Dayton St Pizza

60 Dayton St
New Haven, CT 06515

(203) 389-2454

Appetizers.

  • Garlic Bread
    •  
    • $4.95
  • Garlic Bread W/Cheese
    •  
    • $5.45
  • Chicken Tenders
    •  
    • $7.25
  • (with honey mustard)
  • Jalapeno Poppers
    •  
    • $7.25
  • Bruchetta Bread
    •  
    • $7.25
  • (toasted bread served with a mix of tomatoes, oregano and onion)
  • Fried Mozzarella
    •  
    • $7.25
  • (5 sticks)
  • Fried Calamari
    •  
    • $10.25
  • (lightly battered)
  • Calamari Al Forno
    •  
    • $11.25
  • (fried calamari tossed in a spicy marinara sauce)
Soups.

  • Homemade Pasta Fagioli
    •  
    • $5.25
  • (all soups and salads come with side of bread)
Salads.

  • Garden Salad
    •  
    • $8.45
  • (fresh greens, tossed with tomato, red onion and black olives) w/chicken.
  • Caesar Salad
    •  
    • $11.50
  • (crisp romaine, freshly baked croutons, and homemade caesar dressing, topped with parmesan cheese) w/chicken.
  • Gorgonzola Salad
    •  
    • $11.50
  • (fresh greens, tossed with tomato, red onion, imported olives and gorgonzola cheese) w/chicken.
  • Fresh Mozzarella And Tomato Salad
    •  
    • $9.95
  • (fresh mozzarella and tomatoes layered on a bed of lettuce and topped with balsamic vinegar)
  • Tuna Salad
    •  
    • $9.95
  • (fresh greens, tomato, red onion and olives w/tuna)
  • Antipasto
    •  
    • $11.95
  • (salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, olives, roasted peppers, hot cherry peppers, artichoke hearts)
  • Chef Salad
    •  
    • $10.95
  • (ham, turkey, mozzarella cheese)
Specialty Sandwiches.

(All specialty sandwiches served on fresh hard roll).

  • Chicken Ceasar Sandwich
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (chicken cutlet, romaine lettuce, ceasar dressing)
  • El Panini
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (fresh mozzarella, tomato, fresh basil and olive oil)
  • Veggie Sandwich
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (grilled mushroom, eggplant, onion & roasted pepper)
  • Tuna Sandwich
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (fresh tuna piled high)
  • Turkey Special Sandwich
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (turkey, red roasted peppers, lettuce, honey dijon)
  • Chicken Cutlet Or Grilled Chicken
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (lettuce, tomato, mayo)
  • Hamburger Classic
    •  
    • $6.95
  • (lettuce, tomato, mayo & slice of onion)
Club Sandwiches.

(All club sandwiches served with bacon lettuce & tomato). (All sandwiches served with a pickle)

  • BLT Club
    •  
    • $7.75
  • Turkey Club
    •  
    • $7.75
  • Hamburger Club
    •  
    • $7.75
  • Ham Club
    •  
    • $7.75
  • Tuna Club
    •  
    • $7.75
Hot Subs.

  • Meatball
    •  
    • $7.45
  • Sausage
    •  
    • $7.45
  • Sausage, Pepper And Onion
    •  
    • $7.75
  • (no sauce)
  • Chicken Parmigiana
    •  
    • $7.75
  • Eggplant Parmigiana
    •  
    • $7.75
  • Steak & Cheese
    •  
    • $7.45
  • (add fresh mushrooms, peppers, onions - each item) $0.35
  • BLT
    •  
    • $7.45
  • Veggie
    •  
    • $7.45
  • Pepper & Egg
    •  
    • $7.45
  • Hamburger Sub
    •  
    • $7.45
  • BBQ Steak
    •  
    • $7.75
  • (steak w/ tangy bbq sauce)
  • Buffalo Chicken
    •  
    • $7.75
  • (hot sauce & bleu cheese)
  • Broccoli Rabe & Chicken Cutlet
    •  
    • $7.95
  • Chicken Cutlet
    •  
    • $7.75
  • (you pick the toppings)
Cold Subs.

  • Ham And Cheese
    •  
    • $7.25
  • Salami And Cheese
    •  
    • $7.25
  • Turkey
    •  
    • $7.25
  • Tuna
    •  
    • $7.75
  • El Panini
    •  
    • $7.75
  • (fresh mozzarella tomato, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil)
  • Italian Combo
    •  
    • $7.75
  • (salami, ham & pepperoni)
Specialtty Pies.

  • (Large)
  • (Med.)
  • (Sm.)
  • Fresh Clams
    •  
    • $22.95
    • $19.25
    • $13.25
  • Clam Casino
    •  
    • $25.95
    • $22.95
    • $15.25
  • (pepper, bacon, onion, garlic)
  • Jumbo Shrimp
    •  
    • $27.95
    • $23.95
    • $17.95
  • Shrimp Casino
    •  
    • $30.95
    • $26.95
    • $19.95
  • (pepper, bacon, onion garlic)
  • Broccoli Rabe
    •  
    • $22.95
    • $19.25
    • $13.25
  • Veggie
    •  
    • $22.95
    • $19.25
    • $13.25
  • (onion, pepper, mushroom, olive)
  • Margherita
    •  
    • $18.25
    • $16.25
    • $11.95
  • (white w/crushed plum tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil)
  • The Works
    •  
    • $23.95
    • $21.95
    • $14.75
  • (pepperoni, meatball, sausage, bacon, onion, mushroom, pepper)
  • Primavera
    •  
    • $18.25
    • $16.95
    • $11.95
  • (white w/artichoke hearts, roasted red pepper, basil and garlic)
  • Hawaiian
    •  
    • $18.25
    • $16.95
    • $11.95
  • (ham and pineapple)
  • Chicken & Broccoli
    •  
    • $18.25
    • $16.95
    • $11.95
  • (with white sauce)
  • Cousin Artie
    •  
    • $18.25
    • $16.95
    • $11.95
  • (grated cheese, anchovies, onions, garlic)
Calzones.

  • (Large)
  • (Small)
  • Calzones
    •  
    • $14.25
    • $9.95
  • stuffed with mozzarella and ricotta cheese
  • Additional Items
    •  
    • $2.25
    • $1.75
Stuffed Breads.

(All calzones and stuffed breads come with sauce on the side.)

  • Pepperoni
    •  
    • $9.95
  • Spinach
    •  
    • $9.95
  • Broccoli
    •  
    • $9.95
  • Eggplant
    •  
    • $9.95
  • Broccoli Rabe
    •  
    • $10.95
  • Ham And Sliced Tomato
    •  
    • $10.95
  • Chicken
    •  
    • $9.95
  • Chicken & Broccoli
    •  
    • $10.95
Specialty Pasta Dishes.

(Served with side salad & bread)

  • Dayton Street Gnocchies
    •  
    • $12.95
  • (potato pasta with a blend of sauce and three cheeses)
  • Penne Ala Vodka
    •  
    • $14.95
  • (creamy vodka sauce)
  • Penne Carbonara
    •  
    • $14.95
  • (creamy sauce with bacon)
  • Penne Rosa
    •  
    • $15.95
  • (grilled chicken, mushrooms, onions, fresh tomatoes in a light pink cream sauce)
  • Chicken Primavera
    •  
    • $15.95
  • (penne, grilled chicken, broccoli, sun dried tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic and olive oil)
  • Puttanesca
    •  
    • $14.95
  • anchovies, black olives and capers in a marinara sauce
  • Tuscan Shrimp
    •  
    • $15.95
  • (shrimp sauteed with artichoke hearts, sundried tomatoes & fresh basil)
  • Spaghetti With White Clam Sauce
    •  
    • $15.95
  • (chopped clams, fresh parsley, lemon and garlic)
  • Fra Diavolo
    •  
    • $16.95
  • (shrimp, calamari and clams in a spicy tomato sauce)
  • Cavattelli W/Broccoli
    •  
    • $14.95
  • (broccoli, olive oil & garlic)
  • Ziti W/Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
    •  
    • $15.95
  • (broccoli rabe, sausage & hot cherry peppers)
  • Lobster Ravioli
    •  
    • $17.95
  • (lobster ravioli tossed with vodka sauce) (penne and spaghetti always available)
Dayton St Wings.

All wings served with blue cheese.

  • Dayton St Wings
    •  
    • $7.75
  • 1 mild, 2 hot, 3 meltdown, 4 bbq, 5 spicy bbq, 6 honey bbq, 7 spicy honey bbq, 8 sweet n sour, 9 cajun, 10 teriyaki, 11 honey dijon mustard
Apizza.

(12" - Sm., 16" - med., 18" - large)

  • (Large)
  • (Med.)
  • (Sm.)
  • Mozzarella
    •  
    • $14.95
    • $13.95
    • $9.95
  • Pepperoni
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Meatball
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Sausage
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Bacon
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Onion
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Mushrooms
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Peppers
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Olives
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Spinach
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Broccoli
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Artichoke Hearts
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Roasted Peppers
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Anchovies
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Eggplant
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Sundried Tomatoes
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Chicken
    •  
    • $17.45
    • $15.95
    • $10.95
  • Additional Items
    •  
    • $2.65
    • $2.45
    • $1.65
Side Orders.

  • French Fries
    •  
    • $3.25
  • add cheese for fries $1.05
  • Cajun Fries
    •  
    • $4.75
  • Meatballs
    •  
    • $5.25
  • Sausage
    •  
    • $5.25
Desserts.

  • New York Cheesecake
    •  
    • $5.45
  • (with a cherry on top)
Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream.

  • (Pints)
  • Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream
    •  
    • $6.25
  • ask for flavors, changing all the time
Beverages.

  • Foxon Park
    •  
  • (all flavors), coke, sprite, diet coke, orange, ginger ale, snapple, spring water

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us click here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Legal Notices.