Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Water Mill
  • Citarella Prepared Foods

Citarella Prepared Foods

(631) 726-3636

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 760 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976
  • Restaurant website
  • American
  • Citarella Prepared Foods

  • (631) 726-3636
  • Main
  • Catering
  • Appetizers
    • Frittata $5.99

    • Mozzarella & Tomatoes $5.99

    • Potato Croquettes $5.99

    • Swedish Meatballs $5.99

    • Turkey Meatballs $6.99

    • Gefilte Fish $6.99

    • Arancini $7.99

    • Stuffed Mushrooms $7.99

    • Mushroom Puffs $9.99

    • Sausage Puffs $9.99

    • Seafood Puffs $9.99

  • Salads
    • Bean Salad $5.99

    • Beet Salad $5.99

    • Celery Root Salad $5.99

    • Corn Salad $5.99

    • Cucumber Salad $5.99

    • German Potato Salad $5.99

    • Lentil Salad $5.99

    • Mixed Garden Salad $5.99

    • Potato Salad $5.99

    • Split Pea Salad $5.99

    • Summer Slaw $5.99

    • Greek Salad $6.99

    • Fennel Salad $6.99

    • Creamy Chicken Salad $7.99

    • Grilled Chicken Salad with Tomatoes $7.99

    • Wild Rice Salad $8.99

    • Creamy Tuna Salad $11.98

  • Vegetables
    • Sauteed Carrots $3.99

    • Mashed Potatoes $4.99

    • Grilled zucchini $4.99

    • Beets Al Forno $5.99

    • Cranberry Conserve $5.99

    • Fried Cauliflower $5.99

    • Glazed Sweet Potatoes $5.99

    • Grilled Eggplant $5.99

    • Grilled Mixed Vegetables $5.99

    • Mozzarella & Tomatoes $5.99

    • Potatoes Boulangere $5.99

    • Potato Pancakes $5.99

    • Ratatouille $5.99

    • Sauteed Brussel Sprouts $5.99

    • Sauteed Escarole $5.99

    • Steamed Broccoli $5.99

    • Stuffed acorn Squash $5.99

    • Stuffed Cabbage $5.99

    • Sweet Potato Praline $5.99

    • Sweet Potato Duchess $5.99

    • Roasted Potatoes $6.99

    • Corn Fritters $6.99

    • Grilled Mushrooms $6.99

    • Sauteed Shiitake Mushrooms & Fennel $6.99

    • Vegetable Napoleon $6.99

    • Sauteed String Beans $6.99

    • Sauteed Broccoli Di Rape $7.99

    • Sauteed Endives $7.99

    • Sauteed Spinach $7.99

    • Spinach Pie $7.99

    • Steamed Baby Vegetables $7.99

    • Vegetable Terrine $7.99

    • Stuffed Portobello Mushroom $7.99

    • Poached Asparagus $9.99

    • Stuffed Artichoke $3.99

    • Stuffed Pepper $3.99

  • Fish & Shellfish
    • Mussels Mediterranean $9.99

    • Salmon Cake $9.99

    • Grilled Salmon Salad $11.98

    • Smoked Salmon Terrine $11.98

    • Calamari Salad $13.98

    • Lobster Parisienne $13.98

    • Baked Salmon with Vegetables $15.98

    • Grilled Salmon $15.98

    • Poached Salmon Steaks $15.98

    • Grilled Swordfish $15.98

    • Grilled Tuna $15.98

    • Shrimp with Mango Salsa $15.98

    • Coconut Shrimp $17.98

    • Grilled Skewered Shrimp $17.98

    • Shrimp Francese $19.98

    • Shrimp Scampi $19.98

    • Shrimp & Asparagus Salad $19.98

    • Shrimp Primavera $19.98

    • Lobster Salad $39.96

    • Crab Cake $5.99

    • Sauteed Soft Shell Crab (Seasonal)

    • Varies

  • Meat
    • Swedish Meatballs $5.99

    • Meat Loaf $5.99

    • Roast Pork Loin $8.99

    • Beef Bourguignon $9.99

    • Veal Stew $9.99

    • Beef Stew $9.99

    • Stuffed Pork Loin $9.99

    • London Broil $11.98

    • Roast Lamb $11.98

    • Roast Veal $11.98

    • Lamb Stew $11.98

    • Veal Stew $11.98

    • Veal and Peppers $11.98

    • Osso Buco $19.99

    • Braised Brisket $13.98

    • Flank Steak $13.98

    • Rotisserie Baby Back Ribs $13.98

    • Rack of Lamb $19.98

    • Veal Chop with Mushrooms $19.98

    • Veal Marsala $19.98

    • Veal Rollatini $19.98

    • Veal Scallopini $19.98

    • Beef Wellington $36.99

  • We Also Make to Order
    • Roast Turkey $5.99+

    • Roast Turkey Breast $48.99+

    • Roast Goose $95.99

    • Whole Poached Salmon $119.99+

    • Roast Filet of Beef $36.99

    • Virginia Ham $9.99

    • Honey Baked Ham $9.99

  • Poultry
    • Rotisserie Chicken $3.49

    • Rotisserie Turkey Thighs $3.99

    • Stuffed Cornish Hens $3.99

    • Rotisserie Duck $5.99

    • Buffalo Wings $6.99

    • Turkey Meatballs $6.99

    • Asian Chicken Salad $7.99

    • Chicken Brochette $7.99

    • Chicken Cacciatore $7.99

    • Chicken Curry $7.99

    • Chicken Francese $7.99

    • Chicken Marsala $7.99

    • Chicken Milanese $7.99

    • Chicken Pesto $7.99

    • Chicken Parmigiana $7.99

    • Sesame Chicken Fingers $7.99

    • Grilled Herbed Chicken Breast $7.99

    • Lemon Garlic Chicken $7.99

    • Stuffed Turkey Breast $7.99

    • Turkey Wellington $8.99

    • Grilled Turkey Breast $8.99

    • Chicken Portobello $9.99

    • Stuffed Chicken Breast $9.99

  • Pasta & Grains
    • Cannelloni $5.99

    • Bolognese Lasagna $5.99

    • Vegetable Lasagna $5.99

    • Israeli Couscous with Mushrooms $5.99

    • Kasha Varnishkas $5.99

    • Risotto with Spinach $5.99

    • Pasta Crudaiola $5.99

    • Pasta Primavera $5.99

    • Pasta with Arugula & Tomatoes $5.99

    • Pasta with Broccoli & Mushrooms $5.99

    • Pasta with Peas $5.99

    • Sausage Stuffing $5.99

    • Chestnut Stuffing $6.99

    • Pasta Emilia $6.99

    • Risotto with Wild Mushrooms $6.99

    • Risotto with Pumpkin & Porcini $6.99

    • Ricotta Salata Pasta $6.99

    • Wild Rice Stuffing $6.99

    • Polenta Terrine $7.99

    • Portabello Terrine $8.99

    • Jambalaya $9.99

    • Paella $11.98

    • Orzo Primavera $5.99

    • Risotto Primavera $5.99

  • Desserts
    to inquire about our assortment of fresh pastries please call our main office
    • Desserts

  • Party Platters
    • Tuscan appetizing $120.00

      country style appetizer tray filled with marinated grilled vegetables, Italian meats & cheeses and imported olives. Accompanied with a basket of assorted crackers and baguettes

    • Vegetarian $95.00

      grilled eggplant, mixed grilled vegetables, stuffed grape leaves, judean artichokes, roasted red peppers, bocconcini. Accompanied with basket of assorted crackers and baguettes

    • Whole Poached Salmon $119.99+

      available in three sizes fully garnished and ready to serve

    • Whole Poached Salmon $2.99

      accompanying dill sauce

    • Charcuterie $95.00+

      assorted sliced meats & cheeses with mixed olives, mustard, herbed mayonnaise & bread basket

    • Filet Mignon $170.00+

      tender filet mignon, oven-roasted, pre-sliced & served with creme fraiche-horseradish sauce

    • Garden Crudite $45.00+

      assorted crisp vegetables with dill sauce or roasted red pepper aioli

    • Honey Baked Virginia Ham $215.00

      for up to 28 guests. Pre-sliced and fully garnished and ready to serve.

    • International Cheese $80.00+

      assorted imported and domestic cheeses served with berries, grapes, rustic crackers and breads

    • Jonah Crab Fingers $115.00+

      delicate crab fingers served with a mustard sauce

    • Pate $60.00+

      selection of fine pates and terrines with nicoise olives, comichans, red onions, rustic crackers and breads

    • Seasonal Fruit $45.00+

      assorted seasonal fruits - such as melon, fresh berries, pineapple, grapes and kiwi

    • Sesame Chicken Fingers $40.00+

      sesame chicken fingers arranged on a platter and served with a rich honey mustard.

    • Shrimp Cocktail $80.00+

      large steamed shrimp, lemons and cocktail sauce

    • Smoked Fish $150.00+

      eastern nova, smoked sturgeon, whitefish and sable with cream cheese, nicoise olives, capers, sliced tomatoes, red onions and assorted bagels

    • Smoked Salmon Platter $160.00+

      eastern nova with cream cheese, nicoise olives, capers, sliced tomatoes, red onions and assorted bagels

    • Sushi $55.00+

      small - tuna, smoked salmon, california, avocado-cucumber rolls large - tuna, smoked salmon, california, avocado-cucumber rolls, primavera roll, spicy tuna roll and shrimp-asparagus roll

  • Corporate Gift Baskets
    there is a 12 piece minimum for corporate basket orders. We require a week advance notice for customized corporate baskets. The above prices do not include logo items. We ship anywhere within the continental united states via fedex.
    • Logo Coffee Mug $19.99

      each corporate logo mug comes complete with our house blend coffee, logo cookie, ghiradelli hot cocoa mix, biscotti and two of your logo pens

    • Snacking Crate $59.99

      sure to set a smile on anyone's face. This healthy international basket includes kettle tortilla chips, jalapeno dip, ghiradelli hot cocoa mix, dried fruit and nuts, walker's short breads, cheese sticks, imported preserves, carr's crackers, veggie sticks, cajun nut mix and two logo cookies. Also complete with your corporate logo mug and mouse pad

    • Beautiful Morning $59.99

      our sunrise sampler is a great way to start the day. Silver palette oatmeal, pancake mix, maple syrup, english crumpets, preserves, house blend coffee, dried fruit and nut mix, ghiradelli hot cocoa mix, earl gray tea, biscotti and two corporate logo mugs

  • Salads
    small (10 people) / large (15 people) several of the following salads would make a delicious lunch or they could be used as a companion to our sandwich or meat platters. Choice of Italian or balsamic dressing.
    • Salads $45.00+

      mediterranean chopped salad, mesclun w / tomato, vegetable salad

  • Dessert Platters
    • Chocolate - Dipped Strawberries $50.00+

      fresh strawberries coated in dark or white chocolate

    • Chocohoucs' Delight $40.00+

      assorted chocolate - covered cookies, brownies, sables, truffles, espresso beans & strawberries

    • Mini - Pastry Tray $40.00+

      assorted tartlets apple, blueberry, cherry, chocolate, lemon, mixed berry, mixed fruit & raspberry

    • Sweets Platter $40.00+

      mini butter cookies, chocolate graham crackers, biscotti, brownies, pound cake, lemon and pecan bars

  • Hors D' Oeuvres
    12 pc minimum per item required (all hors d' oeuvres require reheating)
    • Brie / Pear / Almond Fillo Flower $2.00

    • Fresh Tomato Mini Quiche $1.50

    • Hot & Spicy Spring Roll $1.50

    • Kreatopita $2.00

    • Menina Mash $2.00

    • Mini Brie En Croute $2.00

    • Mini Crab Cakes with Tartar Sauce $2.00

    • Mushroom Mini Quiche $1.50

    • Ratatouille Fillo Cup $2.25

    • Spanakopita $2.00

    • Tuscan White Bean Tortilla Crisp $2.25

  • Sandwich Platters
    assorted sandwich & wrap board with vegetable chips
    • Artichoke & Goat Cheese $85.00+

      marinated artichoke hearts, goat cheese and arugula

    • Tomato & Mozzarella $85.00+

      fresh made mozzarella cheese, tomato, basil, pesto and balsamic vinegar

    • Smoked Turkey Apple $85.00+

      smoked turkey, apple, whole groin mustard and watercress.

    • Low Fat Reduced Chicken Salad $85.00+

      chicken breast, grapes, celery, onions, walnuts, mayonnaise, yogurt, mustard and mesclun.

    • Classic Egg Salad $85.00+

      eggs, mayonnaise, celery, red onion, vinegar, tabasco and watercress.

    • Ham & Brie $85.00+

      baked virginia ham, french brie, honey mustard tomato and butter lettuce

    • Roast Beef $85.00+

      roast beef, red onion, gruyere cheese, horseradish mayonnaise and mesclun.

    • Chicken & Avocado $85.00+

      chicken, tomato, avocado, lettuce and lemon aioli

    • Pulled Pork $85.00+

      bbq roast pork, pickle, pepper jack cheese and chipotle mayonnaise

    • Roasted Lamb & Feta Wrap $85.00+

      lamb, feta cheese, tomato, peppers, chick pea mayonnaise and romaine lettuce

    • Curried Chicken Salad Wrap $85.00+

      chicken, apple, raisins, celery, carrots, almonds and parsley

    • Roasted Vegetable & Goat Cheese Wrap $85.00+

      zucchini, yellow squash, eggplant, tomato, roast pepper, goat cheese, herbs and romaine lettuce

    • Vietnamese Chicken Wrap $85.00+

      chicken, sprouts, cabbage, peppers, onions, cashews, and sesame seeds

    • Turkey Avocado Wrap $85.00+

      smoked turkey, bacon, tomato, avocado, pesto and romaine lettuce

    • Shrimp Fajita Wrap $85.00+

      shrimp, tomato salsa and mesclun

    • Chef Salad Wrap $85.00+

      ham, turkey, egg, grape tomato, bell pepper, American cheese, red wine vinaigrette and romaine lettuce

    • Roast Beef Bites $85.00+

      roast beef, creme fraiche horseradish, carmelized onions and arugula.

    • Roast Turkey Bites $85.00+

      roast turkey, cole slaw and arugula.

    • Soft-Shell Crab (Seasonal) $85.00+

      pan-seared soft-shell crab, harissa-caper mayonnaise, tomatoes, red onion and watercress

Menu for Citarella Prepared Foods provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.