Website

• Cuisines:
• American,
• Bakery & Pastries,
• Kosher

Yelp Reviews

• 

• 
  Yum Yum!! Delicious cupcakes, exceptional banana pudding. Parking of course is a bitch read more.

• Posted by Alexander V. on Yelp.com

• 

• 
  I am confused as to whythgis place has four stars!!! My husband and I had a romantic Valentines Day dinner and decided to take a stroll to this well... read more.

• Posted by Akilah G. on Yelp.com

• 

• 
  Well, Magnolia Bake shop has nothing at all to worry about. It is beyond me how this place or Crumbs can have so many 4 - 5 star reviews for such inferior,... read more.

• Posted by Anna S. on Yelp.com

Citysearch Reviews

• 

• 
  I haven't tried the cupcakes nor have I visited the store, but I had a cake special-ordered for my birthday and I was happy with it. It was supposed to be delivered around 10 a.m. and it arrived at... read more.

• Posted by scarletmacaw on Citysearch.com

• 

• 
  I went here on Valentine's Day to pick up cupcakes I specially ordered. It all went fine until I actually tasted the cupcakes. The frosting is good, but the cake part was just stale. It tasted... read more.

• Posted by nic1194 on Citysearch.com

• 

• 
  I had been to Buttercup once several years ago but didn't really remember much, so when I moved to the area, I decided to go back. I now realize that the reason I didn't remember anything about it... read more.

• Posted by ilovebakeries on Citysearch.com

• 

• 
  I ordered 3 dozen cupcakes from Buttercup for a photo shoot for a book cover I am designing. I chose to go there, because other shops I looked at didn't have the right color frosting, and since it... read more.

• Posted by jeanineh on Citysearch.com

• 

• 
  I had heard so many good things about Buttercup Bake Shop but I guess their business is so good that they can afford to offend and turn away potential customers. It was my boyfriend's birthday and... read more.

• Posted by RichGNYC on Citysearch.com

Menuism Reviews

• 

• 
  I love sweets and I love cupcakes. The best part is the frosting. At buttercup I couldn't get enough! I had the Red Velvet and the frosting is the ... read more.

• Posted by AnnieChen on Menuism.com

• 

• 
  They serve the most amazing banana pudding i have ever tasted. It is like no other. The pudding is not thick but light and it is filled with lots... read more.

• Posted by AliceC on Menuism.com

• 

• 
  First thing I noticed at Buttercup was that there wasn't a line out the door! Yay! I tried the red devil cupcake, and ate it right away. The frost... read more.

• Posted by manda on Menuism.com