Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Pleasantville
  • Pony Express To Go

Pony Express To Go

(914) 769-7669

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 30 Wheeler Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570
  • Restaurant website
  • American
  • $$$$$
  • Pony Express To Go

  • (914) 769-7669
  • Menu
  • The Watering Hole
    The Watering Hole
    • Spring Water $1.50

    • Bottled Sodas $1.75

    • Natural Sparkling Juices $1.75

    • All Natural Iced Tea $2.00

    • Natural Cane Sodas $1.75

  • Soup
    • Vegetarian Black Bean Chili $3.25+

    • Southwestern Beef Chili $4.25+

  • Salads
    Salads
    • Phil's Salad $9.25

      Grilled shrimp, guacamole, toasted tortilla, shredded lettuce, tomato, salsa and Express sauce.

  • Chopped Salad Saddle Bags
    Chopped Salad Saddle Bags
    • Chopped Salad Saddle Bags $4.50+

      A bed of fresh natural greens and sliced tomatoes with your choice of protein.

  • Sliders
    Sliders
    • Plain Sliders $5.95

      Just beef. Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • Natural Cheddar Cheese Sliders $6.25

      Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • Chili Sliders $6.25

      All beef. Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • Smothered Sweet Onions Sliders $6.25

      Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • Relish Sliders $6.25

      Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • The Works Sliders $6.75

      Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

  • Big Burger
    Big Burger
    • The Swiss Burger $7.95

      Burger topped with melted Swiss cheese and smothered vidalia onions. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • The St. Louis Burger $9.50

      Burger topped with pulled pork, smothered vidalia onions, cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • Forest Burger $9.50

      Burger topped with portobello mushrooms, smothered vidalia onions and chunky blue cheese. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • El Mexicali Burger $9.50

      Burger topped with guacamole, salsa and jalapeno-jack cheese then drizzled with chipotle sauce. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil. Spicy.

    • The Charro Burger $9.50

      Burger topped with lettuce, pickles, smoked bacon, jalapeno cheese and spicy chipotle sauce. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • The Bomb Burger $7.95

      Burger topped with lettuce, tomato, mayo and cheddar cheese. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • The Surf and Turf Burger $14.95

      Burger topped with lobster and peaky-toe crab salad and two grilled shrimp. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

    • The Portobello Burger $7.75

      Grilled portobello cap, sauteed onion, lettuce, tomatoes, guacamole and your choice of salad or fries. Served on a toasty handmade roll.

  • Hot Dogs
    Hot Dogs
    • Plain Hot Dog $3.00

      100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

    • Sauerkraut Hot Dog $3.50

      100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

    • Smothered Onions Hot Dog $3.50

      100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

    • Southwestern Chili Hot Dog $3.75

      100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

    • Black Bean Chili Hot Dog $3.50

      100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

  • Seafood
    Seafood
    • Lobster Roll $13.50

      Chucky Maine lobster. peaky-toe crab, organic roasted corn, celery and our special lobster sauce stuffed into our toasted hot dog roll with your choice of french fries or salad.

    • 2 Crab Cake Sliders $8.95

      Served with your choice of french fries or green salad. Topped with Express sauce.

  • Southwestern Wraps
    Southwestern Wraps
    • Black Bean Wrap $6.50

      Southwestern black beans, lettuce, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

    • Beef Wrap $7.50

      Southwestern all beef chili, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

    • Chicken Wrap $7.50

      Southwestern-spiced chicken, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

    • Shrimp Wrap $8.25

      Southwestern-spiced shrimp, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

    • Pork Wrap $7.50

      Southwestern pulled pork, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

    • Guac 333 Wrap $8.25

      Guacamole, salsa and chips. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

  • Pulled BBQ
    Pulled BBQ
    • Pulled Chicken Sandwich $7.75

      Pulled chicken, melted cheese and BBQ sauce on a toasted handmade roll. Served with your choice of side.

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $7.75

      Pulled pork, melted cheese and BBQ sauce on a toasted handmade roll. Served with your choice of side.

  • Chicken
    Chicken
    • Grilled Chicken BLT $7.75

      Grilled chicken breast on top of a toasted handmade roll splashed with Pony's chipotle sauce with two strips of Dines organic bacon, lettuce and tomatoes. Served with your choice of side.

    • Chicken Chipotle Cheese Roll $7.25

      Grilled chicken, melted cheese, smothered onions, smokey chipotle sauce and salsa on a toasted handmade hot dog roll. Served with your choice of salad or french fries.

  • Our Original Saddle Bags
    Our Original Saddle Bags
    • Chicken Saddle Bags $6.95

      Served on a bed of crispy french fries.

    • Shrimp Saddle Bags $8.95

      Served on a bed of crispy french fries.

  • Taquitos
    Taquitos
    • Southwest Beef Chili Taquito $3.95

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

    • Black Bean Chili Taquito $3.75

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

    • Crab and Lobster Taquito $4.50

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

    • Pulled Chicken Taquito $3.95

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

    • Grilled Chicken Taquito $3.95

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

    • Pork Taquito $3.95

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

    • Shrimp Taquito $4.50

      All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

  • Quesadillas
    Quesadillas
    • Original Quesadilla $6.50

      All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

    • Vegetarian Black Bean Chili Quesadilla $6.75

      All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

    • Chicken Quesadilla $7.25

      All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

    • Shrimp Quesadilla $8.25

      All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

    • Just Plain Gooey Cheese Quesadilla $6.25

      All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

    • Pulled Pork Quesadilla $7.75

      All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

  • Sides
    Sides
    • French Fries $2.95

    • Cheese Fries $3.50

    • Cheese Fries with Chili $4.25

    • Sweet Potato Fries $3.75

    • Sweet Potato Fries with Cheese $4.25

    • Sweet Potato Fries with Chili $4.75

    • 2 Picklelicious Pickles $1.25

    • Pony's Express Sauce $3.25+

    • Pony's Chipotle Sauce $3.25+

    • Guacamole $4.25+

  • Kid's Hoppy Meal
    Kid's Hoppy Meal
    • Kid's Hoppy Meal $6.50

      Served with french fries, all-natural apple juice, organic cookies and an organic fruit strip.

Menu for Pony Express To Go provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.