Island Burgers & Shakes

766 9th Ave, New York NY 10019 Today's hours: 12:00 pm-10:30 pm islandburgersnewyork.com (212) 307-7934

Cuisines and Dishes at Island Burgers & Shakes:

Burgers
Sandwiches
Salads

Menu for Island Burgers & Shakes

Appetizers

Grilled Asparagus $4.75
Parmigiano reggiano and balsamic
Chili Works $5.75
With cheddar, sour cream and chopped onions
Guacamole and Chips $7.00
Salsa, Guacamole and Chips $8.00
Chili $5.00
Spicy, with beef and red beans
Chili Works and Chips $7.50
Salsa and Chips $6.00
Grilled Chicken Sticks $6.75
Choice of style: BBQ, cajun, italian, mexican, plain or thai

Small Salads

Small Mixed Green Salad $4.25
Antipasto Salad $8.00
Small Tabouleh Salad $6.00
Lil Bacon Bleu Salad $5.75
With mixed greens, croutons, bacon and bleu cheese
Small Mixed Greens and Tomato Salad $5.25
Small Caesar Salad $6.00
Lil Ham Salad $5.75
With mixed greens, tomato, mushrooms, ham and italian herbs

Main Course Salads

Tabouleh Salad $9.00
Cabo San Lucas Salad $9.00
With mixed greens, cheddar, jack, salsa, guacamole, jalapeno, onion, roasted peppers, tomatoes and tortilla chips
Tommy's Phuket Salad $9.00
Mixed greens, roasted peppers, avocado, jalapeno, tomato, onions and mushrooms
Chef Salad $13.00
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, cheddar, swiss, ham, artichoke hearts, olives, mushrooms, tomato, onion and egg
Caesar Salad $9.00
Tuscan Salad $9.00
With mixed greens, mozzarella, mushrooms, onions, roasted peppers, olives, artichoke hearts, tomato and parmagiano reggiano
Cobb Salad $13.00
With mixed greens, grilled chicken, bacon, bleu cheese, avocado, egg and tomato
Boo Zoo Salad $13.00
Mixed greens, blackened chicken, bacon, cheddar, tomato, onion, mushrooms and jalapeno

Chicken and Salad

Chicken and Salad Plate $10.75
Mixed greens and tomatoes served with choice of style chicken
Chicken Fajitas $11.75
With sauteed onions, roasted peppers, guacamole and salsa
Whitey's Chicken Fajitas $11.75
With bacon, cheddar, sour cream, sauteed onions and roasted peppers
Chicken Sticks and Salad Plate $10.00
Mixed green and tomatoes served with choice of style chicken sticks
Big Ass Chicken Fajitas $13.25
With cheddar, acapulco sauce and sour cream

Sandwiches

Mozzarella, Pesto, Tomato and Onion $8.25
On ciabatta
Roasted Pepper, Mozzarella, Onions and Tomato $8.25
On ciabatta
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $6.50
White cheddar on sourdough
Grilled Ham and Swiss $8.00
On rye
Salsa, Jack, Guacamole and Jalapeno $7.75
On sourdough
Genoa Sandwich $9.00
Pesto, roasted peppers, mozzarella, tomato and onion on ciabatta
BLT $7.75
On sourdough with choice of salsa or ranch
BLT on Sourdough $6.50

Burgers and Churascos: Simple

Basic Burger $8.00
Served with lettuce, red onion and pickles. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Bangkok Burger $8.75
Served with thai chili, curry and peanut sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cheeseburger $8.75
With choice of cheese. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Guacamole Burger $9.25
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
HSB Sauce Burger $8.75
Served with a horseradish, sour cream and black pepper sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Mike's Pool Hall Burger $9.25
With jack and sauteed onions on dark rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Mushroom Burger $8.75
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Pesto Burger $9.25
Served on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Ranch Burger $8.75
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Salsa Burger $8.75
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Sauteed Onion and Mushroom Burger $9.25
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Au Poivre Burger $10.00
Served with a black pepper cream sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Basic Churasco $8.50
A grilled chicken sandwich with lettuce, red onion and pickles. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Bangkok Churasco $9.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with thai chili, curry and peanut sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cheese Churasco $9.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with choice of cheese. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Guacamole Churasco $9.75
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
HSB Sauce Churasco $9.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with a horseradish, sour cream and black pepper sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Mike's Pool Hall Churasco $9.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with jack and sauteed onions on dark rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Mushroom Churasco $9.25
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Pesto Churasco $9.75
A grilled chicken sandwich served on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Ranch Churasco $9.25
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Salsa Churasco $9.25
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Sauteed Onion and Mushroom Churasco $9.75
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Au Poivre Churasco $10.50
A grilled chicken sandwich with a black pepper cream sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available

Burgers and Churascos: Mild

Cordon Bleu Burger $10.00
Served with ham and swiss on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Frog Burger $10.50
Served with boursin, bacon and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Mulberry Street Burger $10.50
Served with sauteed onions and roasted peppers on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Patty Melt Burger $10.00
Served with swiss and sauteed onions on toasted rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Charlie's Sweet and Sour Burger $10.25
Served with relish, honey mustard and swiss. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Parmagiana Burger $10.25
Served with marinara, mozzarella and parmesan on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Riviera Burger $10.50
Served with sauteed onions, roasted peppers and mushrooms on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
The Peoples's Choice Burger $10.00
Served with swiss, mushrooms and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Vito's Burger $11.25
Served with roasted peppers and mozzarella on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Boss's Burger $11.25
Served with bacon, jack and ranch on toasted rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
El Camino Burger $11.25
Served with bacon, jack and ranch on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Here's Gianni Burger $11.25
Served with roasted peppers, bacon and a parmesan spread on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Route 66 Burger $11.25
Served with avocado, swiss and bacon on dark rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Sans Spud Burger $11.25
Served with bacon, cheddar, sour cream and chives. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Saratoga HSB Burger $11.25
Served with horseradish, sour cream and black pepper sauce, bacon, and cheddar on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
The Derby Burger $11.25
Served with avocado, bleu cheese and bacon. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cordon Bleu Churasco $10.50
A grilled chicken sandwich with ham and swiss on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Frog Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich with boursin, bacon and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Mulberry Street Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich with sauteed onions and roasted peppers on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Patty Melt Churasco $10.50
A grilled chicken sandwich with swiss and sauteed onions on toasted rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Charlie's Sweet and Sour Churasco $10.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with relish, honey mustard and swiss. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Parmagiana Churasco $10.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with marinara, mozzarella and parmesan on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Riviera Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich with sauteed onions, roasted peppers and mushrooms on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
The People's Choice Churasco $10.50
A grilled chicken sandwich with swiss, mushrooms and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Vito's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with roasted peppers and mozzarella on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Boss's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with bacon, jack and ranch on toasted rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
El Camino Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with bacon, jack and ranch on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Here's Gianni Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with roasted peppers, bacon and a parmesan spread on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Route 66 Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with avocado, swiss and bacon on dark rye. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Sans Spud Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with bacon, cheddar, sour cream and chives. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Saratoga HSB Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with horseradish, sour cream and black pepper sauce, bacon, and cheddar on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
The Derby Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with avocado, bleu cheese and bacon. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available

Burgers and Churascos: A Little Kick

Jalapeno and Jack Burger $10.50
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
BBQ Burger $9.75
Served with a spicy BBQ sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Blackened Burger $9.75
Served with a cajun style rub and seared in a cast iron pan. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cajun Burger $9.75
Grilled with cajun spices. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Derrick's Burger $10.50
Blackened and served with pesto on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Roma Burger $8.75
Served with thyme, rosemary, garlic, oregano and red pepper flakes. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Black n Bleu Burger $10.50
Blackened and served with blue cheese. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Chesky's Burger $10.50
Served with mozzarella and honey mustard. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cowboy Burger $11.25
Served with BBQ sauce, sauteed onions, bacon cheddar and ranch dressing on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side
Honey West Burger $11.25
Served with ham, cheddar and honey mustard. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available upon request. Tomatoes available
Tijuana Burger $11.25
Served with bacon, jack, guacamole and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Slick Willie's Burger $12.00
Served with ham, relish, american cheese, bacon, sour cream, BBQ sauce and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Jalapeno and Jack Churasco $11.00
With lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
BBQ Churasco $10.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with a spicy BBQ sauce. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Blackened Churasco $10.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with a cajun style rub, seared in a cast iron pan. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cajun Churasco $10.25
A chicken sandwich grilled with cajun spices. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Derrick's Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich, blackened and served with pesto on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Roma Churasco $9.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with thyme, rosemary, garlic, oregano and red pepper flakes. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Black n Bleu Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich, blackened and served with blue cheese. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Chesky's Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich with mozzarella and honey mustard. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Cowboy Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with BBQ sauce, sauteed onions, bacon cheddar and ranch dressing on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Honey West Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with ham, cheddar and honey mustard. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Tijuana Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with bacon, jack, guacamole and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Slick Willie's Churasco $12.50
A grilled chicken sandwich with ham, relish, american cheese, bacon, sour cream, BBQ sauce and sauteed onions. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available

Burgers and Churascos: Decadent

Best Western Burger $11.25
Served with ham, jack, sauteed onions, chives and roasted pepper on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Hippo Burger $11.25
Served with curried sour cream, bacon, cheddar, guacamole, sauteed onions and scallions on a pita. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Julius Burger $11.25
A burger with a caesar salad on a pita. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Mona Lisa Burger $11.25
Served with mozzarella, pesto, sauteed onions, mushrooms, roasted peppers and parmagiana reggiano on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Pizza Burger $11.25
Served with mozzarella, marinara, sauteed onions, mushrooms, roasted peppers and parmagiana reggiano on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Princess Grace Burger $11.25
Served with ham, boursin, sauteed onions, mushrooms and roasted peppers on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Sam I Am Burger $11.25
Served with pesto, ham, american cheese and hard-boiled egg. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Will's Burger $11.25
Served with bacon, cheddar, sour cream, sauteed onions and scallions on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Hobie's Burger $12.00
Served au poivre with bleu cheese, sauteed onions and bacon on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Raoul's Burger $12.00
Served au poivre with swiss, mushrooms and bacon on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Marco's Burger $10.25
Served with pesto, ranch, bacon and parmesan on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Best Western Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with ham, jack, sauteed onions, chives and roasted pepper on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Hippo Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with curried sour cream, bacon, cheddar, guacamole, sauteed onions and scallions on a pita. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Julius Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with a caesar salad on a pita. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Mona Lisa Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with mozzarella, pesto, sauteed onions, mushrooms, roasted peppers and parmagiana reggiano on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Pizza Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with mozzarella, marinara, sauteed onions, mushrooms, roasted peppers and parmagiana reggiano on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Princess Grace Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with ham, boursin, sauteed onions, mushrooms and roasted peppers on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Sam I Am Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with pesto, ham, american cheese and hard-boiled egg. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Will's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with bacon, cheddar, sour cream, sauteed onions and scallions on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Hobie's Churasco $12.50
A grilled chicken sandwich au poivre with bleu cheese, sauteed onions and bacon on sourdough. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes available
Raoul's Churasco $12.50
A grilled chicken sandwich au poivre with swiss, mushrooms and bacon on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Marco's Churasco $10.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with pesto, ranch, bacon and parmesan on ciabatta. Lettuce, red onions and pickles on the side. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available

Burgers and Churascos: Hot

Acapulco Burger $9.75
Served with a sweet and spicy mexican sauce with blended roasted onions, jalapeno, garlic and cilantro. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Chili Burger $9.75
Served with homemade beef and bean chili on sourdough toast. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Barzel's Burger $11.25
Blackened and served with jack, bacon and horseradish on ciabatta. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Bourbon Street Burger $11.25
Blackened and served with bacon, jack, bayou mayo and sauteed onions on sourdough. Tomatoes available
Deluxe Chili Burger $11.25
Served with chili, cheddar, sour cream and BBQ sauce on sourdough toast. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Duke's Burger $11.25
Blackened and served with jalapeno and jack on sourdough. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Hermosa Beach Burger $11.25
Served with jack, salsa, jalapeno and sauteed onions. Tomatoes available
Napalm Burger $11.25
Blackened and served with BBQ sauce, jalapeno, cheddar and habanero sauce. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Pancho's Burger $11.25
Served with a mexican sauce, bacon and cheddar. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Pepe's Burger $11.25
Blackened and served with jack, guacamole, bacon and sauteed onions. Tomatoes available
Pop and Top's Burger $11.25
Served with thai sauce, jalapeno and roasted peppers. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
South of the Border Burger $11.25
Served with jack, salsa, guacamole and jalapeno. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
It's a Mad, Mad World Burger $12.00
Blackened and served with pesto, salsa, swiss and pickle relish on a pita. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
The Clyde Burger $12.00
Blackened and served with salsa, bleu cheese, avocado and bacon. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Crescent City Burger $10.50
Blackened and served with bayou mayo, onion and sourdough. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Acapulco Churasco $10.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with a sweet and spicy mexican sauce with blended roasted onions, jalapeno, garlic and cilantro. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Chili Churasco $10.25
A grilled chicken sandwich with homemade beef and bean chili on sourdough toast. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Barzel's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with jack, bacon and horseradish on ciabatta. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Bourbon Street Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with bacon, jack, bayou mayo and sauteed onions on sourdough. Tomatoes available
Deluxe Chili Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with chili, cheddar, sour cream and BBQ sauce on sourdough toast. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Duke's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with jalapeno and jack on sourdough. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Hermosa Beach Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with jack, salsa, jalapeno and sauteed onions. Tomatoes available
Napalm Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with BBQ sauce, jalapeno, cheddar and habanero sauce. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Pancho's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with a mexican sauce, bacon and cheddar. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Pepe's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with jack, guacamole, bacon and sauteed onions. Tomatoes available
Pop and Top's Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with thai sauce, jalapeno and roasted peppers. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
South of the Border Churasco $11.75
A grilled chicken sandwich with jack, salsa, guacamole and jalapeno. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
It's a Mad, Mad World Churasco $12.50
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with pesto, salsa, swiss and pickle relish on a pita. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
The Clyde Churasco $12.50
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with salsa, bleu cheese, avocado and bacon. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available
Crescent City Churasco $11.00
A grilled chicken sandwich blackened and served with bayou mayo, onion and sourdough. Tomatoes and sauteed onions available

Real Big Baked Potatoes

Plain Naked $2.50
Classic $5.00
With butter, sour cream, cheddar, chives and bacon
Standard $3.25
With butter and sour cream
It's Your Thing $2.50
Add extras to a naked potato

Dirty Potato Chips

Regular Chips $1.75
BBQ Chips $1.75
Salt and Vinegar Chips $1.75
Jalapeno Chips $1.75
Sour Cream and Onion Chips $1.75

Old Fashioned Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookies $2.00
Oatmeal Raisin with Walnut Cookies $2.00
Kitchen Sink Cookies $2.00
Oatmeal, coconut, peanut butter, chocolate chips, raisins and pecans
Chocolate Chip with Walnut Cookies $2.00
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies $2.00

Sides

Fries $3.75
Chili Cheese Fries $5.75
Chili Fries $4.75
Cheese Fries $4.75

From the Fountain

Milkshake $5.25
Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, or black and white
Float $5.50
Ice cream with choice of soda
Malted $5.50
A milkshake with malt powder

Beverages

Soda $1.75
Snapple $2.00
Poland Spring $1.75

Menu for Island Burgers & Shakes provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Dining options for Island Burgers & Shakes

Reviews for Island Burgers & Shakes

Ratings and Reviews for Island Burgers & Shakes

May 13 2012

Randolph B. via Yelp

TASTY chicken sandwiches, interesting flavor combinations, but WOWOWWW OVER PRICED! Come on, guys.read more
May 11 2012

Jeremy G. via Yelp

Based on the fact this burger place had numerous favourable reviews in Yelp and coupled with the fact it's a 5 minute walk from where I live, we decided to...read more
May 05 2012

McKay M. via Yelp

I have been here about twice. Once by accident, another to bring in some english friends would wanted american burgers. I can say that I like this place....read more
Jan 10 2009

via Citysearch

Island Burger serves great burgers! They have a wide variety of combinations of toppings for your burger. You can also get the t...read more
Jan 01 2009

ARTROB via Citysearch

This place is way overrated! The burgers, dressing and cheese were tasteless! The only thing that had flavor was the bacon and it ...read more
May 24 2008

via Citysearch

If your looking for good food try Island Burgers and Shakes. The food is great and so is the service and the staff. They have a bi...read more

From Citysearch

The Scene
The long, narrow restaurant feels like it could have been imported from a Malibu roadside. The colorful interior features bright orange-and-red tables, along with paintings and mirrors rendered in the shape of surfboards. Waitstaff go about their work with all the lackadaisical flourish befitting a casual hamburger joint.

The Food
Both the burgers and grilled chicken breast sandwiches rank among the best in New York. The charred-on-the-outside, fist-sized patties are cooked precisely to order, and the menu touts a dizzying 63 varieties of burger and bird, with everything from the basic with cheese to more elaborate concoctions like the satisfying Derby (with bacon, real blue cheese and sliced avocado). Whatever you order, rich, buttery sauteed onions are a must. Much has been made of Island's lack of french fries--space and cost are cited on the menu--but an order of thick crispy salt and vinegar chips almost satisfies the craving.

Map of Island Burgers & Shakes

View larger map and get directions