Maggie Moo's

49 W Maryland St
Indianapolis, IN 46204

(317) 423-3504

Menu for Maggie Moo's provided by Allmenus.com
Prices may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current prices.

Flavors & Mix Ins

mix up an award-winning ice cream creation maggiemoo's super premium ice cream is made fresh in the treatery. you can create your own ice cream masterpiece by selecting one of our award-winning ice cream flavors and choosing your favorite mix-ins, such as

Ice Cream Flavors - Amooretto

Ice Cream Flavors - Apple Strudel

Ice Cream Flavors - Banana Pudding

Ice Cream Flavors - Better Batter

Ice Cream Flavors - Black Cherry

Ice Cream Flavors - Butter Pecan

Ice Cream Flavors - Butter Pecan

Ice Cream Flavors - Cafe Cubana

Ice Cream Flavors - Chai Tea

Ice Cream Flavors - Cheesecake

Ice Cream Flavors - Cocoa Amooretto

Ice Cream Flavors - Cotton Candy

Ice Cream Flavors - Chocolate

Ice Cream Flavors - Chocolate Banana

Ice Cream Flavors - Chocolate Better Batter

Ice Cream Flavors - Choco-Mallo

Ice Cream Flavors - Chocolate Peanut Butter

Ice Cream Flavors - Chocolate Raspberry

Ice Cream Flavors - Cinnamoo

Ice Cream Flavors - Cool Mint

Ice Cream Flavors - Creme Brulee

Ice Cream Flavors - Creamy Coconut

Ice Cream Flavors - Dark Chocolate

Ice Cream Flavors - Egg Nog

Ice Cream Flavors - Espresso Bean

Ice Cream Flavors - French Vanilla

Ice Cream Flavors - Fresh Banana

Ice Cream Flavors - Irish Cream

Ice Cream Flavors - Key Lime

Ice Cream Flavors - Maggie's Fudge

Ice Cream Flavors - Mint Chocolate

Ice Cream Flavors - Moocha

Ice Cream Flavors - Non-Fat Vanilla

Ice Cream Flavors - Peanut Butter with Reese's Peanut Butter

Ice Cream Flavors - Pina Cowlada

Ice Cream Flavors - Pink Bubblegum

Ice Cream Flavors - Pink Peppermint Stick

Ice Cream Flavors - Pistachio

Ice Cream Flavors - Pumpkin Pie

Ice Cream Flavors - Raspberry

Ice Cream Flavors - Red Bull Sorbet

Ice Cream Flavors - Strawberry

Ice Cream Flavors - Southern Peaches

Ice Cream Flavors - Tres Leches

Ice Cream Flavors - Twizzlers

Ice Cream Flavors - Udderly Cream

Ice Cream Flavors - Vanilla

Ice Cream Flavors - Vanilla Bean

Ice Cream Flavors - Very Yellow Marshmallow

Ice Cream Flavors - No-Sugar Added Banana-Strawberry

Ice Cream Flavors - No-Sugar Added Chocolate

Ice Cream Flavors - No-Sugar Added Raspberry

Ice Cream Flavors - No-Sugar Added Strawberry

Mix-Ins -Almonds

Mix-Ins -Bananas

Mix-Ins -Brownies

Mix-Ins -Butterfingers

Mix-Ins -Cappuccino Chips

Mix-Ins -Cherries

Mix-Ins -Chocolate Flakes

Mix-Ins -Chocolate Sprinkles

Mix-Ins -Coconut

Mix-Ins -Cookie Dough

Mix-Ins -Crunchy M'Azing Bar

Mix-Ins -Gummy Bears

Mix-Ins -Heath Bar

Mix-Ins -Kit Kat

Mix-Ins -Lollidots

Mix-Ins -M and M's

Mix-Ins -Mini Marshmallows

Mix-Ins -Mixed Nuts

Mix-Ins -Mounds

Mix-Ins -Oreo's

Mix-Ins -Pecans

Mix-Ins -Peanut Butter M'Azing Bar

Mix-Ins -Pineapple

Mix-Ins -Rainbow Sprinkles

Mix-Ins -Raspberries

Mix-Ins -Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Mix-Ins -Snickers

Mix-Ins -Snow Caps

Mix-Ins -Strawberries

Mix-Ins -Twix

Mix-Ins -Walnuts

Mix-Ins -White Chocolate Chips

Mix-Ins -York Peppermint Patties

New Flavor

New Carrot Cake Ice Cream
spring into a fresh, new flavor,enjoy the creamy cake taste, complete with sweet spices and real carrot flakes, try it in a fresh escape cone or fresh escape shake and make every bunny envious.

Carrot Cake Fresh Escape
carrot cake ice cream with walnuts, teddy grahams and caramel sauce

Carrot Cake Fresh Escape Shake
carrot cake ice cream with teddy grahams and caramel sauce

Shakes

Deliciously Creamy Milkshakes
try maggiemoo's delicious award-winning ice cream in a creamy, thick shake choose one of maggie's favorite shakes or create your own with your favorite ice cream and mix-ins blended into the perfect treat

Non Fat Fruit Smoothies
maggiemoo's refreshing smoothies are made with real fruit, real fruit juice and non fat ice cream or sorbet most of them are fat free

Treats

So Much More Than Ice Cream
maggiemoo's offers more than award-winning ice cream. try our gourmet treats and delicious beverages, including jones soda. here's a look at what's new

New Ice Cream Cupcakes
introducing the cupcake you eat with a spoon award winning dark chocolate ice cream, chocolate cake and marshmallow filling topped with real chocolate ganache. indulge today at your local maggiemoo's ice cream and treatery

Maggie Os -Introducing the Snack of the Year
maggiemoo's award-winning ice cream combined with oreo cookies for the perfect combination, pick up a 6-pack today ask your local treatery about offering maggie-o's at your next party, office meeting or other catering event

Dream Cakes

capture the best parts of a wonderful, magical dream and mix them all together to create new dreams you could experience over and over again you can with maggiemoo's ice cream dream cakes super-premium ice cream made fresh in the store. the freshest ingre

Dream Cakes for Kids

Truffle Dream Cakes

Deluxe Dream Cakes

Classic Dream Cakes

Truffle Cakes

introduce yourself to award-winning ice cream wrapped in real decadent chocolate combined with heavy whipping cream. an experience beyond your most delicious dream.real chocolate. real cream. like never before.

Chocolate Cream Truffle
take a moment to pamper yourself. luscious udderly cream ice cream mixed with chocolate flakes and fudge, enveloped with the dreamiest, creamiest chocolate imaginable. dressed wtih chocolate flakes and perfect pirouettes. relax, enjoy available in 6" and 8" cake sizes.

Chocolate Espresso Truffle
a coffee break so extraordinary you will forget the day's worries. unwind with a slice of espresso bean ice cream blended with fudge enveloped in real rich chocolate, surrounded by cappuccino crunch chips, and topped wtih chocolate covered coffee beans. go ahead, day dream. available in 6"and 8" cake sizes.

Deluxe Dream Cakes

Better Batter Cookie Dreams
licking the bottom of the mixing bowl was never this much fun. we've combined our delicious better batter ice cream with oreos and a dreamy layer of fudge that gives it its crowning touch. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Caramel Drizzle
bet you're smiling already. we've combined the sweet taste of caramel with our award-winning vanilla ice cream, fudge, pecans and topped it all off with the classic heath bar to create a wondrous cake that will stir the senses. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Maggie's S'mores
you'll be asking for s'more in no time. with its dreamy marshmallows, rich award-winning chocolate ice cream and crisp graham crackers, the very mention of this pleasure conjures up images of campfire sing-alongs. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Pecan Perfection
cool and delicious, one slice just won't do. enjoy our rich award-winning chocolate ice cream and fudge blended with the taste of old-fashioned, southern pecan pie. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Strawberry Cheesecream
nothing creates excitement in the soul, and the tummy, quite like strawberries with our cheesecake ice cream. at maggiemoo's, we've painstakingly recreated this delectable treat in an ice cream cake that's not to be missed.available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Cotton Candy Carnival
look for all the smiling blue mouths! this dreamy, bright blue cake is adorned with a marshmallow topping and m and ms and beckons with the flavor of our carnival-style cotton candy ice cream. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Create Your Own
it's all about creativity. and it's all about you when you create your own maggiemoo's ice cream dream cake. choose from a dazzling assortment of fresh ingredients like fruit, candy bars, fudge, cookies, nuts and more and create a dream, overflowing with indulgence. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Classic Dream Cakes

Chocolate Heaven
a chocolate lover's delight! this treat features rich, indulgent chocolate cake paired with our equally decadent award-winning chocolate ice cream and topped with hershey's kisses. one taste and you'll realize it's a little slice of heaven. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Sweetheart
what better way to say, "i love you" than with a personalized dream cake and this one delivers the goods. moist, yellow cake and our award-winning vanilla ice cream adorned with sugar roses await your message of love.all hearts come in different sizes.

Sprinkle
you're invited to a party, complete with delicious yellow cake and delectable award-winning ice cream, all covered with festive rainbow sprinkles. and here's the best part: the party begins with the very first bite. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Special Occasion
enjoy your choice of images and personalized messages coupled with dreamy selections of cake and ice cream. choose from cartoon characters, logos and phrases. our cake artisans can help bring your expressions to life. create a cake perfect for any occasion. available in 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Classic Cookies N Cream
combine scrumptious chocolate cake with fantastic udderly cream ice cream, add oreo cookie mix-ins and top it off with even more oreo cookies. it's the formula for a true american classic. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Turtle
the turtle cake defines indulgence. yellow cake and our award-winning vanilla ice cream provide a rich foundation for a delicious mixture of pecans, fudge and caramel. it's then proudly topped with drizzled fudge, caramel and pecan pieces. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

Maggie's Mud
you loved mud as a kid, now you'll love it even more. enjoy chocolate cake mixed with our award-winning chocolate ice cream and reese's peanut butter cups. and the crowning touch, more reese's peanut butter cups on top. available in 6", 8" and sheet cake sizes.

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us click here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Legal Notices.