • Best Bacon Cheeseburger
    •  
    • $0.25
    • $7.99
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Topped with hickory-smoked bacon and your choice of cheddar, pepper jack, provolone or Swiss cheese.
  • Mushroom Double-Swiss
    •  
    • $7.29
  • topped with sauteed mushrooms and Swiss cheese
Desserts

what better way to top off a great meal than with one of our tempting desserts, created right here. They're big enough to share or take one home to enjoy later

  • Ala Mode
  • Old Chicago's Famous Big Cookie
    •  
    • $0.99
    • $4.29
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. There's no cookie jar big enough for this rich, homemade chocolate chip creation. Served piping hot in a pizza pan, it's a must-share treat for 2-3 people.
  • Little Big Cookie
    •  
    • $0.99
    • $2.29
  • just as wonderful as its big brother, but sized for one or two.
  • New Brownie Mousse Pie
    •  
    • $4.59
  • rich fudge-style homemade brownie, baked with semi-sweet chocolate chips, topped with a smooth and chilled chocolate mousse, garnished with toasted almonds and whipped cream. Deliciously decadent!
  • Turtle Cheesecake
    •  
    • $4.99
  • our delicious homemade cheesecake with the added pleasure of rich chocolate, caramel and pecans. Drizzled with chocolate for a delicious finish
  • Homemade Cheesecake
    •  
    • $4.59
  • it takes two days to make, but just seconds to devour. A double-sized, creamy slice of homemade cheesecake swirled with strawberry preserves on a graham cracker crust
Beverages

enjoy complimentary refills on fountain sodas, lemonade, iced or hot tea and coffee

  • Gourmet Root Beer and Soda
    •  
  • ask your server for flavors
  • Soda
    •  
  • Iced or Hot Tea
    •  
  • Lemonade
    •  
  • Regular or Decaf Coffee
    •  
  • Assorted Juices
    •  
  • orange, grapefruit, pineapple, cranberry, tomato and apple
Starters

get things rolling with some awesome appetizers. We've got something for everyone with plenty to share

  • Best Italian Nachos
    •  
    • $7.59
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. An old Chicago creation of golden pasta chips piled high with mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage and pepperoncinis served with pizza sauce
  • Our Best Wings
    •  
    • $7.79
  • three varieties to fit any mood our tangy buffalo, honey chipotle BBQ or smokin' jalapeno firehouse
  • Best Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls
    •  
    • $7.19
  • try our signature starter! Pizza dough rolled and baked with pepperoni, green onions, ranch dressing, pepper jack and mozzarella. Served with our homemade pizza sauce
  • Artichoke Dip
    •  
    • $7.29
  • a flavorful fusion of artichoke hearts, spices and melted cream cheese accompanied by vegetables and toasted garlic bread
  • Mozzarella Sticks
    •  
    • $6.49
  • crispy on the outside, tasty on the inside and rewarding with every bite. Served with our homemade pizza sauce
  • Best Signature Trio
    •  
    • $9.29
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. All three of old Chicago's best on one plate. Italian nachos, Sicilian pepperoni rolls and cheese garlic bread
  • Nachos Grande
    •  
    • $7.49
  • they're huge! Tortilla chips layered with black beans, anaheim peppers, red onions, tomatoes, cheese, cilantro, sour cream and our fresh homemade salsa. Add guacamole 1.29. Add chicken 1.99
  • Chicken Tenders-Buffalo or Original
    •  
    • $6.99
  • feeling spicy? Try our crisp and zesty buffalo-style chicken tenders served with blue cheese dressing. Or go for our original tenders with ranch dressing for dipping
  • Sampler Platter
    •  
    • $16.99
  • try a little of everything. Buffalo and honey chipotle BBQ wings, artichoke dip, mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders, fresh veggies and toasted garlic bread with a variety of dipping sauces. Ideal for four or more
  • Cheese Garlic Bread
    •  
    • $4.99
Salads

tossed fresh and made with the finest ingredients. Entree salads are served with toasted garlic bread

  • Crispy Chicken
    •  
    • $8.49
  • Romaine topped with crispy chicken, tomatoes, red and green onions and shredded cheeses. Served with ranch dressing
  • Honey BBQ Chicken Salad
    •  
    • $7.99
  • fresh greens tossed with sweet red pepper ranch dressing, topped with honey chipotle BBQ chicken, diced tomatoes and pepper, jack cheese. Garnished with corn tortilla strips and green onions
  • Best Oriental Chicken
    •  
    • $8.49
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Teriyai chicken layered over spiced chilled noodles, crisp greens, red bell peppers are covered with balsamic vinaigrette and sweet chili dressing, green onions, wonton chips and toasted sesame seeds
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar
    •  
    • $8.49
  • Romaine tossed with a tangy caesar dressing and crispy croutons. Topped with grilled chicken breast and fresh parmesan
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar with Classic Caesar
    •  
    • $5.99
  • New Southwestern Turkey Cobb Salad
    •  
    • $8.29
  • our twist on a cobb salad featuring a medley of oven-roasted turkey. Rome tomatoes, hard boiled eggs, sweet red pepper, red onions, crisp bacon, pepper jack cheese and topped with homemade guacamole. Served with green chili ranch dressing
Side Salads and Soup

  • Antipasto Salad
    •  
    • $3.79
  • a delicious combination of pepperoni, salami, mozzarella and provolone over greens tossed in Italian dressing. Garnished with tomato, green onions, pepperoncinis and black olives
  • Old Chicago's Famous House Salad
    •  
    • $3.49
  • fresh greens combined with tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, croutons and toasted almonds
  • Side Caesar
    •  
    • $3.29
  • Soup of the Day
    •  
    • $3.49
Classics

enjoy one of these tasty favorites. Steaks may be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats or poultry may increase your risk of foodborne illness

  • New Fisherman's Catch
    •  
    • $10.99
  • a combination of Sam Adams beer-battered cod fillets with six crispy shrimp, all lightly fried and served with sides of tartar and cocktail sauce, coleslaw and salt and vinegar fries
  • Fish and Chips
    •  
    • $9.59
  • a traditional favorite. Sam Adams beef-battered cod lightly fried and paired with salt and vinegar fries, zesty coleslaw and our tangy tartar sauce
  • Best Shrimp Basket
    •  
    • $10.59
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Nine crispy, plump breaded shrimp fried golden brown and served with our homemade chipotle lime cocktail sauce, fries and coleslaw. Add four extra shrimp for the perfect catch 2.00
  • Baked Chicken Parmesan
    •  
    • $9.69
  • marinated chicken breast covered with homemade parmesan breadcrumbs and baked to order. Smothered with marinara and melted mozzarella. Served with linguine marinara
  • New Steak and Shrimp Combo Platter
    •  
    • $12.49
  • our seasoned 8 ounce USDA choice top sirloin steak is grilled and topped with tarragon garlic butter plus four large breaded shrimp. Served with fries and fresh steamed vegetables
  • New O.C's Classic Grilled Sirloin Steak
    •  
    • $10.99
  • 8 ounce sirloin with fries and steamed vegetables
  • Crispy Chicken Tenders - Original or Buffalo
    •  
    • $9.29
  • breaded tenders served with fries and ranch dressing. Or heat things up with spicy buffalo tenders and our famous blue cheese dressing
Pastas

always good, our pastas are served with your choice of our house salad, side caesar or a cup of soup and toasted garlic bread

  • Best Chicken Alfredo
    •  
    • $10.69
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Creamy Alfredo sauce and oven-roasted chicken tossed with fettuccine
  • New Chicken Giovanni
    •  
    • $10.99
  • grilled chicken, cherry tomatoes, spinach, artichoke hearts, Anaheim peppers and sweet bell peppers tossed in a white wine sauce with penne pasta
  • Linguine and Meatballs
    •  
    • $9.59
  • three large, homemade meatballs served over our linguine tossed with fire-roasted marinara sauce. Sprinkled with fresh basil and parmesan cheese
  • Fire-Roasted Linguine Marinara
    •  
    • $8.59
  • Mushroom and Spinach Lasagna
    •  
    • $9.79
  • our vegetarian, lasagna baked in a creamy parmesan sauce and covered in marinara
  • New Chicken Penne Piccata
    •  
    • $10.89
  • garlic roasted chicken breast and penne pasta tossed in a butlery sauce of white wine, capers, sun-dried tomatoes and lemon juice
  • Best Traditional Meat Lasagna
    •  
    • $10.69
  • a favorite for over 30 years. Rich layers of mozzarella, provolone, parmesan and ricotta with Italian sausage and seasoned beef. Baked to perfection and smothered with our bolognese sauce
Calzones

try our famous calzones. you'll enjoy our signature dough filled with mouth-watering meats, fresh vegetables, a blend of mozzarella, parmesan and ricotta cheeses, baked to perfection

  • Build Your Own Zone
    •  
    • $8.99
  • do it your way. Choice of any three toppings plus melted cheese
  • Best Our Famous Chicago Seven
    •  
    • $9.79
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. A twist on our original Chicago seven pizza filled with Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, red onions and melted cheese
  • Meat Me
    •  
    • $9.39
  • meat lovers unite. A calzone packed with garlic-spiced Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, andouille sausage, pepperoni, roasted garlic, fresh basil and cheese
  • Southwestern Fajita Calzone
    •  
    • $9.29
  • a spicy combination of grilled chicken, homemade salsa, sliced anaheim peppers and a Mexican blend of cheeses. Served with a side of green chili ranch dressing
  • Add Chicken
  • Spinach Artichoke
    •  
    • $1.29
    • $8.99
  • a flavorful vegetarian blend of fresh spinach, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil and roasted garlic with melted cheese.
Individual Pizzas

have the perfect pizza made just for you. We've got several varieties with great toppings and a choice of two delicious crusts

  • Chicago-Style Crust
    •  
    • $9.59
  • you'll love this crust. Our made from scratch dough is baked thick and crispy with a rich buttery flavor
  • Thin Crust
    •  
    • $9.59
  • our homemade dough, hand-stretched and baked just right
  • Build Your Own
    •  
  • create your favorite or try something new with your choice of any three toppings. Additional toppings 1.09 each
  • Specialty Pizzas
    •  
  • any of our specialty pizzas can be made as individuals let our variety match your appetite
Create a Masterpiece

meats-pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, hickory ham, marinated chicken, andouille sausage, Canadian bacon, smoked bacon, anchovies and seasoned ground beef. Cheeses-extra mozzarella, cheddar, parmesan, provolone, ricotta and swiss. Veggies-mushrooms,

  • Thin Crust 14-Inch (Serves 2-3)
  • Large (Serves 3-4)
  • Medium (Serves 2-3)
  • Original Deep Dish or Chicago-Style 3 Toppings
    •  
    • $5.69
    • $19.69
    • $15.99
  • Original Deep Dish or Chicago-Style 2 Toppings
    •  
    • $13.99
    • $17.69
    • $14.29
  • Original Deep Dish or Chicago-Style 1 Toppings
    •  
    • $1.69
    • $1.99
    • $1.69
Stuffed Pizzas

all of the finest ingredlents stuffed between two layers of our homemade dough and baked to perfection

  • Best Our Stuffed "Chicago Seven"
    •  
    • $15.69
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, red onions and mozzarella stuffed in a baked crust
  • Build Your Own
    •  
    • $15.59
  • create your favorite with your choice of any three toppings
  • Spinach Artichoke
    •  
    • $14.99
  • a rich and flavorful vegetarian blend of fresh spinach, artichoke hearts, sun-dired tomatoes, fresh basil and toasted garlic with melted mozzarella,parmesan and ricotta cheeses
Specialty Pizzas

our signature pizzas are the cornertone of old chicago. We build them with only the finest ingredients and made our dough from scratch daily. Choose from out three homemade crusts: our original-style, our rich, crunchy chicage-style or our thin crust. Sav

  • Thin Crust 14-Inch (Serves 2-3)
  • Original Deep Dish or Chicago-Style Large (3-4)
  • Original Deep Dish or Chicago-Style Md(Serves 2-3)
  • Best Our Original "Chicago Seven"
    •  
    • $15.99
    • $19.99
    • $15.99
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. A 'conspiracy' of Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, black olives. green peppers, red onions and mozzarella cheese
  • Vegetarian Seven
    •  
    • $14.79
    • $18.49
    • $14.99
  • all of the flavor of the "Chicago seven" with roasted green chilies and tomatoes instead of the meat
  • Best Double Deckeroni
    •  
    • $14.89
    • $18.99
    • $15.49
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Double and two layers of mozzarella with a spicy pizza sauce
  • Meat Me
    •  
    • $16.29
    • $20.89
    • $16.69
  • garlic-spiced Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, andouille sausage, pepperoni, roasted garlic, fresh basil and mozzarella
  • New King of Hearts
    •  
    • $15.99
    • $19.99
    • $15.99
  • artichoke hearts, roasted garlic, red onions, roma tomatoes mozzarella and our rich, creamy artichoke and cheese sauce
  • Thai Pie
    •  
    • $14.99
    • $18.29
    • $14.79
  • roasted chicken, fresh mushrooms, red peppers and broccoli with thai chili pizza sauce. Topped with green onions, teriyaki, mozzarella and cheddar on a sesame seed crust
  • Best The Classic
    •  
    • $15.29
    • $18.99
    • $15.29
  • everything's good, but we've picked our favorites. Loads of pepperoni, mushrooms, Italian sausage, roasted garlic and mozzarella
  • Hawaiian
    •  
    • $15.29
    • $18.99
    • $15.29
  • Canadian bacon, pineapple, red peppers, green onions, mozzarella and sweet and pizza sauce
  • New Taos
    •  
    • $15.99
    • $19.99
    • $15.99
  • seasoned grilled chicken, roma tomatoes, roasted green chilies, fresh cilantro , mozzarella and cheddar cheese with a spicy black bean sauce
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza
    •  
    • $15.49
    • $19.59
    • $15.49
  • crispy tenders rolled in our signature buffalo sauce with diced red peppers, mozzarella and pepper jack cheeses. Topped with celery curls and green onion
  • New Say Cheese
    •  
    • $15.99
    • $19.99
    • $15.99
  • a flavorful, gourmet six-cheese blend with roma tomatoes, roasted garlic and our signature homemade pizza sauce

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us click here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Legal Notices.