Fish Tales Market & Eatery

11711 Overseas Hwy, Marathon FL 33050 floridalobster.com (305) 743-9196

Cuisines and Dishes at Fish Tales Market & Eatery:

Seafood
American

Menu for Fish Tales Market & Eatery

Homemade Soups & Starters

Red Conch Chowder $3.50
White Lobster Bisque $4.50
Homemade Conch Fritters $4.95
Buffalo Shrimp; Or Oysters $7.95
Cracked Conch $8.95
Fried Calamari $6.95
Smoked Fish Spread $4.95

Raw Bar

Steamed Shrimp $8.95
1/2 lb.
Steamed Clams $8.95
dz.
Oysters $5.95 - $7.95
(in season)
Stone Crab Claw App. $0.00
3 medium

Salads

Conch Salad $5.95
marinated with just the right zip
Ceasar Salad $5.95
add grilled chicken or fish ($9.95)
Johnny's Salad $5.95
hand tossed romaine with johnny's special dressing

Sandwiches Or Platters

Fried Lobster Sandwich $7.95
Fried Oyster Sandwich $7.95
Grilled Of Fried Chicken Sandwich $5.95
Steak Sandwich $8.95
choice steak
Fried Fish Of The Day Sandwich $5.95
Grilled Fish Of The Day Sandwich $5.95
add wasabi or honey mustard sauce $1:00
Grilled Yellowfin Tuna Sandwich $0.00
Char-Grilled Burger $3.95
Mushroom/Onion Swiss Burger $5.95
with sauteed mushrooms & onions & melted swiss
Fried Coach Sandwich $8.95
1/4# All Beef Hot Dog $0.00
German Snapper Sandwich $7.95
fried on grilled swirled rye with cole slaw, fries & muenster cheese.
Johnny's Rambler $7.95
fried snapper on grilled rye with cheese, tomato & tarter with fries & cole slaw

Homemade Desserts

Homemade Desserts $2.95
key lime pie; crunchy chocolate peanut butter pie or our homemade mud pies (chocolate cookie crust, topped with fudge & whipped cream) choose from coffee or chocolate chip.

Drinks

Fountain Soda $1.25
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fruit Punch Or Pink Lemonade (20 Oz) Bottled Water $1.25
Proud To Serve Fresh Brewed Tender Leaf Iced Tea $1.25
Fresh Roasted Whole Bean Millstone Coffee $0.95

Draft Beer

Budweiser, Michelob Light, Coors Light $2.50 - $7.95
Key West Sunset Ale, Foster's Or Killian's Red $3.50 - $8.95

Wines

Chardonnay, White Zinfandel, Merlot, Cabemet Sauvignon $3.50

Menu for Fish Tales Market & Eatery provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Reviews for Fish Tales Market & Eatery

Ratings and Reviews for Fish Tales Market & Eatery

May 04 2012

Kayla B. via Yelp

Heard such great things about this place, and was severely disappointed. Food was cold and was tasted like it was out of a freezer. Why buy frozen fish in...read more
Mar 25 2012

Jay P. via Yelp

Fish Tales was our go-to source for fresh fish during our week stay in Marathon. Over the course of a week we purchased fresh yellowtail snapper, mutton...read more
Feb 27 2012

Budlette N. via Yelp

We are staying in the keys for a couple of weeks and on a whim decided to give this place a try. So glad we did too! The first day i had the smoked wahoo...read more

Map of Fish Tales Market & Eatery

View larger map and get directions

Own Fish Tales Market & Eatery? Update your menu online!