Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe

2909 Central St, Evanston IL 60201 (847) 491-1232

Cuisines and Dishes at Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe:

Ice Cream
American

Menu for Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe

Hand Dipped Ice Cream Cones

Single Dip Cone $2.44
Double Dip Cone $3.45
Triple Dip Cone $4.10
Kid's Cone $1.64
Soft Serve Frozen Yogurt $2.44 - $3.95
(non-fat & sugar-free)
Hartigan's Cookie Monster $2.53
IIIy Caffe Of Italy $0.00
cappucinno, latte, espresso, mocha
Hand Dipped Take-Home Ice Cream $3.62 - $13.49

Hartigan's Soda Fountain

Home-Made Milk Shakes $3.95 - $4.25
choose any delicious flavor
Old-Fashioned Malts $3.95 - $4.25
choose any delicious flavor
The Original Black Cow $3.49 - $3.75
shhh... "this is a root beer float"
Hartigan's Old-Fashioned Soda: $3.49 - $3.75
try this... & step back in time
Sherbet Coolers $3.49 - $3.75
our sherbets are really fantastic. best you'll ever
Sunset Cooler $3.95 - $4.25
raspberry sherbet mixed with fresh squeezed lemonade
Creamsicle Cooler $3.95 - $4.25
vanilla ice cream & orange sherbet blended together
Hartigan's Twisters: $3.95 - $4.25
soft-serve vanilla or chocolate, blended with your choice
Cappucinno Burst: $3.50 - $3.95
Mocha Burst $3.50 - $3.95
Chocolate Burst $3.50 - $3.95
ice cream or yogurt blended with crushed ice, milk & our secret syrups. we top it off with whip cream & cinnamon
Smoothies $4.15 - $4.50
yogurt or ice cream blended with fresh milk (whole or skim), crushed ice & fresh fruit toppings
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade $2.53
Cool Mountain & Sprecher Soda $1.50

Hartigan's Sundae Bar

Hartigan's Hot Fudge Sundae $4.15
choose any two flavors. go ahead.. be adventurous! we'll ladle hot fudge over your ice cream and top it off with real whip cream, mixed nuts & cherries.
Terry Bets "U" Can't $6.50
on baby... c'mon in with an empty stomach for this one. we'll fill you up, and maybe a friend too. five scoops, any flavors, three toppings of your choice, brownie fingers, real whip cream, mixed nuts, & cherries perched on top.
House Boat On Wheels $4.90
hope you're hungry... this banana split is so good it'll send you right over board. three scoops, any flavors, & three toppings all laying over a banana in a boat. it's over flowing with gobs of whip cream, nuts & cherries. you might need a life jacket for this one
Evanston Express Sundae $4.75
purist at heart? this one's for you... three delicious scoops of new york vanilla ice cream, hot fudge heaped on top, and real whip cream, nuts, & cherries. it will get you there on time
Marcia's Matterhorn $4.75
we have our own swiss alp right in evanston. three scoops of chocolate chip, cookies 'n cream, & mint chocolate chips are climbing high, with tons of hot fudge cascading down her sides. look out below...nuts and cherries are rumbling on top too.
Mint Monster Sundae $4.75
three scoops of peppermint, mint chocolate chip, & after dinner mint, heaped high with hot fudge & loads or orea cookies, whip cream & cherries. not for the faint of heart!
Terry's Turtle Sundae $4.75
two scoops of praline pecan on a bed of fresh pecans, with hot fudge & caramel swirling on top. real whip cream, nuts & cherries finish it off
S'more Sundae Please $4.50
two scoops of butter brittle, hot fudge, caramel, marshmallow, & a fist full of graham cracker crumbs. whip cream & cherries make it sinfully delicious
Brownie Ala Mode $4.50
calling all chocolate lovers... two scoops of ice cream laying on a rich, chocolate brownie. we'll pour hot fudge on top, & whip cream, nuts, and cherries. satisfied? you bet!
Banana Royale $4.50
we'll slice & dice up a banana & pour it over two scoops of ice cream, any kind your heart desires. hot fudge, real whip cream, nuts, & cherries follow quickly. it's yummy in your tummy
Marshmallow Sundae $4.15
traditionalists beware... this is pure heaven. two scoops of chocolate, mounds of marshmallow, & real whip cream with cherries on top
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae $4.50
this is more exciting than a trip to the zoo... we'll put two scoops of elephant tracks in a huge dish, than we'll gob on the hot fudge & reeses peanut butter cups, whip cream, nuts & cherries. you'll be roaring loudly after this one...
Krazy Kookie Sundae $4.50
two scoops of cookies 'n cream, dripping with hot fudge, & oreo cookies sprinkled on top. oh yeah... whip cream & cherries too. outstanding!
Baby Turtle Sundae $3.55
just as delicious with one scoop

Menu for Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Reviews for Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe

Ratings and Reviews for Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe

Feb 08 2012

Hanna D. via Yelp

I love Hartigans! Marcia the owner is one of the sweetest women I have ever met, she truely cares about her business & has put her whole heart into it. The...read more
Nov 15 2011

Jennifer L. via Yelp

I've been going to Hartigan's for the last 6 or 7 years and the ice cream is of the highest quality. In fact I can not name another ice cream that tastes...read more
Jun 25 2011

Jennifer B. via Yelp

If you are looking for good ice cream with a side of 1985....come to Hartigan's! It's like time stands still in there. It's definitely an old-school ice...read more
Feb 19 2009

CSMobileUser via Citysearch

The best ice cream on the north shore hands down ...read more
Aug 15 2008

via Citysearch

Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe is an old fashioned ice cream parlor on Central Street in Evanston that the whole family will love to ...read more

Map of Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe

View larger map and get directions

Own Hartgan's Ice Cream Shoppe? Update your menu online!