My Tomato Pie

3085 Sheridan Dr, Buffalo NY 14226 (716) 838-0969
Cuisines and Dishes at My Tomato Pie:
  • Diner

Menu for My Tomato Pie

Other menus for My Tomato Pie

Menu for My Tomato Pie provided by

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Recent reviews for My Tomato Pie Rating 3.5 stars

Ratings and Reviews for My Tomato Pie

Based on 46 reviews
  • Yelp user Patricia F.

    Rating 4 stars

    Dec 24 2015

    via Yelp

    Love the staff!!! Food is good. But Belly is confusing. Never seems to have the correct amount of points credited or visits. And no way to correct more

  • Yelp user Eric W.

    Rating 1 stars

    Jan 01 2016

    via Yelp

    I ordered from there for the first time today and it is garbage. I ordered a pepperoni and banana pepper calzone and a bruschetta bread. The bruschetta more

  • Yelp user Kelsey S.

    Rating 4 stars

    Sep 22 2015

    via Yelp

    I have gone to My Tomato Pie with my mom since I was very young. We have a tradition of going every black Friday, I am sad to hear they are going to more

Powered by Yelp

Map of My Tomato Pie

Owner? Update your menu! Own My Tomato Pie? Update your menu online!