Sutton Pizza & Gyro

1140 1st Ave, New York NY 10065 Today's hours: 11:00 am-12:00 am (646) 582-6915
Cuisines and Dishes at Sutton Pizza & Gyro:
  • Italian
  • Pizza

Menu for Sutton Pizza & Gyro

Order Online on Seamless

Menu for Sutton Pizza & Gyro provided by

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Dining options for Sutton Pizza & Gyro

Recent reviews for Sutton Pizza & Gyro Rating 4 stars

Ratings and Reviews for Sutton Pizza & Gyro

Based on 67 reviews
  • Yelp user Glenn C.

    Rating 4 stars

    May 01 2016

    via Yelp

    If you are with some out of towners and you are looking for a good local slice, you should look no further. Was looking for a local pizza place with a more

  • Yelp user James W.

    Rating 4 stars

    Sep 05 2015

    via Yelp

    It's a very casual place. The owner is very nice and I saw him make the pizzas himself on the counter. I love this authentic feel. The slices are more

  • Yelp user Sean D.

    Rating 2 stars

    Jun 16 2016

    via Yelp

    Surely these reviews can't be serious. This pizza tasted like $1 pizza with a $2.75 price tag. I bet if you did a blind taste-test, you probably wouldn't more

Powered by Yelp

Map of Sutton Pizza & Gyro

Order Online on GrubHub