Overall Rating:

Based on 373 Reviews


Santarpio's is awesome for the cheap... read more.

I grew up around here, and Santarpio's... read more.
![]()
This is a great place to get no frills... read more.
![]()
Okay..Honestly...the pizza was pretty... read more.
![]()
This pizza has good crust and a good... read more.
![]()
Expect to wait in a line that moves... read more.

The Scene
Locals, some of them of Italian lineage, flock to this local institution to soak up the atmosphere. Some posters and photographs hanging on the windowless wooden walls date back to the restaurant's days as an all-male establishment, serving slices for five cents apiece. Local characters sip at a long bar, while diners take a seat in wooden booths. Smoke from the grill intermingles with amiable chatter, Frank Sinatra tunes and the aroma of authentic, homemade Italian marinara. Friendly waiters snag any opportunity for a good wisecrack.
The Food
Pizza comes in one size: Large (12 inches). A small amount of cheese and lots of wonderfully sweet, fresh-tasting marinara cover a crust of medium thickness. The list of toppings sticks strictly to the basics. Charred lamb chunks and large, juicy pork sausages are surprising additions to the otherwise exclusive pizza menu, but customers love them as sides or appetizers.
Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. Legal Notices © 2012 Allmenus.com. All rights reserved. Made in NYC.