Yoders Restaurant

3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota FL 34239 yodersrestaurant.com (941) 955-7771

Cuisines and Dishes at Yoders Restaurant:

American

Menu for Yoders Restaurant

Salads, Soups, etc.

COBB SALAD $8.95
Chopped turkey, egg, peas, bacon, cheese, tomato. Layered on a bed of crisp lettuce. Our customers' favorite!
ASIAN CHICKEN SALAD $8.95
Crisp lettuce, mandarin oranges, almonds, chow mein noodles with breaded or grilled chicken breast. Served with fruit bread.
CHEF SALAD $7.95
Crisp lettuce in a bowl, choice of chopped turkey or ham, cheese, egg, tomato and cucumbers.
BREADED OR GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD $8.95
Your choice, breaded chicken tenders or grilled chicken breast sliced on top of crisp lettuce with all the trimmings. Served with homemade fruit bread.
TACO SALAD $8.50
Bowl of crisp lettuce with onion, cheese, tomato, served with hot chili meat over the top.
STUFFED TOMATO $6.95
With your choice of chicken or tuna salad on a bed of crisp lettuce.
VEGETABLE PLATE $6.50
Choice of three side dishes and homemade bread. Add a fourth side for 1.50.
AMISH QUESADILLAS $8.95
Grilled tortilla with chicken, cheese and fresh mushrooms served with salsa and sour cream.
Homemade Dressings
French (our house), Thousand Island, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Herb & Spice, Oil & Vinegar Additional Dressing Add $0.75
Fat-Free Dressings
Raspberry Vinaigrette, Catalina French, Italian

Soups

HOMEMADE SOUP OF THE DAY $3.25 - $4.25
HOMEMADE CHILI $3.75 - $4.75
Mom's recipe
CUP OF SOUP AND HALF SANDWICH $6.95
Tuna or Chicken Salad

Manhattans

ROAST BEEF, TURKEY OR MEATLOAF $8.50 - $7.50
on homemade bread, served with real mashed potatoes, and all smothered in our (made from stock) gravy

Side Dishes

Mashed Potatoes $2.65
w/gravy
Amish Potato Cakes $2.65
Chicken Dressing $2.65
Stuffing
French Fries $2.65
Baked Potato $2.65
after 4 p.m.
Baked Sweet Potato $2.65
after 4 p.m.
Corn Fritter Cakes $2.65
Fruit Jello $2.65
Amish Buttered Noodles $2.65
5-Bean Salad $2.65
Sliced Tomatoes $2.65
Tossed Salad $2.65
Cole Slaw $2.65
Carrot Salad $2.65
Applesauce $2.65
Buttered Corn $2.65
Green Beans $2.65
Vegetable of the Day $2.65
Fried Okra $2.65
Baked Hot Apples $2.65
Cottage Cheese $2.65
Corn Muffins $2.65
Onion Rings $2.65
add $1.00

Daily Specials - Monday

SMOKED BBQ CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Slow roasted, juicy & tender.
BEEF & NOODLES $8.50 - $6.95
PULLED SMOKED PORK $10.50 - $8.50
Smoked for hours, pulled off the bone in tender pieces. Outrageously delicious!

Daily Specials - Tuesday

BBQ PORK RIBS $9.95
A little spicy, a little sweet, a long time favorite.
BAKED CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Lightly seasoned, served with our dressing.
YODER'S CASSEROLE $8.50 - $6.95
Ground beef, noodles, vegetables all in a mushroom sauce, topped with cheese & croutons.
CHICKEN & DUMPLINGS $8.95 - $7.50

Daily Specials - Wednesday

GOULASH $8.50 - $6.95
Ground beef and macaroni in a zesty tomato sauce. Yummy!
POT ROAST & VEGETABLES $10.95
Roast is slowly braised with carrots, celery, onion & new potatoes. Comes with one side.
BAKED CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Lightly seasoned, served with our dressing.

Daily Specials - Thursday

SMOKED BBQ CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Slow roasted, juicy & tender.
SCALLOPED POTATOES $8.50 - $6.95
Potatoes & ham scalloped together for that perfect taste.
BAKED CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Lightly seasoned, served with our dressing.
CHICKEN LIVERS & DRESSING $8.95 - $7.50
Livers are lightly breaded, seasoned and pan fried, served with our dressing.

Daily Specials - Friday

CABBAGE ROLLS $8.50 - $6.95
Ground beef & sausage, rice & seasonings rolled in cabbage leaves with a light tomato sauce.
PAN FRIED CHICKEN $9.50 - $10.95
Quarter Chicken
Half Chicken $14.95 - $16.95
Just the way our grandma used to make it. Lightly seasoned, handbreaded and pan fried.
FRIED FISH $11.95
All you care to eat! Crispy, light and delicious.
PRIME RIB $13.50 - $15.50
after 4 p.m.

Daily Specials - Saturday

PULLED SMOKED PORK $10.50 - $8.50
Smoked for hours, pulled off the bone in tender pieces. Outrageously delicious!
SMOKED BBQ CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Slow roasted, juicy & tender.
BAKED CHICKEN $10.50 - $9.25
Lightly seasoned, served with our dressing.
CHICKEN LIVERS & DRESSING $8.95 - $7.50
Livers are lightly breaded, seasoned and pan fried, served with our dressing.

Hamburgers

ONE THIRD POUND FRESH GROUND BEEF BURGER $5.95

Hamburgers - BUILD YOUR OWN BURGER

AN EXTRA PATTY $3.95
AMERICAN OR SWISS CHEESE $0.75
CRISPY BACON $2.95
GRILLED ONIONS $0.75
GRILLED MUSHROOMS $0.75

Sandwiches

GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST $7.50
garlic seasoned or plain
MOM'S MEATLOAF $6.95
CHICKEN OR TUNA SALAD $5.95
FRIED FISH FILLET $5.95
CRAB CAKE SANDWICH $5.95
GRILLED CHEESE $3.95
American or Swiss
BACON, LETTUCE AND TOMATO $5.95
on toast with mayo
B.L.T. WITH SLICED TURKEY $7.50
HAM & CHEESE $6.50
served hot or cold
SLICED TURKEY BREAST $6.95
REUBEN $7.50
SLOPPY JOE $4.95
BBQ CHICKEN SANDWICH $5.50

Beverages

ORANGE OR GRAPEFRUIT JUICE $1.95 - $2.95
MILK $1.95 - $2.95
Whole or Skim
CHOCOLATE MILK $1.95 - $2.95
COKE, DIET COKE, SPRITE, ROOT BEER $1.95
free refills
PINK LEMONADE $1.95
free refills
TEA hot or iced $1.95
free refills
COFFEE OR DECAF $1.60
free refills
HOT CHOCOLATE $1.95

Desserts - Homemade Pies

CREAM PIES $3.95
Peanut Butter Cream (Customers' favorite), Chocolate Peanut Butter, Coconut Cream, Fresh Strawberry, Chocolate Cream
Homemade Butterscotch $3.95
Banana Cream $3.95
It's a winner!
Florida Key Lime $3.95
Traditional, tart and sweet with a graham crust. If it's not the best you've ever tried, we'll buy it!
Yoder's Key Lime $3.95
(Our regular) Light and fluffy in a pastry crust.
BAKED PIES $3.95
While They Last! Try your baked pie warmed up with ice cream (add $2.00)
Dutch Apple Crumb $3.95
Blueberry Crumb $3.95
Cherry $3.95
Rhubarb $3.95
Strawberry Rhubarb $3.95
Shoofly $3.95
Red Raspberry $3.95
Black Raspberry $3.95
Southern Pecan $3.95
Chocolate Pecan $3.95
Baked Peach $3.95
Pumpkin $3.95
Mom's Egg Custard $3.95
Sugar-Free Apple $3.95

Desserts

Homemade Cheesecake $4.95
Yoder's Best Chocolate Cake $3.95
Cake of the Day $3.95
Hand-dipped Ice Cream $3.50 - $4.50

Take Me Home

Regular 10" Whole Pie $16.00
serves 6-10
Smaller 8" Whole Pie $12.00
cream pies only available (serves 4-6)
Whole Cheesecake $25.00
serves 10-14
Whole Yoder's Chocolate Cake $25.00
Mom's Breakfast Sweet Rolls $7.95
Loaf of White or Wheat Bread $2.95
Homemade Apple Butter $5.50
Homemade House Dressing $5.50
Blue Cheese Dressing $7.50

Healthy Start

SPECIAL K BREAKFAST $6.25
Special K Cereal, skim milk, small orange juice, fresh fruit and coffee.
Two Egg Beaters $4.85
with toast or fruit bread
Fresh Strawberry & Banana Fruit Cup $3.50
Hot Oatmeal $2.95
Assorted Muffins $1.95

Juices and Beverages

Orange or Grapefruit Juice $1.95 - $2.50
Apple or Tomato Juice $1.95 - $2.50
Coffee or Decaf $1.60
Tea $1.95
hot or iced
Hot Chocolate $1.95
Whole or Skim Milk $1.75 - $2.25
Chocolate Milk $1.75 - $2.25

Sunrise Combination Platters

BISCUITS & GRAVY $5.95
Biscuits smothered with our hamburger or sausage gravy, served with homefries or grits.
TWO FARM FRESH EGGS $4.25 - $6.50
With homefries or grits, served with toast & jelly or fruit bread.
TWO FARM FRESH EGGS $5.95
With bacon, sausage or ham, served with toast & jelly or fruit bread.
COMBO SPECIAL $5.95
Two eggs, two mini hotcakes, bacon, sausage or ham.
FRIED CORNMEAL MUSH $4.25 - $5.25
Made from scratch, served with butter and syrup.
AMISH SCRAMBLE $4.95
Two eggs and fried potatoes scrambled together, topped with cheese, served with toast and jelly or fruit bread.
TWO EGGS SCRAMBLED $4.65
Topped with cheese, served with homefries or grits and toast & jelly or fruit bread.
LOW CARB BREAKFAST $6.25
Two scrambled eggs with cheese, bacon or sausage with fresh sliced tomato.
AMISH SCRAMBLE $6.95
Scrambled with bacon, sausage or ham, Onions or mushrooms add $0.75

And More

One egg $2.95
with toast & jelly or fruit bread
Two eggs $3.65
with toast & jelly or fruit bread
Biscuits & Gravy $4.95
Half Order Biscuits & Gravy $3.95
Homefries with Gravy $4.95
Hot Oatmeal $2.95
with Milk & Brown Sugar
Oatmeal & Hot Apples $4.95
Cold Cereal $2.95
Special K, Frosted Flakes or Raisin Bran
Fried Egg Sandwich on toast $2.95 - $5.45
Mom's Homemade Cinnamon Sweet Roll $3.25
Try it heated with butter!

Omelettes

SPINACH & MUSHROOM OMELETTE $6.95
Two egg omelette with spinach, fresh mushrooms and swiss cheese.
TWO EGG OMELETTE $6.95
With choice of two items listed below.
THREE EGG OMELETTE $7.95
With choice of three items listed below.

Country Morning French Toast Hot Cakes

FRENCH TOAST $3.95 - $5.45
a Yoder's specialty! Made with our thick sliced homemade bread, served with butter & syrup.
STUFFED FRENCH TOAST $3.95 - $6.95
Thick homemade bread stuffed with cream cheese and raspberry filling dipped in egg batter and grilled golden brown.
APPLE FRITTER FRENCH TOAST $3.95 - $5.65
with hot apples.
HOTCAKES $4.25 - $4.95
regular or whole wheat
HOTCAKES $4.95
Served with peanut butter
HOTCAKES $5.95
Served with hot apple

A La Carte

Mom's Homemade Sweet Roll $3.25
Country Homefries $2.50
Southern Grits $1.75 - $2.50
Baked Hot Apples $2.50
Two Mini Hotcakes $2.50
Homemade Toast $1.75
white, rye, wheat
Homemade Fruit Bread $1.95
Assorted Muffins $1.95
Biscuit $1.95
buttered and grilled
Bagel $1.95 - $2.95
Bacon, Sausage or Ham $2.95
Extra Egg with order $1.25
Side of Gravy $2.25 - $3.50
Egg Beaters/Whites $0.60
substituted for eggs add

Menu for Yoders Restaurant provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Other menus for Yoders Restaurant

Jump to:
Main
Dinner

Reviews for Yoders Restaurant

Ratings and Reviews for Yoders Restaurant

May 11 2012

Stacey L. via Yelp

The best! Every year we visit Siesta Key, it involves a trip to Yoder's. Never fails to disappoint. My husband says their fried chicken is the best he...read more
Apr 27 2012

Cheri P. via Yelp

The rest of this review (can't fit here) is found on my blog at: http://thewateringmouth.com/yoders-restaurant-review-sarasota-fl/ I wanted to try out...read more
Apr 23 2012

Dwayne H. via Yelp

Absolutely LOVE coming to Yoder's as this place is the ONLY true Amish cooking available in Sarasota! Yoder's is authentic Amish cooking and unlike the...read more
Nov 27 2008

via Citysearch

Great homemade cooked meals that are comfort foods. Helpings are more than generous. No meal would be complete without a piece of...read more

Map of Yoders Restaurant

View larger map and get directions

Own Yoders Restaurant? Update your menu online!