A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect any affiliation or endorsement of the listed restaurant. Prices may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current prices.
Check out our complete selection of cocktails in our Bar Log.
CHEESEBURGER IN PARADISE COCKTAIL
Recipient of the 2006 Cheers Award- Best Signature Drink An Island-size drink for two that will change your attitude Frozen layers of Parrot Bay Rum Pina Colada, Myers's Rum Runner, Margaritaville Margarita and Strawberry daiquirl each prepared with fresh
A refreshing beverage made with Blueberry and Pomegranate Monin flavorings, our Island Lemonade, and a splash of club soda. We then top it all off with real blueberries.
$3.99
JAMAICAN ROOT BEER FLOAT
Our Caribbean version of the classic Root Beer float, We make ours with creamy Blue Bell Vanilla Ice Cream, Coconut Monin flavoring, and Barq's Root Beer. If you are thirsty for more, please enjoy complimentary refills of Root Beer. food-borne illness.
$2.99
SURFSIDE SODAS
Cool and refreshing mixture of Fresca and Monin flavoring your choice of Ruby Red Grapefruit, Pomegranate, or Peach. Enjoy unlimited refills.
$3.99
MOUTH - WATERING MILKSHAKES
Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry. Oreo, strawberry / banana or chocolate / banana shakes, made with Blue Bell ice cream.
$2.49
ISLAND LEMONADE
$2.99
ISLAND PARADISE
Straight from the Island, this signature beverage is sure to please, A mouth-watering combination of pineapple and coconut grenadine and splash of Sprite. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafood may increase
For children under 10. Beverage included, Veggies can be substituted for any side.
$4.95
FIRST MATES PLATE
Grilled chicken breast with a side of veggies.
$4.95
MINI - CHEESEBURGERS
These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafood may increase your risk of food-borne illness.
$3.45
THE BIG GRILLED CHEESY
$4.95
FLYIN CHICKEN FINGERS
$3.45
CAPTAIN MAC 'N CHEESE
$2.25
LIL PIRATES TREAT
Choice of vanilla or chocolate Blue Bell ice cream topped with chocolate sauce, sprinkles and Oreo cookie crumbles. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafood may increase your risk of food-borne illness.
Four Mini-Crab cakes lightly breaded and fried with lettuce and red pepper aioli sauce
$7.99
POPCORN SHRIMP
Lightly breaded, mildly seasoned and fried, served with our Asian dipping sauce
$4.49
ONION SIX-STRINGS
Thinly sliced onions, breaded and deep-fried until golden-brown and lightly seasoned. Served with our Asian clipping sauce
$3.99
SWEET POTATO CHIPS
Lightly fried sweet potato chips, dusted with our own seasoning blend
$3.99
FRENCH-FRIED POTATOES
Idaho potatoes, lightly fried and flavored with our own special blend of seasonings.
$7.49
TROPICAL CHICKEN SATAY
Four Thai marinated chicken skewers grilled and served on a bed of field greens with our Coconut Curry dipping sauce.
Ten
Six
Four
$11.99
$7.49
$4.99
MINI - CHEESEBURGERS
An ISLAND FAVORITE! You'll be in paradise with our Mini-cheeseburgers topped with cheese, pickles and onions. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafood may increase your risk of food-borne illness.
$7.49
BLACKBEARD'S SHRIMP
Six large shrimp seasoned and blackened, served on Cuban toast with a red pepper aioli sauce
Eighteen
Twelve
$10.49
$7.49
CLIPPER CHICKEN WINGS
Lightly seasoned and breaded chicken wings with your choice of sauce: Jerk, Teriyaki or Buffalo Cayman.
$12.99
CARNIVOROUS HABITS PLATTER
Mini-Cheeseburgers, BBQ Jerk ribs, Teriyaki wings and Onion Six-Strings Great for sharing! These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafood may increase your risk of food-borne illness.
Bowl
Cup
$5.49
$3.99
I WILL PLAY FOR CUMBO
Just the way jimmy likes it. A true classic made with roasted chicken and Andouille sausage
$8.99
ISLAND QUESADILLA
A large flour tortilla stuffed with pulled chicken, Cheddar and Jack cheeses, crinsini mushrooms, balsamic onions, roasted peppers and chopped bacon, Served with sour cream and salsa
$7.99
BAYOU CRAB AND SPINACH DIP
Lump crab meat mixed with spinach and Asiago cheese, served with Cuban crustinis
A mix of iceberg, romaine hearts and spring mix lettuces, shredded carrots, red cabbage, cucumbers, wontons, asparagus, and tomatoes all tossed in our house balsamic vinaigrette. Add pulled chicken for 2.99. Add grilled seasoned steak for 3.99. Add grille
$9.99
ISLAND CHEF SALAD
We start with our lettuce mix and then add roasted chicken candied almonds, golden raisins, pineapple adn coconut then toss with our incredible Island dressing and garnish with fresh fried plantains
$10.49
COSTA RICAN STEAK SALAD
Our lettuce mix, roasted corn, cucumbers, red onions, wontons, salsa and Danish Blue Cheese, tossed in our house balsamic vinaigrette and topped with a healthy portion of grilled seasoned steak. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or an
$6.99
WHICH WAY DO I STEER?
Choose your favorite sandwich, 1/2 El Cubano Sandwich or 1/2 Vahamian BBQ Pork Sandwich and add a soup or House Salad
All burgers are made with 100% fresh ground choice chuck, served on a toasted bun, Served with French-Fried Potatoes, Sweet Potato Chips, Island or Vegetable of the Day, A TURKEY or VEGGIE BURGER is available as a replacement for any of our beef burgers a
$8.29
BBQ CHEDDAR BURGER
Cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, pickles, lettuce and fried onions. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafo
$8.29
BURGER OF THE DAY
Ask your server about our featured daily burger.Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
$8.29
NOT TOO PARTICULAR NOT TOO PRESSED BURGER
An ISLAND FAVORITE! It's heaven on a bun, Topped with Velveeta cheese, salsa ketchup. pickles and mayo, pressed until golden-brown. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
$8.29
BAJA BURGER
Sour cream, shredded lettuce, jalapenos, onions, cheddar cheese and salsa. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
$8.49
BACON BURGER
Sour cream, shredded lettuce, jalapenos, onions, Cheddar cheese and salsa. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked me
$8.49
MUSHROOM SWISS BURGER
Crimini mushrooms, Swiss cheese fried onions, Asian mayo and lettuce. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
$8.99
MINI-CHEESEBURGERS
An ISLAND FAVORITE! You'll be in paradise with six of our Mini-Cheeseburgers, topped with cheese, pickles and onions. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
$8.29
CHEESEBURGER IN PARADISE BURGER
American cheese, pickles, lettuce red onion and tomato, with a big kosher dill pickle on the side. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
$9.29
MINI-CRAB BURGERS
Four Mini-Crab cakes lightly breaded and fried with lettuce and red pepper aioli sauce. Choice of dressings include: Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Honey Mustard. Blue cheese and Pan-Asian.
All selection are served with your choice of French-Fried Potatoes, Sweet Potato Chips, Island rice or Vegetable of the Day. Add a House Salad for 1.99. Add Danish Blue Cheese Crumbles for .50.
$14.99
CORAL REEFER CRAB CAKES
Two of our crab cakes made with lump crab meat, seasoned and sauteed vegetables, then pan-seared and oven baked with a red pepper aioli sauce
$14.99
BBQ JERK RIBS
Our slaw-cooked, marinated domestic pork ribs lightly seasoned with jerk spices and basted with our zesty pineapple Jerk BBQ sauce.
$11.49
TROPICAL CHICKEN SATAY
Six Thai marinated chicken skewers, grilled and served with our Coconut Curry dipping sauce.
$13.49
TROPICAL TILAPIA
Freshwater Tilapia from Central America, blackened or grilled and lightly topped with a pineapple salsa
$12.99
N' AWLINS BBQ SHRIMP
Large shrimp sauteed and simmered in our authentic N' Awlins sauce, Served with hot Cuban bread for dipping
$10.99
SIESTA KEY SIRLOIN
7 oz. flame grilled USDA Choice sirloin served with our Sweet Potato Chips and choice of side item
$9.99
ST, BARTS CITRUS CHICKEN
A citrus marinated breast of chicken seasoned grilled and served over Island Rice
All sandwiches are served with your choice of French-Fried Potatoes, Sweet Potato Chips, Island Rice or Vegetable of the Day. Add a House Salad for 1.99 Add Danish Blue Cheese Crumbles for .50
$8.29
SHRIMP PO BOY WRAP
Fresh fried shrimp, shredded lettuce and Caribbean tartar sauce rolled into a tomato basil tortilla
$9.99
COSTA RICAN STEAK WRAP
A tomato basil tortilla with grilled seasoned steak , Swiss cheese, roasted peppers, crimini mushrooms, salsa and balsamic onions, pressed until golden brown. These items are cooked to order, however consuming raw or undercooked meats and seafood may incr
$8.69
EL CUBANO
The one and only true Cuban sandwich/ Ham, salami, pork and Swiss cheese on traditional Cuban bread, along with mayo mustard and pickles and pressed until golden-brown
$7.99
JERK CHICKEN WRAP
Fried jerk chicken strips, lettuce, salsa, chopped bacon, red pepper aioli sauce, red onions, Cheddar and Jack cheeses in a tomato basil tortilla
$9.49
SOUTH OF THE BORDER FISH SANDWICH
Freshwater Tilapia from Central America, blackened or grilled, and served on our starfish bun, Topped with red pepper aioli sauce, lettuce, tomato, pickles and red onions
$8.29
GRILLED CARIBBEAN JERK CHICKEN SANDWICH
Jerk rubbed chicken breast, covered with red and yellow roasted peppers, Swiss cheese with a red pepper aioli sauce on our tomato focaccia bread
$8.49
BAHAMIAN BBQ PORK SANDWICH
Mojo criollo marinated pulled pork tossed in our BBQ sauce and piled high on Cuban bread with red onions and pickles, pressed until golden brown
An 18% graruity will be added to parties of 8 or more. We use 1005 Canola Oil.
$5.99
CHOCOLATE NACHOS
An ISLAND FAVORITE made for sharing. Chocolate and flour nachos fried and sweetened, then covered with chocolate sauce strawberries and colored sprinkles, Served with Blue Bell strawberry and vanilla ice cream for dipping
$5.29
MANGO CHEESECAKE
Cheesecake layered with tropical flavors of mango, topped with whipped cream
$5.99
JAMAICAN APPLE CRISP
Warm caramelized Granny Smith apples with a touch of ginger and cinnamon abundantly covered with crisp granola walnut crumbs and topped with Blue Bell vanilla ice cream. this dessert contains walnuts and almonds.
$4.99
KEY LIME PIE
Try our delicious authentic recipe straight from the florida keys. A generous slice topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut
$5.99
HAVANA BAHANA CHOCOLATE CHIP CAKE
Warmed chocolate banana cake with chocolate icing and chocolate chips. Goes great with a scoop of Blure Bell vanilla ice cream for .99.
Cheeseburger In Paradise has been added to your Favorites list.