Totonno's Pizzeria - CLOSED

462 2nd Ave, New York NY 10016 (212) 213-8800
Cuisines and Dishes at Totonno's Pizzeria:
  • Pizza
  • Pasta
  • Salads
This restaurant is closed.

Menu for Totonno's Pizzeria

Menu for Totonno's Pizzeria provided by

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Recent reviews for Totonno's Pizzeria Rating 3 stars

Ratings and Reviews for Totonno's Pizzeria

Based on 40 reviews
  • Yelp user Rachel C.

    Rating 3 stars

    Nov 02 2010

    via Yelp

    A perfect red sauce and pillows of perfectly cooked mozzarella do not always make for the perfect pizza. Sadly the crust was just too overcooked for more

  • Yelp user Tyler L.

    Rating 5 stars

    May 09 2015

    via Yelp

    Very old traditional pizza with a fantastic crust. The accolades make sense as this pizza is one of the best examples of why NYC is pizza heaven. The more

  • Yelp user Art L.

    Rating 2 stars

    Oct 29 2009

    via Yelp

    I just had to try this place as I recalled that years ago this place was one of the top 10 pizza restaurants in the city. What I do recall about more

Powered by Yelp

Map of Totonno's Pizzeria

Other dining options nearby

Or see all nearby Pizza and Pasta restaurants or all online ordering restaurants in the area.