Too Jay's

3501 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34239
(941) 362-3692

Main

Fresh Deli Meats

priced by the 1/2 pound

$5.25
Corned Beef

$5.25
Turkey Breast

$5.25
Turkey Pastrami

$3.50
Liverwurst

$3.25
Knockwurst

$3.75
Genoa Salami

$5.25
Brisket of Beef

$3.25
Deli Franks

$5.25
Roast Beef

consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

$6.50
Tongue

$3.75
Ham

$5.25
Pastrami

$6.25
Hard Salami

$3.50
Beef Salami

Fresh Fish Favorites

priced by the 1/2 pound. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

$11.50
Baked Salmon

$13.75
Nova Salmon

$11.50
Sable

$5.95
Clubs

$5.95
Whitefish

$7.50
Whitefish Salad

$16.95
Sturgeon

Sidelines

$4.75
Basket of Onion Rings

$1.25
Small Order Fries

$2.50
Basket of French Fries

$1.75
Cole Slaw

$1.75
Potato Salad

$1.75
Fresh Fruit

$1.50
Applesauce

$1.50
Low-Fat Cottage Cheese

$1.75
Bagel & Cream Cheese

$2.25
Toojay's Famous Knish

The Bakery

all of our desserts are made from scratch using only the freshest of ingredients.

$1.95
Tallhouse Squares

$3.75
Chocolate Layer Cake

$3.75
Banana Dream

toojay's featured item

$3.75
Carrot Cake

$2.65
Napoleon

$2.35
Chocolate Eclairs

$3.75
Killer Cake

toojay's featured item

$3.75
Cheesecake

$3.25
Key Lime Pie

$2.25
Rice Pudding

$1.65
Brownie

$1.35
3 Mini Black & Whites

$1.95
Rugalach (3)

$3.75
Chocolate Cheese Delight

$5.25
Toojay's Ultimate Combination

slices of our three most popular cakes banana dream, carrot and chocolate layer combine to create the ultimate dessert. Perfect for sharing.

Specialty Salads

priced by the 1/2 pound

$7.50
Shrimp Salad

$4.75
Dill Chicken Salad

$1.50
Potato Pancakes

$1.50
Pickles (1 Lb.)

$1.50
Pickled Tomatoes (1 Lb.)

$2.75
Stuffed Cabbage

$2.25
Potato Knishes

$4.25
Greek Olives (1 Lb.)

$1.95
Blintz (Uncooked)

$1.25
Cole Slaw

$1.25
Potato Salad

$3.25
Fruit Salad

$4.25
Hummus

$4.25
Tabouleh

$1.75
Cream Cheese

$4.75
Dijon Chicken Salad

$4.75
Mandarin Chicken Salad

$4.75
Tuna Salad

$7.50
Whitefish Salad

$2.95
Egg Salad

$3.25
Chopped Liver

Freshly Baked Breads

$2.09
Loaf of Rye (1 Lb.)

$2.09
Whole Wheat (1 Lb.)

$2.09
Loaf of Challah

$0.75
Bagels

$3.49
Half Dozen Bagels

Fresh Baked Pastries and Desserts

Slice
Whole
$3.75
$16.00
Cheesecake

$3.75
$16.00
Carrot Cake

$3.75
$16.00
Killer Cake

$3.75
$16.00
Banana Dream

$3.75
$16.00
Chocolate Layer Cake

$3.75
$16.00
Chocolate Cheese Delight

Ea.
$1.75
Danish (Cheese or Prune)

$2.35
Eclairs

$1.95
Tollhouse Squares

$4.25
Rice Pudding (1 Lb.)

$1.75
Muffins

Slice
Whole
$3.25
$11.50
Key Lime Pie

$5.25
Toojay's Ultimate Combination

slices of our three most popular cakes banana dream, carrot and chocolate layer combine to create the ultimate dessert. Perfect for sharing.

$4.50
Rugalach (1/2 Lb.)

Ea.
$2.65
Napoleon

$1.65
Brownies

$1.35
Large Black & Whites

$3.25
Mini Black & Whites (1/2 Lb.)

Starters

$6.95
Shrimp Salad

$5.75
Smoked Whitefish Salad

$4.75
Hummus

$7.50
Combination Platter

toojay's featured items loaded potato skins, crispy chicken tenders and beer battered onion rings.

$6.25
Toojay's California Roll

pinwheel slices of turkey, tabouleh and cream cheese rolled in a soft tortilla.

$4.75
Fruit Plate

$4.75
Tabouleh

$6.50
Blintzes

$3.50
Half Order

$4.75
Stuffed Cabbage

$7.75
Chicken Quesadilla

$6.50
Chicken Fingers

$6.50
Buffalo Chicken Fingers

toojay's featured items

$4.75
Potato Pancakes

$4.75
Beer Battered Onion Rings

$5.75
Potato Skins

$4.25
Chopped Chicken Liver

Salads

$8.95
Shrimp Salad Platter

toojay's featured items

$7.75
Stuffed Tomato

$7.95
Tuna Salad Platter

toojay's featured items

$7.95
Mandarin Chicken Salad Platter

$7.95
Dijon Chicken Salad Platter

$7.75
Smoked Whitefish Salad Platter

$7.95
Dill Chicken Salad Platter

$5.95
Traditional Caesar Salad

$7.95
Traditional Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken

$8.50
Mandarin Chicken Salad

white breast of chicken, mandarin oranges and sweet red grapes tossed in a tangy tropical dressing served atop a bowl of fresh mixed salad greens.

$7.95
Toojay's Chopped Salad

$8.50
T.J.'s Trio

generous scoops of our popular dill chicken, tuna and dijon chicken salads served on a bed of lettuce garnished with fresh vegetables. Substitute shrimp salad for any scoop add $1.00

$8.50
Crispy Chicken Salad

lightly breaded chicken tenders fried to a crisp golden brown and served atop fresh romaine & garden vegetables.

$7.95
Chef Salad

$6.75
Egg Salad Platter

$7.95
Greek Salad

$9.95
Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken

Our Healthy Corner

$7.50
Turkey Burger Platter

$7.95
Lite Chicken Platter

$7.75
Turkey Caesar Wrap

$7.95
Greek Wrap

toojay's featured items

$7.75
Tuna Salad Pita or Wrap

$7.75
Vegetable Lasagna

vegetarian items

$7.75
Wraps & Pitas Toojay's California Wrap

fresh roasted turkey, tabouleh and a touch of cream cheese, rolled in a soft tortilla served with fresh fruit.

$7.75
Roasted Vegetable Wrap

vegetarian items

$7.50
Veggie Pita Pocket

vegetarian items

$8.95
Shrimp Salad Pita or Wrap

toojay's featured items

$8.25
Chicken Caesar Pita or Wrap

$7.75
Turkey Platter

$7.50
Garden Burger Platter

vegetarian items

$7.50
Mediterranean Health Trio

toojay's featured items tabouleh, hummus and fresh fruit salad, served with pita bread.

$6.95
California Fruit Salad

$7.75
Portobello Mushroom Stack

vegetarian items

$6.75
Garden Vegetable Pizza

vegetarian items fresh vegetables baked on a pita crust topped with provolone and parmesan cheeses.

Deli Classic Combinations

$8.50
Triple J

toojay's featured items corned beef, roast beef, turkey & Swiss cheese rolled with lots of cole slaw & Russian dressing.Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you h

$8.50
Turkey Reuben

served with French fries

$8.50
Toojay's Ultimate Brisket

freshly braised brisket with onions, horseradish sauce & muenster cheese served on grilled rye bread with French fries.

$8.25
Combo Deli Platter

your choice of 3 meats served with cole slaw, potato salad & choice of bread.

$8.50
Rachel

served with French fries.

$8.50
Reuben

toojay's featured items served with French fries

$7.95
The J & J

roast beef, turkey, cole slaw and Russian dressing. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

$7.95
Toojay's Classic

corned beef & pastrami. Add a smear of chopped liver $0.50

$8.50
Your Creation, Your Combination

create your ultimate deli sandwich. If you can think of it, we can make it.

Sandwiches

all sandwiches served with cole slaw, dill pickle & dressings on your choice of freshly baked rye, whole wheat, challah, bagel or deli roll. Add your choice of cheese to any sandwich $0.50 add a side of fries to any sandwich 1.25

$6.50
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato

$7.50
Tuna Salad

$8.95
Shrimp Salad

toojay's featured item

$6.50
Egg Salad

$6.95
Genoa Salami & Provolone

$6.75
Chopped Liver

$7.95
Nova Salmon on a Bagel

consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

$7.50
Dijon Chicken Salad

$7.95
Whitefish Salad Sandwich

$7.50
Dill Chicken Salad

$7.50
Roast Sirloin of Beef

consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

$7.75
Brisket of Beef

$7.50
Smoked Ham, Brie & Onion

$6.95
Beef Salami

$8.50
Tongue

$7.95
Hard Salami

$6.95
Liverwurst

$6.95
Smoked Ham & Swiss

$7.50
Hot Corned Beef

toojay's featured item

$7.50
Hot Pastrami

$7.95
The Italiano

ham, genoa salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato & onion on a fresh roll with italian dressing.

$7.75
Turkey

$7.95
Turkey & Chopped Liver

$7.75
Turkey Pastrami

$7.95
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato

Specialty Soups

all of our soups are made from scratch, using only the freshest ingredients. All soups available by the quart.

Bowl
Cup
$3.25
$2.50
Soup of the Day

$3.25
$2.50
Chicken Noodle Soup

$3.50
$2.50
Matzo Ball Soup

toojay's featured item

$3.75
Crock of French Onion Soup

Bowl
Cup
$3.75
$2.95
Chili

Fish Platters

all of our smoked fish is hand sliced to order ensuring the best quality. Platters are served with fresh bagel, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, olives & lemon.

$10.95
Nova Salmon

toojay's featured item

$10.95
Smoked Whitefish

$11.50
Kippered Salmon

$11.50
Nova & Whitefish

$11.50
Whitefish & Kippered Salmon

$11.50
Nova & Kippered Salmon

Toojay's Melts and More

$6.25
Grilled Cheese with Bacon & Tomato

$6.75
Franks & Beans

$7.95
Philly Cheese Steak

$7.75
Open Faced Turkey Melt

$7.75
Chicken Quesadilla

$7.50
Hot Ham & Swiss

$7.50
Chicken Fingers

buffalo style or original. Toojay's featured item

$7.95
Tuna Melt

toojay's featured item

$7.95
Meatloaf Melt

$6.50
Blintzes

$7.95
Turkey Pastrami Melt

$5.75
Grilled Cheese

$7.50
Chili Dogs

toojay's featured item

$7.50
Cheddar Bacon Dogs

$7.75
Knockwurst Doubles

$7.75
Vegetable Lasagna

vegetarian item

Char-Broiled Burgers

8 oz. of lean chopped steak char-broiled to perfection and served on a fresh deli roll with French fries, cole slaw, lettuce, tomato & dill pickle.

$6.95
Jay Burger

$7.50
Cheeseburger

$7.75
Bacon Cheeseburger

$6.95
Turkey Burger

$7.75
Mushroom Swiss Burger

$7.95
Burger A La Toojay's

topped with mushrooms, bacon, and melted muenster. Toojay's featured item

$7.75
Gorgonzola Bacon Burger

$7.50
Garden Burger

vegetarian item

Grilled Chicken

tender grilled chicken breast served on a deli roll with French fries, cole slaw, lettuce, tomato and dill pickle.

$7.50
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

$7.50
Grilled Dijon Chicken Sandwich

$7.95
Chicken A La Toojay's

grilled teriyaki chicken topped with mushrooms, bacon and melted muenster cheese. Toojay's featured item

$7.50
Grilled Teriyaki Chicken Sandwich

$7.95
Hickory Chicken Sandwich

grilled chicken breast basted with barbeque sauce and topped with crisp bacon and American cheese.